Skip to content

supervisor: requests #656

Open
Open

Description

@cgwalters-bot

The supervisor agent's item (tracker#626): each run posts its typed action requests here as JSON, and the executor in supervisor.yml performs only the ones .github/supervisor/actions.cjs admits. Not for discussion.

Generated-by: https://github.com/cgwalters/#llms

Activity

  1. github-actions commented on Oct 16, 2026

    @github-actions

    ✅ supervisor ended well. Result: #656 (comment)

  2. cgwalters-bot commented on Oct 16, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type": "supervisor_action", "action": "comment", "repository": "cgwalters-forge/agentic-job", "item": 882, "body": "PR cgwalters-forge/tracker#883 (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/pull/883) merged the ranked plan as docs/plan.md and the first piece of slice 1: secure-host's setup and probe steps now run `agentic-job sandbox timed` instead of `node workflow/setup-timing.mjs --run`. Still left for this issue: the rest of slice 1, which is porting world-write.mjs (root's bpftool loader, which needs a privileged CI run to prove) and platform.mjs, apt.mjs and binary.mjs (which run before the binary exists) into Rust. After that come the later slices ranked in docs/plan.md, starting with installing agents from pinned, checksummed tarballs instead of the distribution's npm. The PR measured no real-run timing and notes that this piece saves almost no time, since hosted images ship Node."}
    {"type": "supervisor_action", "action": "comment", "repository": "cgwalters-forge/agentic-job", "item": 854, "body": "PR cgwalters-forge/tracker#861 (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/pull/861) merged `agentic-job handback check` and the shorter brief. Together they cover patch shape, protected paths, output schemas, the secret scan and outcome validity in-session. One part is still left: the per-output limits that gh-aw's handlers enforce at apply, such as link count, body length and mentions. The PR notes that a field gh-aw's collector would refuse is still found only after the session, and main has no link-count check. That gap is how research run https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/38873013355 (#719) failed with E008 (54 links, 50 allowed), as the comment above says. The validator should apply those limits with the handler's own values and name the limit that was exceeded, so the agent can trim or split. Smaller follow-ups the PR left open: the scratch checkout copy under $TMPDIR has no bound, and no test covers `run` installing handback.json or the CLI's exit status."}
    {"type": "supervisor_action", "action": "comment", "repository": "cgwalters-forge/operator", "item": 2, "body": "Supervisor pass of 2026-10-16 15:00 UTC (checks failing: queue, dependabot, stuck, failures, held, unclosed). Decisions for the operator, recommended option first:\n\n1. Unclosed issues whose merged PR did what they ask. A: close each with its PR link. B: leave open.\n- agentic-job#855 by https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/pull/860 (review and dispatch with a key, early key check, v0.5.2 pin, the P2 docs and detection skip).\n- agentic-job#853 by https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/pull/859 (re-scoped: the tools were never disabled; the prompt now asks for edit tools, plus a claude-acp CI job). The PR did not check agenthome's opencode config for disabled edit tools; check it separately if that matters.\n- agentic-job#845 by https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/pull/849 (v0.5.2 is released, 08:37 UTC).\nagentic-job#882 (PR cgwalters-forge/tracker#883) and agentic-job#854 (PR cgwalters-forge/tracker#861) have work left; this pass comments what is left on each.\n\n2. Stuck plan on tracker#455: the plan recorded at https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/issues/455#issuecomment-6208032079 (item 3, agent-board README positioning) ran as https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/38850381002 and merged as https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agent-board/pull/95. That PR used Refs on purpose: tracker#455 (items 1 and 2) and agent-board#19 still have open work. A: keep both issues open and dispatch a triage run on tracker#455 so its record reflects that item 3 is done and the scheduler stops skipping the finished plan. B: close tracker#455 and track items 1 and 2 in tracker#596 and the linked agentic-job/agent-board issues.\n\n3. Failed research run https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/38873013355 on agentic-job#719: apply refused its comment with E008 (54 links, max 50). The controller already posted the report by hand in two parts on agentic-job#719 at 08:34 UTC. A: do not dispatch it again; the failures check will keep listing it until a newer research run on agentic-job#719 exists or it ages out of the lookback. B: dispatch it again with fewer than 50 links in the task. The lasting fix is the link-limit validation still missing from agentic-job#854.\n\n4. Held https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/pull/618 (needs-human since 2026-10-15 13:06 UTC). The reason still applies: the PR conflicts with main (merge state DIRTY), and the fix run found it cannot pass its own new workflows-check without a maintainer-approved trusted-trigger zizmor exception. Using pull_request instead would let proposals replace their required gate, which defeats the PR's purpose. A: decide whether to approve that narrowly reviewed trusted-trigger exception on main first, then remove the label so the poll can start fresh fix rounds. B: close the PR and re-plan the checker rollout as an operator-led change.\n\nNo action needed:\n- Queue: agentic-job#860, cgwalters-forge/tracker#829, cgwalters-forge/tracker#814, cgwalters-forge/tracker#777, cgwalters-forge/tracker#740, cgwalters-forge/tracker#741, cgwalters-forge/tracker#698, cgwalters-forge/tracker#641, cgwalters-forge/tracker#640 and cgwalters-forge/tracker#657 all left the merge queue on failed_checks or merge_conflict, and each merged on a later attempt. The failed merge-group jobs varied: session-sandbox api_key test, a sandbox probe, the confined-step docker control probe, secure-host's report step and a GitHub 502. That mix looks like intermittent CI rather than one cause. Worth watching if the same job keeps repeating.\n- Dependabot: agentic-job#631 was closed as superseded by agentic-job#633, which merged on 2026-10-15.\n- Broker and pace observations have been unavailable since 14:53 UTC, under an hour, so this pass asks for nothing about them. The broker-probe runs since at least 2026-10-15 20:21 UTC all ended skipped, which suggests the probe is switched off. A later pass will ask about it if it stays unavailable."}
    

    Comment on agentic-job#882. Its implement PR cgwalters-forge/agentic-job#883 merged with only the first piece of slice 1, so the issue stays open (unclosed check). The comment records what is left.

    Comment on agentic-job#854. cgwalters-forge/agentic-job#861 merged the in-session validator, but it does not enforce gh-aw's per-output limits. That gap caused the E008 failure of https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/38873013355 (failures check). The comment records what is left.

    Comment on the supervisor log (operator#2). It lists the operator's decisions: closing agentic-job#855, #853 and #845 after their merged PRs #860, #859 and #849; the finished plan on #455 (stuck check, merged as cgwalters-forge/agent-board#95); whether to dispatch the #719 research again (recommended: no, the report was already posted by hand); and the hold on cgwalters-forge/agentic-job#618 (held check; still conflicted and waiting on a trusted-trigger decision). It also records why the queue and dependabot failures need no action: every listed PR merged later, and cgwalters-forge/agentic-job#631 was superseded by the merged #633.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  3. cgwalters-bot commented on Oct 16, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type": "supervisor_action", "action": "comment", "repository": "cgwalters-forge/operator", "item": 2, "body": "Supervisor pass of 2026-10-16 15:27 UTC, adding to the 15:00 UTC pass on this issue. Its four decisions (closing agentic-job#855, cgwalters-forge/tracker#853 and cgwalters-forge/tracker#845; the stuck plan on tracker#455; the E008 research run on agentic-job#719; the hold on agentic-job#618) still stand as asked, and nothing about them has changed since. This pass adds one new decision and one answer.\n\n1. Idle scheduler (new). The last two passes, https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/38921652252 and https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/38920661945, each ended with 7 slots free and nothing started. The largest share of skips, 6 of 22, is needs design: open sub-issues with no plan. The log does not name them. By elimination against the epics' open sub-issues they are agentic-job#114 (threat-detection job), agentic-job#119 (memory across runs), agentic-job#120 (other MCP servers and Playwright), tracker#517 (harness gaps), tracker#603 (broker by one name and outage detection) and agenthome#8 (move procedures into skills). Most other skips are expected and need no action: umbrellas, open pull requests, items in repositories the scheduler does not follow, a blocker, and a research plan that is dispatched by hand. The remaining skip is the tracker#455 plan from decision 2 of the earlier pass. A: dispatch a triage run on each of those six issues so each gets a plan, or a research run where the design is open (agentic-job#114, cgwalters-forge/tracker#119, cgwalters-forge/tracker#120). Agent dispatches stay manual until a durable cost cap is enforced. B: leave them unplanned and accept idle slots for now.\n\n2. Answer to the open point on agentic-job#853. agenthome main has no opencode config yet. The pending https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agenthome/pull/10 denies edit only to the read-only subagents (general reviewer, explore, fast). The primary build agent keeps its edit tools, and the top-level permission is allow. That is consistent with the operator's rule not to limit tools, so it does not block closing agentic-job#853.\n\nUnchanged: the queue and dependabot evidence is all merged or superseded. Broker and pace observations have been unavailable since 14:53 UTC, still under an hour. broker-probe.yml runs only when the BROKER_OUTAGE variable is apply, which explains its skipped runs. A later pass will ask about it if it stays unavailable."}
    

    Comment on the log issue (operator#2). The only new failing check since the 15:00 UTC pass is idle. Passes 38921652252 and 38920661945 each left 7 slots free. Six skips were needs design, which by elimination are agentic-job#114, #119 and #120, tracker#517 and #603, and agenthome#8. The playbook makes dispatching triage or research runs the operator's decision, so this asks for it. The comment also settles what the earlier pass left open on agentic-job#853: agenthome#10 denies edit only to read-only subagents.

    No other action. The previous pass's requests already cover the rest of today's checks, and its comments on agentic-job#882 and agentic-job#854 were posted at 15:03 UTC.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  4. cgwalters-bot commented on Oct 16, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type": "supervisor_action", "action": "comment", "repository": "cgwalters-forge/agentic-job", "item": 821, "body": "PR cgwalters-forge/tracker#826 (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/pull/826) did steps 2 to 4: a per-model `[agent.context-windows]` table for the main agent and the child, compaction at three quarters of the window, today's 32768/24576 kept as the fallback, and `config check` refusing a window outside 1..=1,048,576, with tests. The output cap is unchanged. Tracker commit https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/commit/fcd04513e48bd9781d755012488d71331fd3503e then set `\"zai-glm-5-3\" = 131072` in hosted.toml and acp-experiment.toml. Still left from step 1: confirm the window that the broker's provider really serves for zai-glm-5-3. GLM-5.3 documents 1M, but nobody has confirmed the served value, and 131072 is a conservative guess. If the provider serves 128,000, it leaves only about 3% headroom over the compaction point plus v0.5.2's 32,000 output cap, so lower the window or max_output_tokens. After that, re-run the cgwalters-forge/tracker#813 experiment (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/issues/813) at the new window, as this issue asks, to compare compaction counts and see whether the hand-back appears unprompted."}
    {"type": "supervisor_action", "action": "comment", "repository": "cgwalters-forge/operator", "item": 2, "body": "Supervisor pass of 2026-10-16 ~18:45 UTC. It adds to the 15:00 and 15:27 UTC passes on this issue. Their decisions on tracker#455 (stuck), agentic-job#719 (E008 research run), agentic-job#618 (held) and the idle needs-design issues still stand unchanged, so this pass does not repeat them. Since then, agenthome#8 has received a triage plan (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agenthome/issues/8#issuecomment-6219545410), and it waits for a dispatch by hand. Recommended options are listed first.\n\n1. Unclosed issues (new). A: close each one with its PR link. B: leave them open.\n- agentic-job#724 by https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/pull/728. Setup installs the pinned Vibe whenever either agent needs it, config check refuses unsupported children, and docs/harness.md covers shared-token Mistral authorization. A test covers a non-Vibe main agent with a Vibe child. A real install of a Vibe child was left to CI.\n- agentic-job#720 by https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/pull/725 (in-session `handback scan` with file, line and pattern, plus the brief's guidance) and https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/pull/941 (closing #918). With #941, a credential-shaped string now warns instead of refusing. That makes moot what was left of item 3: reporting the location of a final refusal, and keeping the refused patch.\nagentic-job#821 (PR cgwalters-forge/tracker#826) still has work left, and this pass comments what remains on it. The comments on agentic-job#882 and cgwalters-forge/tracker#854 were posted at 15:03 UTC.\n\n2. Broker probe switched off. The broker observation has been unavailable since 14:53 UTC. Every broker-probe.yml run in the listing ended skipped, the latest being https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/38931210276, because the job runs only when the tracker variable BROKER_OUTAGE is apply (README, Broker outages). A: set BROKER_OUTAGE=apply on cgwalters-forge/tracker, so outages get detected and the supervisor's broker and infrastructure checks have data. B: keep it off on purpose. In that case the broker check will keep failing as unavailable, and you may want a reviewed change to health.cjs that reports a probe switched off on purpose as ok. This pass asks once and will not repeat it.\n\n3. Pace observation stale. Pace has been unavailable since 14:53 UTC. usage.yml is scheduled every 15 minutes, but GitHub ran it only about every four hours today (successful runs at 04:19, 09:06, 13:55 and 17:56 UTC, for example https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/38943569966). The health pass treats a snapshot older than usageStaleMinutes (45) as unavailable, so pace is blind most of the time. The supervisor agent's token cannot read cgwalters-forge/bot-ops, so this pass could not confirm the snapshot's own timestamp. A: have a reviewed change trigger the usage publish from a workflow that runs reliably, such as a workflow_dispatch from poll.yml, which runs every few minutes. B: raise usageStaleMinutes to match the observed cadence and accept a slower pace signal. C: leave it as it is. This pass asks once and will not repeat it.\n\nNo action needed: the queue's new evidence (agentic-job#926 and #927 merged, and #940 is back in the merge queue with its checks green) follows the same pattern as before. The failed merge-group jobs were intermittent, not one cause: the confined-step docker control probe, e2e runs whose queue branch was removed, an egress-git sandbox check, a session port-bind test, and one real test failure on cgwalters-forge/tracker#829 that was fixed before it merged."}
    

    Comment on agentic-job#821 (unclosed check). PR cgwalters-forge/tracker#826 and tracker commit fcd0451 did steps 2 to 4. The served context window for zai-glm-5-3 is still unconfirmed, and the #813 re-run hasn't happened. The comment records both.

    Comment on the log issue (operator#2). It asks only about what is new since the 15:00 and 15:27 UTC passes:

    • Closing agentic-job#724 (done by #728) and agentic-job#720 (done by #725, with the rest made moot by #941).
    • The broker probe, switched off by BROKER_OUTAGE (latest skipped run) and unavailable for over an hour now.
    • The pace check, blind because usage.yml runs only about every four hours (latest) against a 45-minute freshness limit.

    The Unavailable playbook asks for each of these once.

    No other action:

    • Queue: agentic-job#940 is back in the queue with its checks green, and the other nine merged.
    • Idle: the passes 38947735769 and 38946798433 skip for many separate reasons, none of them dominant, and the operator already has those asks.
    • Already asked today: stuck (tracker#455, merged as agent-board#95), failures (#719 run, report posted by hand) and held (agentic-job#618, still conflicting and waiting on a trusted-trigger decision). Nothing about them has changed.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  5. cgwalters-bot commented on Oct 16, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type": "supervisor_action", "action": "comment", "repository": "cgwalters-forge/agent-board", "item": 100, "body": "PR cgwalters-forge/tracker#103 (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agent-board/pull/103) made the three poll changes. Before needs-human there is now a diagnostic round (`diagnosticPool`, off by default). Identical queue failures are counted by job and step, and merge groups are told apart by run id. A continued partial PR can be retitled (`continuation.retitle`, off by default). What is left from this issue: the agentic-job part is not filed. The issue asks for an agentic-job issue that lets a fix run on a partial pull request update its title and body. The run could not open issues and found no existing one. Also, the operator has to decide before `diagnosticPool` is turned on, because it allows a third run, more than the two fix rounds AGENTS.md cites. Open points from the PR: the excerpt is read from the first page of check annotations, not the raw log. After a diagnostic round, every needs-human stop quotes that excerpt, even when the stop has another reason. Nothing was run against live GitHub."}
    {"type": "supervisor_action", "action": "comment", "repository": "cgwalters-forge/agent-board", "item": 90, "body": "PR cgwalters-forge/tracker#98 (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agent-board/pull/98) removed the poll's un-drafting step. It added continuation runs for checkpoint drafts, capped by `continuation.rounds` (default 2) and then needs-human, and `continuation.pools` to send a continuation to another pool. It removed the ready step outright, with no switch, because the tracker's wrappers pin v0.5.1. What is left: the review site does not yet show checkpoint drafts as \"continuing (round N)\" with the reason, because the PR changed only the poll's status line. The poll can now set a completed continuation's title and description itself, through `continuation.retitle` in cgwalters-forge/tracker#103 (off by default). The agentic-job issue asking fix runs to set them is still not filed (see cgwalters-forge/tracker#100). Open from the PR's self-review: a stale body checkpoint can drive continuations of a draft that a later push completed, and the stop comment still says \"fresh fix rounds\" although continuations reset too."}
    {"type": "supervisor_action", "action": "comment", "repository": "cgwalters-forge/operator", "item": 2, "body": "Supervisor pass of 2026-10-16 ~21:55 UTC. It adds to the 15:00, 15:27 and 18:45 UTC passes on this issue. The earlier decisions still stand unchanged: tracker#455 (stuck), agentic-job#618 (held, still conflicting), agentic-job#720 (unclosed), and the broker probe and pace observations. This pass does not repeat them. Recommended option first.\n\n1. Dispatch on an umbrella (new). https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/38970200264 is an implement run on agentic-job#882. That issue has sub-issues, so the dispatch check flags it. The bot started this run by hand at 21:33 UTC; the scheduler did not. Its plan (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/issues/882#issuecomment-6225122307) limits it to work that no child issue owns. All four children (#884, #885, #919, #920) are closed, and secure-host still has github.mjs and inference-preflight.py to move into the binary. No open pull request covers that work, so the run duplicates nothing, and this pass does not cancel it. A: let it run. In future, file that kind of remainder as a child issue so the umbrella rule does not flag it. B: cancel it and file the remainder as a child issue.\n\n2. Unclosed issues (new). A: close each one with its PR link. B: leave them open.\n- agent-board#101 by https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agent-board/pull/102. It pins review.yml to actions commit bc0ea824 (agentic-job v0.5.2) and keeps the pin test, as the issue asks.\nagent-board#100 (PR cgwalters-forge/tracker#103) and agent-board#90 (PR cgwalters-forge/tracker#98) still have work left, and this pass comments what remains on each. The run in item 1 is handling agentic-job#882.\n\n3. Scheduler bug (new). Both idle passes, https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/38969872505 and https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/38969047976, skip actions#35 (epic tracker#528) with \"could not be read: GET /repos/cgwalters-forge/actions/issues/528: HTTP 404\". The scheduler looks up the epic's number in the item's repository instead of the epic's own repository, so actions#35 can never start. I found no issue that owns this bug. A: file it against the scheduler in agent-board. B: leave it.\n\nNo action needed:\n- Idle: the idle check is already out of date. Since 21:27 UTC, the bot has started implement runs by hand on agent-board#111 to cgwalters-forge/tracker#114, agentic-job#596 and cgwalters-forge/tracker#882, agenthome#8 and tracker#672. Pace is still unavailable, so this pass cannot tell whether that burst is within the claude pool's pace. The other skips are expected: umbrellas, a repository that is not followed, a blocker, an open PR, and a triage plan that is dispatched by hand.\n- Queue: the ten pull requests on the queue check, agentic-job#698 to #940, all merged on their second queue attempt. Their first-attempt failures each had a different cause: an egress control step, e2e agent runs ending in exit state 4, a secure-host build and a session-sandbox test."}
    

    Comment on agent-board#100 (unclosed). PR cgwalters-forge/tracker#103 made all three poll changes. The issue also asks to file the agentic-job part (fix runs updating a partial PR's title and body), and that is not done. The comment records it, along with the operator decision needed before diagnosticPool is turned on.

    Comment on agent-board#90 (unclosed). PR cgwalters-forge/tracker#98 did the poll side. The review site's "continuing (round N)" display is not done, and the agentic-job issue is still not filed. The comment records both.

    Comment on the log issue (operator#2). It asks only about what is new since the 18:45 UTC pass:

    • The flagged dispatch on agentic-job#882. It is an umbrella, but the bot dispatched it by hand for work no child issue covers. It duplicates nothing, so this pass does not cancel it.
    • Closing agent-board#101, done by #102.
    • A scheduler bug: actions#35's epic, tracker#528, is looked up in the actions repository and returns 404 (pass).

    Idle is already out of date: implement runs are starting again. The ten queue PRs all merged on their second attempt. Broker, pace, stuck (tracker#455), held (agentic-job#618) and agentic-job#720 were asked about earlier today and have not changed, so this pass does not repeat them.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  6. cgwalters-bot commented on Oct 17, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type": "supervisor_action", "action": "comment", "repository": "cgwalters-forge/agent-board", "item": 19, "body": "PR cgwalters-forge/tracker#95 (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agent-board/pull/95) only refers to this issue: it added the README section \"Where it fits\" and did not make the fixes listed here. On main today, the stale README section \"Scheduled deterministic staging preview\" is gone. `item add` now takes `--priority`, and `item add` and `item edit` write with the operator's own token when given `--apply`. Still left: `run record` still needs `--run` with the Actions URL pasted in (it fails with \"no recorded Run; supply --run\"), instead of finding the run from the caller's run-name and confirming with `--yes`. `run record` still prints proposals only, with no operator `--apply` path, so applying the Run and Result fields remains manual. That is the main reason this issue gave for the join costing more typing than `gh project item-edit`. The scheduled reconcile workflow (#7) is still untested here."}
    {"type": "supervisor_action", "action": "comment", "repository": "cgwalters-forge/operator", "item": 2, "body": "Supervisor pass of 2026-10-17 ~00:05 UTC. It adds to the four passes of 2026-10-16 on this issue. These earlier decisions still stand unchanged, so this pass does not repeat them: tracker#455 (stuck, still open), agentic-job#618 (held, still conflicting and waiting on a trusted-trigger decision), agentic-job#720, agent-board#101, the broker probe (switched off by BROKER_OUTAGE; its runs at 16:20, 19:39 and 22:12 UTC were all skipped) and the stale pace snapshot. Recommended option first.\n\n1. Unclosed issue (new). A: close agent-board#96 with https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agent-board/pull/97, which pinned review.yml to the actions commit for agentic-job v0.5.1 as the issue asked. https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agent-board/pull/102 (v0.5.2, agent-board#101) has since replaced that pin, so nothing is left. B: leave it open.\nagent-board#19 is not done: PR cgwalters-forge/tracker#95 only refers to it. This pass comments on cgwalters-forge/tracker#19 what is left: `run record` finding the run without `--run`, and an operator apply path for its proposals.\n\nNo action needed:\n- Idle: the two flagged passes (23:39 and 23:47 UTC) came before fill mode was turned on (tracker 07f76fd, 23:49 UTC). The next pass, https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/38983670996, dispatched actions#55. That issue is the refiling of actions#35, closed at 23:48 UTC. The 404 skip on actions#35 that the 21:55 UTC pass reported has therefore stopped, but whether the scheduler bug is real is still open. That pass ran in normal mode, slightly ahead of the claude pool's pace, so fill did not add runs. The remaining skips are expected.\n- Queue: all ten pull requests, agentic-job#698 to #940, merged on 2026-10-16. The earlier passes covered them."}
    

    Comment on agent-board#19 (unclosed). PR cgwalters-forge/tracker#95 only refers to this issue and is a README addition. On main, the stale README section is gone, and item add --priority/--apply exist. run record still needs --run and only proposes changes. It has no operator --apply path. The comment records what is left, so the issue stays open.

    Comment on the log issue (operator#2). It asks the operator to close agent-board#96, which #97 did and #102 has since replaced. It also records that the idle check is out of date: after fill mode was turned on in tracker 07f76fd, the next pass dispatched actions#55. Queue (all ten merged), stuck (tracker#455), held (agentic-job#618, unchanged since 2026-10-15), broker and pace are unchanged since yesterday's passes, which already asked about them. This pass does not repeat those asks.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  7. cgwalters-bot commented on Oct 17, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type": "supervisor_action", "action": "comment", "repository": "cgwalters-forge/agentic-job", "item": 1039, "body": "The merge queue removed this pull request twice for failed checks (merge-group runs https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/actions/runs/38999944179 and https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/actions/runs/39000843683), and the third attempt is on the same head. This is a real failure in the change, not a flake. Both times the job this pull request adds, confined-cleanup, failed in its step \"The runner ended the orphan\". It never read the confined job's log: each of its six `gh api repos/$REPO/actions/jobs/$job/logs` calls failed with \"the response contains terminal escape sequences; pass --allow-escape-sequences to output it anyway\". The runner's job logs contain ANSI colour codes, so the `if` is false on every try, and the step ends with \"orphan ended: no (pid ... not terminated by the runner's cleanup)\" whether or not the runner ended the process. confined-cleanup is skipped in this pull request's own CI, so this path first ran in the merge group. Fix: pass --allow-escape-sequences to that gh api call, or fetch the log another way that writes raw bytes to the file, then let CI run confined-cleanup once outside the merge queue. Re-enqueueing without a new head fails the same way."}
    {"type": "supervisor_action", "action": "comment", "repository": "cgwalters-forge/operator", "item": 2, "body": "Supervisor pass of 2026-10-17 ~04:15 UTC. It adds to the 2026-10-16 passes and the 00:05 UTC pass on this issue. These earlier decisions still stand unchanged, so this pass does not repeat them: tracker#455 (stuck), agentic-job#618 (held), the unclosed pairs agent-board#100/#103, cgwalters-forge/tracker#101/#102, cgwalters-forge/tracker#90/#98, cgwalters-forge/tracker#96/#97 and cgwalters-forge/tracker#19/#95, the broker probe (switched off by BROKER_OUTAGE) and the stale pace snapshot. Recommended option first.\n\n1. Stuck: agentic-job#1012 (new). Its run https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/38992943513 stopped at 01:57 UTC with missing data: its prerequisite agentic-job#1011 (the secure-host image) was open. #1011 was closed at 02:41 UTC by https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/pull/1034, so that reason no longer holds. The scheduler skips the issue as dispatched already. A: dispatch the plan https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/issues/1012#issuecomment-6228155676 again, with \"agentic-job#1011 is merged (#1034)\" in the task. B: leave it.\n\n2. Stuck: actions#57 (new). Its run https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/38992961891 stopped with missing data: it needs the agentic-job release that publishes and attests ghcr.io/cgwalters-forge/secure-host (v0.6.0 in the issue). That reason still holds. v0.5.3 was released at 02:39 UTC, before #1034 merged, and the org has no secure-host package. The scheduler dispatched it because the dependency is written only in the issue text. A: record the dependency as a blocked-by link (no agentic-job issue tracks that release, so file one), and dispatch actions#57 again after the release. B: dispatch again by hand after the release, without the link, which risks another early dispatch. C: edit the plan to stop early without spending a run.\n\n3. Held: tracker#665 (new), needs-human since 2026-10-16 14:06 UTC (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/pull/665#issuecomment-6217266194). The continuation run https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/38912130688 asked for an operator decision. The PR turns on operatorComments for bootc-dev/*, but dispatch.toml and fix.toml list only exact cgwalters-forge repositories. As merged, each operator comment in bootc-dev would get a claim from the bot and then a run the bounds refuse. tracker main still has no bootc-dev entry, so the reason still holds. The run's options, reordered: A: keep the PR as a draft, or close it, until the promote path for external targets exists, as docs/operator-notes.md (2026-10-09, bootc-dev is external) implies. B: add exact bootc-dev repositories to dispatch.toml with an output policy you accept, and extend poll.test.cjs. That also lets implement runs open pull requests there, and through fix.toml lets fix runs push. C: merge as-is and accept the refused runs and claim comments.\n\n4. Queue: agentic-job#1039 (new) fails for a real reason. The supervisor comments the fix on the PR. The bot re-enqueued it twice (03:58 and 04:13 UTC) on an unchanged head, after two identical confined-cleanup failures, so the queue spends about eight minutes at position 1 on each try. A: leave it to the poll's fix rounds, and stop the re-enqueueing if it continues. B: remove it from the queue by hand.\n\nNo action needed: the epic tracker#677 (misctool) carries needs-human. Its last exchange (rename to cgwalters-forge-misctool, 01:32 to 01:35 UTC) is answered, and it waits on your approval of the plan."}
    

    Comment on agentic-job#1039 (queue). The PR adds the job confined-cleanup. It failed the same way in both merge groups (38999944179, 39000843683): gh api .../jobs/$job/logs refuses the log because it holds terminal escape sequences, so the orphan check can never pass. That is a real failure in the change, so the comment says what to fix. It does not call it a flake.

    Comment on the log issue (operator#2). It asks only about what is new since the 00:05 UTC pass:

    No other action. Broker and pace are unavailable but were already asked about once (2026-10-16 18:45 UTC). The unclosed pairs, tracker#455 and agentic-job#618 are unchanged since earlier passes. The tracker#677 epic warning waits on the operator's plan approval.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  8. cgwalters-bot commented on Oct 17, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"comment","repository":"cgwalters-forge/operator","item":2,"body":"Supervisor pass of 2026-10-17 ~08:50 UTC. It adds to the earlier passes on this issue (latest 04:15 UTC). These decisions still stand unchanged and are not repeated: tracker#455 (stuck), agentic-job#618 (held, still conflicting with main), tracker#665 (held, the bootc-dev bounds decision from the 04:15 pass), agent-board#100 and cgwalters-forge/tracker#101 (unclosed), the broker probe (BROKER_OUTAGE off) and the pace snapshot (SUPERVISOR_READ_TOKEN). Recommended option first.\n\n1. Unclosed (new). A: close each with its PR link. B: leave open.\n- tracker#657 by https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/pull/658. The config points at cgwalters-forge/tracker#656 and operator#2, the cooldown is 1 hour, and a test checks the policy. The PR left unverified whether the executor can write to this private issue. It can: the execute job of run https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/39001484208 reported its comment here as done.\n- tracker#659 by https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/pull/661. It added all seven checks, made a read unavailable for an hour fail, wrote a playbook entry per check, and named the token scopes for SUPERVISOR_READ_TOKEN as asked. Its self-review left open points that could become new issues: there is no way to acknowledge a known failing condition, so broker and pace wake the agent every hour, and pace reports no direction.\n- tracker#651 by https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/pull/654. It pinned review to the v0.5.2 wrapper commit and set the GLM context window in both tomls, with the config test.\n\n2. Release v0.6.0 (new; unblocks actions#57 and actions#61). The release prep https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/pull/1121 merged at 08:41 UTC and closed agentic-job#1101, but there is no v0.6.0 tag yet. The latest release is still v0.5.3. The run for actions#61, https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/39008047314, stopped as its plan said to because the tag was missing. actions#57 waits for the published secure-host image. The scheduler skips both as dispatched already. A: tag and publish v0.6.0, confirm the image is attested, then dispatch actions#57 and actions#61 again with v0.6.0 is released in the task. B: wait.\n\n3. Stuck: tracker#687 (new). Its run https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/39002690019 stopped with missing data, and the plan has since been revised to wait for tracker#686 and agenthome#14. agenthome#14 closed at 05:55 UTC. The pull request for cgwalters-forge/tracker#686, https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/pull/694, is a draft with needs-human: continuation round 1 (run https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/39003170563) ended with an incomplete checkpoint. A: read the checkpoint on cgwalters-forge/tracker#694 and decide its hold, then dispatch the plan for cgwalters-forge/tracker#687 again after cgwalters-forge/tracker#694 merges. B: leave both.\n\n4. Stuck: tracker#692 (new), with actions#62. Both runs stopped because no agentic-job release supports a secondary pull request repository. That still holds. The pull request for agentic-job#1075, https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/pull/1092, is a draft with needs-human after continuation round 2 (run https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/39008022387) ended incomplete. A: decide the hold on #1092 first. After it merges and is released, dispatch actions#62 and then tracker#692. B: leave them, and the scheduler keeps skipping them.\n\n5. agenthome#16 (skipped as dispatched already). Its run https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/39003628884 stopped because cgwalters-forge/misctool returns 404 and has no release. It still returns 404 to the read token. This waits on approval of the epic plan for tracker#677 and on the repository being created. A: dispatch it again once misctool has a tagged musl release. B: leave it.\n\nIdle: no separate action. The two flagged passes (08:16 and 08:23 UTC) ran in normal mode and on pace, with slots free. The largest skip reason, plan was dispatched already, covers items 2 to 5 plus tracker#455. The other skips are umbrellas, open pull requests, unfollowed repositories and needs-human.\n\nQueue: no action. All six pull requests merged. agentic-job#1039 merged on a new head, and main's ci.yml now passes --allow-escape-sequences in confined-cleanup. agentic-job#1103 was removed once for the local-sockets sandbox check and merged on a new head at 08:18 UTC."}
    

    Comment on the log issue (operator#2) is the only request. It covers what is new since the 04:15 UTC pass:

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  9. cgwalters-bot commented on Oct 17, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor

    Supervisor pass, 2026-10-17 (queue, stuck, held failing). No requests: every action and dispatch cap in the policy is 0, and .github/supervisor/config.json has no agent.state. That makes replace_state both disabled and targetless, so this pass sends no supervisor-actions block. Missing capability: a configured state issue plus a positive replace_state cap (and dispatch caps for the asks below). I read the current run's supervisor-health artifact (run 39032493989) and docs/operator-notes.md; the newest entry (17 Oct) records that D17 changed.

    queue. All five flagged PRs have merged (#1103, #1039, #940, #926, #927). One real failure class: #1039 left the queue seven times on the same head (877512cf). Each time confined-cleanup's "The runner ended the orphan" step failed (e.g. run 38999944179) because gh api refused to write job logs containing escape sequences. Main's ci.yml now passes --allow-escape-sequences, and the last six merge-group ci runs, from 07:42 to 10:13 UTC, are green including confined-cleanup. So it is resolved, and no issue is needed. The others were one-off failures that passed on re-entry with an unchanged head, so they look like flakes:

    No owning issue exists for the local-sockets flake. File one if it recurs.

    stuck. All five implement runs failed at apply because the agent returned missing_data, so no PR was opened. There are four causes:

    The operator needs to decide whether to enable triage dispatch for these.

    held. agentic-job#618 has been held needs-human since 15 Oct: poll's stop comment. Fix round 1 pushed nothing, and the PR conflicts with main. It is approved, but vet fails: the PR changes the workflow checker that is itself required, and ingress refuses it. It does not meet the remove_needs_human conditions. The operator has to decide between removing the label for fresh fix rounds, landing the checker change by another route, or closing it.

    broker, pace. Both report observation unavailable since 12:28 UTC. That is under the one-hour threshold, so they are not failing yet. Check them on the next pass.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  10. cgwalters-bot commented on Oct 17, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor

    Supervisor daily pass, 2026-10-17 (health run https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/39045123417). No requests: every action's dailyCaps entry is 0 and maxDispatchesPerPass/maxDispatchesPerDay are 0, so dispatch, comment, create_issue, close, remove_needs_human, replace_state and status_update are all disabled in this policy. There is also no configured state issue (agent.state is absent from .github/supervisor/config.json, and the policy's state is null), so this pass ends without a replace_state request rather than guessing a target. No supervisor memory was read or written.

    broker (unavailable). The probe is switched off, not failing: every scheduled run of broker-probe.yml since at least 2026-10-16 has been skipped (for example 39035218436), because its job runs only when vars.BROKER_OUTAGE == 'apply'. agent-board's health pass reads skipped probe runs as no observation (crates/board-forge/src/supervise/health.rs, probes). The real onset is 2026-10-16T14:53Z. The 08:34 report shows that onset; the 12:25 report and this one restart it at 12:28Z. That restart is the previous-report lookup that 65e8f16 addresses. Operator decision: re-enable the probe (BROKER_OUTAGE=apply), or accept that broker health (and the infrastructure check, which depends on it) stays unobserved.

    pace (unavailable, same onset). The check needs a usage snapshot no older than usageStaleMinutes (45). usage.yml is scheduled every 15 minutes, but GitHub has started it only every 2 to 4 hours (successful runs at 06:04, 10:33 and 13:53Z today). So the snapshot is very likely stale whenever a health pass reads it. Inference: this run's read-only token cannot open the private snapshot repository, so I could not tell staleness apart from a read or token-scope failure. Operator decision: widen usageStaleMinutes to match the observed schedule, or check that the health token can still read the snapshot.

    queue (fail, all resolved). All five pull requests have merged since. Real failures, each fixed by a later push: agentic-job#1039 failed confined-cleanup (orphan not ended by the runner's cleanup) on four queue entries across three queue SHAs, for example 39004055060, then merged after the 05:11Z push. agentic-job#1103 failed secure-host-image (39014163035), then merged after the 08:00Z push. Flakes, which merged on an unchanged requeue: agentic-job#927 failed e2e-dispatch (research) in secure-host (38937465809). agentic-job#940 failed a confined-step docker control (38947122197). agentic-job#926 left the queue within a minute without a failed run of its own, then merged after a rebase. Nothing to decide unless the #927 or #940 flakes recur.

    held (fail). agentic-job#618 (workflows: keep proposals from replacing their required checker) has been needs-human since the poll's stop comment on 2026-10-15. Head 308ea5dde541 conflicts with main, and fix round 38735083141 pushed nothing. The dispatch's status comment says a rebase alone is not enough. The PR's own new check refuses its trusted-trigger zizmor suppression. The suggested self-repository syntax breaks actionlint, and switching to pull_request would defeat the PR. So this is more than a merge conflict, and remove_needs_human would not apply even if it were enabled. Operator decision: authorize a narrowly reviewed trusted-trigger exception for this checker, or close or supersede #618.

    All other checks are ok in this report.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  11. locked as resolved and limited conversation to collaborators on Oct 17, 2026
  12. cgwalters-bot commented on Oct 17, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor

    Daily pass, 2026-10-17. Inputs read: state issue tracker#718 (still its initial body), docs/operator-notes.md, and health.json from run 39054351430. The policy enables only replace_state: dispatches and every other action are capped at 0. So the one request is the state update, and everything below is for the operator to decide.

    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"replace_state","body":"Supervisor state (tracker#718). Replaced by the hosted supervisor through replace_state; do not edit by hand. Locked, collaborators only.\n\nLast pass: 2026-10-17 daily pass, run https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/39054351430, report on tracker#656.\n\nPolicy seen: dispatches 0 per pass and per day; comment, create_issue, close, remove_needs_human and status_update caps 0; replace_state 1.\n\nOpen findings:\n- broker: unavailable since at least 2026-10-16T14:53Z. Every broker-probe.yml run is skipped (its job runs only when vars.BROKER_OUTAGE is apply), and health ignores skipped probes. Owner: tracker#659. Operator: turn the probe on, or have health report a switched-off probe as off.\n- pace: unavailable since at least 2026-10-16T14:53Z, though usage.yml succeeds (last 17:00Z). Health reads the snapshot from a private repository with SUPERVISOR_READ_TOKEN or the job token; probably no read access there (inference). Owner: tracker#659.\n- queue: agentic-job#1152, #1103, #1039, #940 and #926 have all merged. #1152 hit a sandbox_host probe-test flake (merge-group CI run 39050989667; it passed on the same group sha). #1103 had a real local-sockets sandbox-check failure (run 39014163035), fixed by a new head. #1039 failed confined-cleanup (orphan not terminated) 7 times on an unchanged head, 03:44-05:12Z (run 38999944179), and was requeued each time until a new head fixed it. #940 (run 38947122197, docker control step) and #926 (run 38948070346, e2e agent exit 4) passed on their next entry. The check also counts the removal event GitHub logs at merge, so it keeps failing for 24h after a merge. Neither the requeue loop nor this false positive has an owning issue yet.\n- stuck: tracker#697, cgwalters-forge/tracker#353, cgwalters-forge/tracker#321, cgwalters-forge/tracker#692 and agenthome#16 are skipped as dispatched already. Each implement run failed at apply after missing_data and opened no PR. cgwalters-forge/tracker#353 and cgwalters-forge/tracker#321: the runs checked out tracker, not composefs-rs. They ran at 11:39Z, before the fork bounds (8c54844, 12:04Z), and depend on cgwalters-forge/tracker#697. cgwalters-forge/tracker#697: its run got 404 on agent-board source (run 39028173232), though agent-board is public. cgwalters-forge/tracker#692: waits on the actions wrapper pin (bot comment on cgwalters-forge/tracker#692). agenthome#16: misctool was 404 then; it is public now but has no release or tag. None of the five is locked, so a dispatch would be refused.\n- idle: tally at 17:24Z: needs design 16, umbrella 11, dispatched already 11, needs-human 10, composefs-rs plans not followed 6 (deliberate, per 8c54844).\n\nNext checks:\n- Whether the probe is turned on and a read token is added, and the broker and pace observations come back.\n- Whether misctool gets a release (unblocks agenthome#16) and the wrapper pin moves (#692).\n- Whether cgwalters-forge/tracker#697 lands; cgwalters-forge/tracker#353 and cgwalters-forge/tracker#321 then need new plans that target the fork.\n- Once dispatch caps are positive and the items are locked: triage with no-pull-request on the stuck items.\n- Whether a merge-queue bounce repeats on an unchanged head."}
    

    broker fails because there is nothing to observe. Every broker-probe.yml run today was skipped: its job runs only when vars.BROKER_OUTAGE == 'apply'. agent-board's health pass ignores skipped probes and reports the check unavailable. Earlier reports show this since at least 2026-10-16T14:53Z. The 12:28Z unavailable_since only marks a pass that lost the carried timestamp, the gap 65e8f16 closed. This is no evidence of a broker outage: poll and the agent runs are healthy. Operator: turn the probe on, or decide that health should report a switched-off probe as off rather than failing. Owner: tracker#659.

    pace has been unavailable for the same span, though usage.yml succeeds (last run 17:00Z). Health reads the snapshot comment from the private repository named in .github/usage/config.json, using SUPERVISOR_READ_TOKEN || github.token. My inference, matching tracker#659: that token cannot read the private repository. A 45-minute staleness limit against a publish cadence GitHub stretches to hours would also do it. Operator: give the health pass a read token for that repository, or confirm it already has one so the staleness explanation can be checked.

    queue: all five evidence PRs have merged. agentic-job#1152 bounced on sandbox (0, true, true) / each_probe_fails_when_its_protection_is_removed (run) and passed on the same merge-group SHA, so a flake. #1103 failed for real: secure-host-image's local-sockets sandbox check (run), fixed by a new head. #1039 failed confined-cleanup (orphan not terminated by the runner's cleanup, run) seven times on an unchanged head between 03:44 and 05:12Z. It was requeued each time until a new head fixed it. That was a real failure, retried without a change. #940 (docker control step, run) and #926 (e2e agent exit state 4, run) passed on their next entry. The check counts every removed_from_merge_queue event within 24h, including the one GitHub logs at merge, so it keeps failing after a PR has merged. Operator: two possible tracker issues (I cannot file them, create_issue is capped at 0). One: the queue requeues an unchanged head after a real merge-group failure. Two: the health check should ignore removals at merge and PRs that later merged.

    idle and stuck share a cause. The 17:24Z pass had free slots and skipped 11 plans as dispatched already. Most of the rest needed design, were umbrellas, were held needs-human, or were composefs-rs plans the poll deliberately does not follow (8c54844). The five stuck items each ended with missing_data at apply and no PR:

    The playbook would ask for triage with no-pull-request. Dispatch is capped at 0, and none of the five issues is locked, so the executor would refuse it anyway. Operator: re-plan #353 and #321 against the fork once #697 lands, and cut a misctool release for agenthome#16.

    Not run here: no status_update, comment, close or remove_needs_human, all disabled. Nothing else needed attention: poll, runs, epics, dispatch, approved, infrastructure, dependabot, decisions, release, failures, held, unqueued and unclosed are all ok.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  13. cgwalters-bot commented on Oct 17, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type": "supervisor_action", "action": "replace_state", "body": "# Supervisor state\n\nLast pass: 2026-10-17, daily pass, against health artifact 12110520671 (supervisor run 39058004774, tracker 9fd226f). Requests in that pass: this replacement only. Every other action and every dispatch is disabled by the policy (caps 0).\n\n## Open findings\n\n- broker (unavailable since 2026-10-17T12:28Z): broker-probe.yml runs only when `vars.BROKER_OUTAGE == 'apply'`; every scheduled run since at least 2026-10-16T22:12Z was skipped (latest 39049437201). So the probe is switched off. This is not an observed outage. Operator: enable the probe, or have health treat a disabled probe as \"off\" rather than fail.\n- pace (unavailable since 2026-10-17T12:28Z): 9fd226f switched the health read to the bot's token, but the first health pass on 9fd226f (run 39058004774, 18:28Z) still reports pace unavailable. The cause was not observable with the agent's read-only token. Next: read that run's health job log once it completes.\n- queue: agentic-job#1152, #1103, #1039 and #940 all merged. #1152 (merge-group run 39050989667: sandbox_host.rs:270, \"the root service sent no status\" for gpasswd) and #940 (run 38947122197, confined run step job) were re-queued on the same head and passed, so they look like flakes. #1103 (secure-host-image, run 39014163035) and #1039 (confined-cleanup orphan, runs 39004978095 and earlier) failed for real and were fixed by new pushes. No issue tracks the sandbox_host root-socket flake; create_issue is disabled, so the operator was asked to file one.\n- stuck: 5 implement plans ended with missing_data and no PR:\n  - tracker#353, cgwalters-forge/tracker#321 (runs 39029524987, 39029519313): the runs checked out tracker, but the code lives in composefs-rs. tracker#697 (step 2) says cgwalters-forge/tracker#160's work should be filed as implement issues in cgwalters-forge/composefs-rs; tracker#700 (bounds) merged at 12:05Z. Operator: re-file or re-plan these issues in the fork.\n  - tracker#697 (run 39028173232): the run got a 404 reading agent-board source. agent-board is public now; it may have been unreachable at 11:18Z (inference). cgwalters-forge/tracker#700 landed step 1. Steps 2 and 3 (schedule.repositories, fork PRs in the poll) remain.\n  - tracker#692 (run 39003197614): waiting on agentic-job#1075 and actions#62 (both open), as the bot noted on the issue.\n  - agenthome#16 (run 39003628884): misctool was created at 10:47Z, after the run; it still has no tags or releases (misctool#1 is open). Do not re-run until a release exists.\n  - None of the five issues is locked, so a dispatch on any of them would be refused anyway.\n- held: agentic-job#1092 (a draft, part of agentic-job#1075) has needs-human since 06:02Z. Fix round 2 (run 39008022387) checkpointed as incomplete with no new head. Operator: remove the label for fresh rounds, or rescope the PR. It blocks the cgwalters-forge/tracker#692 chain.\n\n## Next checks\n\n- Check whether broker and pace come back after the probe or variable is enabled.\n- Check whether the sandbox_host root-socket flake recurs in the agentic-job merge queue.\n- Watch for a misctool release (unblocks agenthome#16) and for agentic-job#1075 and actions#62 (unblock cgwalters-forge/tracker#692).\n- Watch for fork issues for cgwalters-forge/tracker#353 and cgwalters-forge/tracker#321.\n"}
    

    Daily supervisor pass. Inputs read: state issue #718 (the initial placeholder body), docs/operator-notes.md, and health.json from artifact 12110520671 (run 39058004774, which matches the report). The operator request has no body, so no plan was requested. The policy disables every dispatch and every action except replace_state, so this batch only records state.

    broker: unavailable since 12:28Z because the probe is switched off. It is not an outage: broker-probe.yml runs only when vars.BROKER_OUTAGE == 'apply', and every scheduled run since at least 10-16 22:12Z was skipped (e.g. 39049437201). Operator: turn the probe on, or decide that health should report a disabled probe as off rather than fail.

    pace: still unavailable on the first health pass after 9fd226f, which moved the read to the bot's token (run 39058004774 ran on 9fd226f). The agent's read-only token cannot see why. The next check is that run's health job log once it completes. No numbers are given here.

    queue: all four PRs merged. #1152 (run: sandbox_host.rs:270, "the root service sent no status" for gpasswd) and #940 (run, confined run step job) passed when re-queued on the same head, so they look like flakes. #1103 (secure-host-image) and #1039 (confined-cleanup orphan) failed for real and were fixed by new pushes. No issue tracks the root-socket flake. Operator: file one in agentic-job (create_issue is disabled for me).

    stuck: all five runs ended with missing_data and no PR. None of the issues is locked, and dispatch is disabled, so I requested no runs.

    • tracker#353 and #321: the runs checked out tracker, but the code is in composefs-rs. Step 2 of #697 says Epic: Help cgwalters maintain his FOSS: ostree, composefs, bootc and friends #160's work should be filed as issues in cgwalters-forge/composefs-rs, and the bounds for it landed in #700. Operator: re-file or re-plan these two in the fork.
    • #697 (run): the run got a 404 reading agent-board source. agent-board is public now (inference: it was unreachable at 11:18Z). Steps 2 and 3 remain.
    • #692: waiting on agentic-job#1075 and actions#62, both open.
    • agenthome#16: misctool was created at 10:47Z, after the run, and still has no release. Re-running it now would fail the same way.

    held: agentic-job#1092 is a draft scaffold for #1075. Fix round 2 checkpointed as incomplete with no new head, and the poll's comment explains the hold. Operator: remove needs-human for fresh fix rounds, or rescope or close the PR. It gates #692.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  14. cgwalters-bot commented on Oct 17, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor

    Supervisor daily pass, 2026-10-17 ~20:30Z, the first in apply mode after tracker#726. Inputs read: state issue tracker#718 (still its initial body, because every earlier pass ran in preview: the execute log of https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/39058004774 says "Preview only; no requests applied"), docs/operator-notes.md, and health.json from artifact 12113801084 (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/39066362661), which matches the report.

    {"type": "supervisor_action", "action": "create_issue", "title": "poll: A real merge-group failure is re-queued when several jobs fail, because the poll names it by the first failed job", "body": "Goal: the poll stops re-queuing a head after its second identical merge-group failure even when several jobs fail.\n\nEvidence: https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/pull/1177 left the merge queue three times on one head (226cd7ee) for failed_checks, and cgwalters-bot re-added it each time (19:47, 20:02 and 20:17Z on 2026-10-17). Each merge-group ci run failed the same way: all eight e2e agent jobs stopped in the secure-host step with `unknown field agent, expected one of sandbox, egress, setup` from the host config (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/actions/runs/39064020662, https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/actions/runs/39065032116, https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agentic-job/actions/runs/39066076628). That is the head's own failure, not a flake.\n\nCause: `removal` in agent-board's crates/board-forge/src/poll.rs treats a merge-group failure as the head's own only when `job J failed at step S` matches the one it recorded, and then starts a diagnostic round. `group_failure` returns the first failed job of the jobs listing. With eight failing jobs that was e2e-full, then e2e-check-run, then e2e-people, so the names never matched and each removal was re-queued as new, up to `mergeQueue.tries`.\n\nSteps:\n1. Record the set of failed (job, step) pairs and count an overlap with the recorded set as the same failure.\n2. Add a test with two merge-group runs that list the same failing jobs in a different order.\n\nProof: a fixture replaying #1177's runs stops after the second removal and starts a diagnostic round."}
    {"type": "supervisor_action", "action": "create_issue", "title": "Lock followed issues so collaborators-only dispatch can act: agent-board#111's locking half has no owner", "body": "Goal: open ordinary issues in followed repositories are locked, so that the supervisor's dispatches, which require a locked conversation, can be admitted.\n\nEvidence: https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agent-board/issues/111 asked for (1) locking new issues and pull requests in followed repositories with a reusable workflow in cgwalters-forge/actions and a caller in each repository, with the poll locking unlocked items as a backstop, (2) a collaborators-only check at dispatch and (3) a sanity check in the brief. It closed when https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agent-board/pull/115 merged. That PR did step 2 for dispatch only, and its description lists step 1, the poll backstop, the fix-round and steering checks and step 3 as follow-ups. No open issue carries them, and none of actions, tracker, agentic-job or agent-board has a lock workflow.\n\nEffect: an org search for open locked issues finds only tracker#718, cgwalters-forge/tracker#656 and cgwalters-forge/tracker#176. All 14 plans the scheduler skips as dispatched already, among them tracker#697, cgwalters-forge/tracker#353, cgwalters-forge/tracker#321, actions#68, actions#69, tracker#692 and agenthome#16, are unlocked, so supervise execute refuses a supervisor dispatch on any of them. The supervisor's stuck and idle duties cannot be carried out in apply mode. https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agent-board/issues/138 item 4 proposes a supervisor lock action, which covers the supervisor but not new items.\n\nOptions:\nA (recommended): file the cgwalters-forge/tracker#111 follow-ups as an implement issue: the reusable lock workflow and its six callers, and the poll backstop for items whose authors and editors are all collaborators.\nB: add only cgwalters-forge/tracker#138's lock action, and the supervisor requests a lock before each dispatch.\n\nProof: the org search returns the stuck items as locked, and a supervisor triage dispatch on one of them is admitted."}
    {"type": "supervisor_action", "action": "create_issue", "title": "Epic tracker#596 (P0) cannot advance: its pending plan closes agentic-job#611, which is already closed, so every coordinator pass is refused", "body": "Goal: an epic whose pending plan can no longer apply is re-planned or applied without the stale action, rather than retried every pass.\n\nEvidence: every scheduler pass logs a coordinator error for tracker#596. The apply of plan comment 6207389344 is refused: `action 1 (close_sub_issue): cgwalters-forge/agentic-job#611 is a closed sub-issue; a plan may not change it`. See the board job of https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/39065897819 (20:19Z). The plan was written at 2026-10-16 03:25Z, while cgwalters-forge/tracker#611 was open. cgwalters-forge/tracker#611 closed at 03:32Z when agentic-job#612 merged. https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/issues/596 has not been updated since 03:33Z on 10-16, and the supervisor's epics health check reports ok.\n\nSteps:\n1. In epic apply, treat a close_sub_issue whose target is already closed as satisfied, or have the coordinator re-plan after its apply is refused, instead of retrying the same plan.\n2. Have the epics health check fail when the coordinator's apply of the same plan is refused in consecutive passes.\n3. Re-plan cgwalters-forge/tracker#596 once either change lands.\n\nProof: the next coordinator pass on cgwalters-forge/tracker#596 applies or re-plans, and a test with an already closed sub-issue in a plan is not refused indefinitely."}
    {"type": "supervisor_action", "action": "status_update", "status": "at-risk", "body": "Supervisor daily pass, 2026-10-17, the first in apply mode. At risk: some work is moving, but several approved plans are blocked and the supervisor cannot dispatch yet.\n\n- tracker#677 chain: agentic-job#1092 is held needs-human after an incomplete continuation round. It gates agentic-job#1075, the agentic-job release that includes it, actions#62 and tracker#692. agenthome#16 waits for a misctool release (misctool#2 open).\n- tracker#674 slices actions#68 and actions#69 wait for agentic-job#1177 and #1187 and a release that includes them. #1177 fails every merge group on a host-config field the image rejects, and the poll re-queued it three times on the same head. A tracker issue was filed for the operator.\n- tracker#596 (P0) has not advanced since 2026-10-16: its pending plan is refused in every pass. A tracker issue was filed.\n- tracker#353 and cgwalters-forge/tracker#321 need new plans in the composefs-rs fork after tracker#697.\n- No ordinary issue is locked, so the executor would refuse every supervisor dispatch. Locking has had no owner since agent-board#111 closed. A tracker issue was filed.\n- The broker probe is switched off and the usage snapshot is older than health allows, so neither check is observed."}
    {"type": "supervisor_action", "action": "replace_state", "body": "# Supervisor state\n\nReplaced by the hosted supervisor through replace_state; do not edit by hand.\n\nLast pass: 2026-10-17 ~20:30Z, daily pass, health artifact 12113801084 (supervisor run https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/39066362661). This is the first pass in apply mode, after tracker#726. The earlier passes on 2026-10-17 ran in preview, so their replace_state requests were never applied.\n\nRequested in this pass: create_issue x3 (the poll's queue re-tries, issue locking, the cgwalters-forge/tracker#596 apply refusal), status_update at-risk, and this replacement. No dispatch, comment, close or remove_needs_human request: none would pass the executor's checks.\n\n## Open findings\n\n- dispatch blocked: only tracker#718, cgwalters-forge/tracker#656 and cgwalters-forge/tracker#176 are locked among open issues in the org. Every stuck or skipped plan is unlocked, so a dispatch would be refused. agent-board#111's locking half (lock new items, poll backstop) was never done; agent-board#138 item 4 proposes a lock action. Filed for the operator in this pass.\n- queue: agentic-job#1177 (head 226cd7ee) was re-queued 3 times. Every merge group fails all 8 e2e agent jobs in the secure-host step with `unknown field agent` in the host config (runs 39064020662, 39065032116, 39066076628). It is a real failure. The poll names the failure by the first failed job, which differed each time, so its stop-at-the-second-failure rule never fired. Filed in this pass. #1152, #1103 and #1039 merged earlier.\n- epic tracker#596 (P0): the coordinator's apply of plan comment 6207389344 is refused every pass because it closes agentic-job#611, which is already closed. No progress since 2026-10-16 03:33Z; the epics check says ok. Filed in this pass.\n- stuck, all unlocked:\n  - tracker#697 (run 39028173232, 404 on agent-board source); steps 2-3 remain.\n  - tracker#353 and cgwalters-forge/tracker#321 (runs 39029524987, 39029519313) checked out tracker, not composefs-rs. They need re-plans in the fork after cgwalters-forge/tracker#697.\n  - actions#68 (run 39061910637) waits on agentic-job#1175 (PR #1177) plus a release; actions#69 (run 39061954255) waits on agentic-job#1176 (PR #1187) plus a release. Latest release is v0.6.1.\n  - tracker#692 and actions#62 wait on agentic-job#1075 (PR #1092, held) plus a release.\n  - agenthome#16 waits on a misctool release; misctool#2 is open and there is no release yet.\n- held: agentic-job#1092, a draft that is not approved, has been held needs-human since 2026-10-17 06:02Z after continuation round 2 (run 39008022387) checkpointed incomplete. It is not eligible for remove_needs_human. Operator: remove the label for fresh rounds, or rescope it.\n- broker: probe switched off (broker-probe.yml runs only when vars.BROKER_OUTAGE is apply; latest run 39059453834 was skipped). No outage evidence.\n- pace: unobserved. usage.yml is scheduled every 15 minutes but last ran at 19:12Z, while health ran at 20:24Z, past usageStaleMinutes. Likely staleness rather than access (inference).\n- idle: 7 slots free. The skips are mostly needs design, dispatched already (13), umbrella and needs-human. agentic-job#1168's plan is refused because it stacks on another issue without --bot.\n\n## Next checks\n\n- Whether #1177 is held or gets a diagnostic round now that its tries are used, and whether the filed queue issue lands.\n- Whether issues get locked; then triage the stuck items with no-pull-request (pool mistral), at most 2 a pass.\n- Whether #1092 is released or rescoped; whether agentic-job ships #1075, #1175 and #1176 in a release; whether there is a misctool release.\n- Whether cgwalters-forge/tracker#596 re-plans.\n- Whether the broker probe is enabled and the usage snapshot stays fresh.\n"}
    

    Why no dispatch, close, comment or remove_needs_human request. Dispatch: an org search for open locked issues finds only tracker#718, #656 and #176. All 14 plans the scheduler skips as dispatched already are unlocked, so the executor would refuse any dispatch on them, and an invalid request would refuse this whole batch. Close: no stuck issue has a done triage receipt. remove_needs_human: the only held PR is not eligible (below). Comment: I left a supervisor note off agentic-job#1177, because the scheduler and poll refuse a conversation that holds one, and that would block the poll's own fix round.

    queue (real failure, requeue loop). cgwalters-forge/agentic-job#1177 was re-added to the merge queue three times on head 226cd7ee. Every merge group failed all eight e2e agent jobs in the secure-host step with unknown field agent, expected one of sandbox, egress, setup from the host config (1, 2, 3). It is the change's own failure. The poll's rule to stop at the second identical failure never fired, because group_failure in agent-board's poll.rs names the failure by the first failed job in the listing (e2e-full, then e2e-check-run, then e2e-people). Filed as the first create_issue. #1152, #1103 and #1039 had merged earlier, as previous passes found.

    stuck / idle (7 slots free, nothing started). Most skips are needs design, dispatched already (13), umbrella or needs-human. The stuck items:

    The playbook's triage with no-pull-request is blocked only by the missing locks. agent-board#111's locking half was left undone when agent-board#115 closed it; agent-board#138 item 4 proposes a lock action. Filed as the second create_issue, for the operator to choose between them. Separately, agentic-job#1168's plan is refused because it stacks on another issue without --bot.

    epics (health says ok, but it is not). Every coordinator pass is refused applying tracker#596's plan, because it closes agentic-job#611, which closed seven minutes after the plan was written. The P0 epic has not moved since 2026-10-16 03:33Z. Filed as the third create_issue.

    held. agentic-job#1092 is a draft that is not approved. It is held after continuation round 2 (run) checkpointed incomplete with no new head (poll comment). It is not a conflict-only hold, so remove_needs_human does not apply. Operator: remove the label to start fresh rounds, or rescope or close the PR. It gates #1075, a release, actions#62 and tracker#692.

    broker (unavailable). The probe is switched off: broker-probe.yml runs only when vars.BROKER_OUTAGE == 'apply', and every run is skipped (latest 39059453834). There is no evidence of an outage: poll and runs are ok. Operator: enable the probe, or have health report a disabled probe as off.

    pace (unavailable). usage.yml is scheduled every 15 minutes, but its last run was at 19:12Z while this health pass read at 20:24Z, past usageStaleMinutes. Inference: staleness, not access, now that 9fd226f reads with the bot's token. Operator: widen the limit, or find why GitHub starts usage.yml so rarely.

    The other checks (poll, runs, dispatch, approved, infrastructure, dependabot, decisions, release, failures, unqueued, unclosed) are ok. The operator request asked for no plan, so no plan issue was filed.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  15. 460 remaining items

  16. cgwalters-bot commented on Nov 15, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"dispatch","repository":"cgwalters-forge/actions","item":230,"kind":"triage","pool":"claude","reason":"merged-open"}
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"dispatch","repository":"cgwalters-forge/agent-board","item":636,"kind":"triage","pool":"claude","reason":"merged-open"}
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"dispatch","repository":"cgwalters-forge/tracker","item":982,"kind":"triage","pool":"openai","reason":"no-plan"}
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"replace_state","body":"# Supervisor state\n\n## Latest sweep: 2026-11-15 ~12:00Z (health pass)\n\nI read state 718 first (last edited 10:53Z, unchanged at re-read) and kept its record. Operator notes: unchanged since 11-14. This was the health sweep for supervisor run 43711008021. Read-only; no new implementation asked for. Older detail is in this issue's edit history (index in the 11-14 08:05Z revision; 11-15 00:40Z for the release-train root cause, 07:25Z for the hold tally and the 13 promotion handoffs, 08:30Z for tracker#1688 and the release-list re-holds, 09:40Z for the coordinator-rescope gap, 10:50Z for the three implement dispatches).\n\n### Changed since 10:50Z\n\n- The 10:50Z implement runs all opened PRs. agent-board#636 is fixed by agent-board#1008 (merged 11:40Z). actions#230 is fixed by actions#272 (merged). Both issues are still open, so I asked for merged-open triage on each. agentic-job#2070 has agentic-job#4253, a draft with green CI that is in continuation round 3 (fix run 43710485199).\n- The release train failed again at 11:13Z (43707897871, \"unrecognized secure-host action pin\"). That run used board ede9c9d, from before #1008 merged. The board pin moved to 72c4c7f at 11:51Z (43710924394), so the hourly :23 train run is the first real test of the fix.\n- Pass 43710202423 (11:42Z): claude and openai both reported under pace and idle. Stage 4's budget left 159 candidates unread, starting with tracker#982 (agent-board#803, held behind agent-board#782 and #1001). I asked for triage on tracker#982 (openai, no-plan): a P0 ostree ci-bootc segfault whose last update was 11-04.\n- The promotion-handoff skips (needs-supervisor) are the same set as at 07:25Z. Size refusals (signature 88122969) are still owned by tracker#1430 (open). The bounds signature 2a72bf79 (count 1) is agent-board#782's branch, which is left to the operator.\n- Supervisor run 43708086196 (11:16Z) ran health only and posted no request.\n\n### Requested\n\n12:00Z: triage on actions#230 and agent-board#636 (claude, merged-open), triage on tracker#982 (openai, no-plan), and this state. No status update (already sent today).\n\n### Excluded from supervisor dispatch\n\nAs in the 10:50Z revision, plus actions#230, agent-board#636 and tracker#982 (triage dispatched 12:00Z; follow their verdicts). agentic-job#2070: follow agentic-job#4253. Dispatch only to claude and openai, and to openai only when it is not over.\n\n### Owners and gates\n\nAs in the 10:50Z revision.\n\nMissing executor capabilities: as in the 10:50Z revision (file_bug without a health signature while bugEpic is set; clear_needs_human disabled; no release-train dispatch action).\n\nOperator asks: unchanged from the 10:50Z revision (recommend yes to each).\n\n### Next checks\n\nRelease-train run after 11:51Z on board 72c4c7f: if it passes, the wrapper pin PR to v0.6.14 follows. If it fails again, file_bug needs a signature (or a person files it). Triage verdicts on actions#230, agent-board#636 and tracker#982. Whether agentic-job#4253 leaves draft. Whether the closed-PR pass error recurs (then file_bug, repository agent-board, link tracker#680). bootc#136 review. tracker#1688 outcome. agent-board#1002 follow-up. tracker#1687 label and answer. #1004 progress. tracker#1685 closure. agentic-job#3690. Next status update after 11-16 10:50Z.\n\nSupervisor profile: cgwalters-forge/agenthome at ce75a397b285ee000d4046bae405e0ecb6bb08d6\n"}
    

    Pass and pace. Polls ran and passed through 11:42Z. Pass 43710202423 started nothing. It reported claude and openai both under pace, and stage 4's budget left 159 candidates unread (agent-board#803, which is held behind agent-board#782 and #1001). Most of the blocker list is still the operator review queue in agentic-job. To use the free slots, I asked for triage on the first unread candidate, tracker#982 (P0 ostree ci-bootc segfault, last updated 11-04).

    Earlier implement runs. All three 10:50Z runs opened PRs. agent-board#1008 (release-train pin parser) and actions#272 merged, but agent-board#636 and actions#230 are still open, so I asked for merged-open triage on each. agentic-job#4253 is a draft with green CI, in continuation round 3.

    release. The train failed at 11:13Z (43707897871, unrecognized secure-host action pin) on the old board revision, before #1008 merged. The board pin moved at 11:51Z, so the next hourly train run is the first test of the fix. The wrapper stays behind v0.6.14 until it passes.

    signatures, apply-failures, needs-supervisor, held, queue, reviews, runs, epics, dispatch. No change since the last record. tracker#1430 owns the size refusals. The promotion-handoff skips and held drafts are as recorded. The queue and reviews evidence is the same operator review queue.

    Operator. Nothing new to decide. Earlier asks stand.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  17. cgwalters-bot commented on Nov 15, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"dispatch","repository":"cgwalters-forge/agent-board","item":636,"kind":"implement","pool":"claude","reason":"merged-open"}
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"dispatch","repository":"cgwalters-forge/actions","item":230,"kind":"implement","pool":"claude","reason":"merged-open"}
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"replace_state","body":"# Supervisor state\n\n## Latest sweep: 2026-11-15 ~13:10Z (daily pass)\n\nI read state 718 first (last edited 12:02Z, unchanged at re-read) and kept its record. Operator notes: unchanged since 11-14. This was the daily sweep for supervisor run 43716910800. Read-only. Older detail is in this issue's edit history (index in the 11-14 08:05Z revision; 11-15 00:40Z for the release-train root cause, 07:25Z for the hold tally and the 13 promotion handoffs, 08:30Z for tracker#1688 and the release-list re-holds, 09:40Z for the coordinator-rescope gap, 10:50Z for the three implement dispatches).\n\n### Changed since 12:00Z\n\n- Triage verdicts (12:07Z), all `partly`. agent-board#636: the train still fails on board 72c4c7f (run 43713029858, 12:17Z, same \"unrecognized secure-host action pin\"). agent-board#1008 changed only fixtures and docs. `repin_host` (board-forge/src/release_train.rs L96-112) scans every `wrappers.files` entry, and actions' lint/tests/review_wrapper.rs (L40, L1295) and README.md (L178) contain `secure-host@` followed by a quote, `{` or `<`, so `pin_at` bails. The fix is in agent-board; no operator decision is needed. actions#230: only an evidence.md refresh citing run 43708182513 is left, plus closing superseded Dependabot PRs actions#204 and #211. tracker#982: owned by tracker#42 (refresh the ostree 26.04 migration branch); nothing to dispatch from here.\n- agentic-job#4253 (for agentic-job#2070) is now held needs-human: continuation round 3 (43710485199) ended without a new head. This is the same pattern as agentic-job#3690.\n- The agent-board#1004 fix run 43710212977 timed out (new signature edf5e96f, count 1, no bug yet).\n- Passes: the 12:02Z and 12:16Z passes read every candidate and found nothing ready to start. The 12:30Z, 12:42Z and 12:52Z passes ran short on the bot token's hourly core limit; 12:52Z (43716060890) deferred all 29 live epics and left 260 candidates unread. It budgeted from a snapshot whose reset was a minute away. 12:42Z (43715207731) failed on one operation (agent-board#830 comments) under the same budget. claude is under pace and openai is near it.\n- forge-sync 43716492097 failed in forge-sync-drift (not yet read).\n- Supervisor run 43714195259 (12:30Z) posted no request.\n\n### Requested\n\n13:10Z: implement on agent-board#636 (parent tracker#680) and actions#230 (parent tracker#674), claude, merged-open, and this state. No status update (already sent today).\n\n### Excluded from supervisor dispatch\n\nAs in the 10:50Z revision, plus agent-board#636 and actions#230 (implement dispatched 13:10Z; follow their PRs), tracker#982 (owned by tracker#42), agentic-job#2070 (follow agentic-job#4253). Dispatch only to claude and openai, and to openai only when it is not over.\n\n### Owners and gates\n\nAs in the 10:50Z revision. Size refusals (88122969) remain owned by tracker#1430. Bounds signature 2a72bf79 (agent-board#782's branch) is left to the operator.\n\nMissing executor capabilities: as in the 10:50Z revision (file_bug without a health signature while bugEpic is set; clear_needs_human disabled; no release-train dispatch action). New candidate bug with no signature, so it has no owner yet: the pass budgets from a rate-limit snapshot even when the window resets during the pass (agent-board; link tracker#680).\n\nOperator asks: unchanged from the 10:50Z revision (recommend yes to each). New: agentic-job#4253 remove needs-human to restart its fix rounds (recommend yes, like agentic-job#3690).\n\n### Next checks\n\nPRs from the agent-board#636 and actions#230 implement runs. After the agent-board#636 fix merges, a board pin move and the next train run; then the wrapper pin PR to v0.6.14. Whether the 13:02Z and later passes get a full request window and start work. forge-sync drift failure. Whether edf5e96f recurs (then file_bug with signature). agentic-job#4253 and #3690 holds. bootc#136 review. tracker#1688 outcome. agent-board#1002 follow-up. tracker#1687 label and answer. #1004 progress. tracker#1685 closure. Next status update after 11-16 10:50Z.\n\nSupervisor profile: cgwalters-forge/agenthome at ce75a397b285ee000d4046bae405e0ecb6bb08d6\n"}
    

    Pass and pace. claude is under pace and openai is near it. The 12:02Z and 12:16Z passes read every candidate and found nothing ready to start. The 12:30Z to 12:52Z passes ran short on the bot token's hourly request limit, and 12:52Z (43716060890) deferred all 29 live epics. It also kept to a budget snapshot taken a minute before the limit reset. 12:42Z (43715207731) failed one operation under the same budget. The two implement requests above give claude ready work. The snapshot-near-reset behaviour looks like an agent-board defect (tracker#680), but with no health signature the executor cannot file it while bugEpic is set; a person would need to file it.

    Release train / release. The train still fails on board 72c4c7f (43713029858): agent-board#1008 changed only fixtures and docs. Triage on agent-board#636 traced the failure to repin_host, which scans every configured wrapper file. Test strings in actions' lint/tests/review_wrapper.rs and a placeholder in its README.md are not real pins, and the parser errors on them. Implement on agent-board#636 is requested. Until it ships, the v0.6.14 wrapper pin stays behind.

    actions#230. Triage says only the evidence.md refresh is left, plus closing the superseded Dependabot PRs #204 and #211. Implement is requested. tracker#982 is owned by tracker#42, so nothing is requested for it.

    held. agentic-job#4253 (for agentic-job#2070) is now held needs-human after continuation round 3 ended without a new head, the same pattern as agentic-job#3690. Operator: remove needs-human on each to restart fix rounds (recommend yes). The executor's remove_needs_human covers only merge-conflict holds.

    signatures / apply-failures. 88122969 is still owned by tracker#1430. New: edf5e96f, a timeout of the agent-board#1004 fix run (43710212977). It has a count of 1, so no bug yet.

    Other checks (runs, dispatch, queue, reviews, epics, needs-you, stranded, unclosed, unset) have the same evidence as the 12:00Z record in tracker#718. forge-sync 43716492097 failed in its drift recipe; I have not read it yet. The status update for today has already gone out. This read-only run cannot update findings documents or topic issue bodies.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  18. cgwalters-bot commented on Nov 15, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"plan_epic","epic":680,"reason":"no-runnable-work"}
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"replace_state","body":"# Supervisor state\n\n## Latest sweep: 2026-11-15 ~14:50Z (health pass)\n\nI read state 718 first (last edited 13:14Z, unchanged at re-read) and kept its record. Operator notes: unchanged since 11-14. This was the health sweep for supervisor run 43725576944. Read-only. Older detail is in this issue's edit history (index in the 11-14 08:05Z revision; 11-15 00:40Z for the release-train root cause, 07:25Z for the hold tally and the 13 promotion handoffs, 08:30Z for tracker#1688 and the release-list re-holds, 09:40Z for the coordinator-rescope gap, 10:50Z for the three implement dispatches, 13:10Z for the #636/#230 triage verdicts).\n\n### Changed since 13:10Z\n\n- Both 13:10Z implement dispatches landed. agent-board#1012 (\"Move secure-host pins only on uses: lines\") merged 13:51Z and closed agent-board#636. actions#273 merged and closed actions#230.\n- The release train recovered: run 43725581856 (14:40Z) succeeded and opened actions#274, the wrappers' pin to v0.6.14 (tracker#1673). actions#274 fails ci (lint/tests wrappers: main_pins_use_the_tested_annotation, review_wrapper_pins_its_own_actions_by_full_commit), workflows-check (zizmor ignore on cgwalters-agent.yml L196) and wrapper-runner (host configuration refused). Review 43725640139 asked for changes: the direct action drops the forwarder's egress write-policy translation. All four trace to one train defect: agent-board crates/board-forge/src/release_train.rs repin_host_line (L103-122) replaces the local forwarder `./.agentic-job-source/secure-host` with `cgwalters-forge/actions/secure-host@<merge>`. Decision (ours, build question): the train should leave the local forwarder alone, since it moves with the reusable-workflow pin; only remote secure-host pins move. actions#274 is on release-train/**, so poll fix rounds can repair it now; the train defect recurs on v0.6.15 until agent-board changes. No open issue owns it.\n- Bounds signature 37f6023a (count 1): triage of cgwalters-forge/ostree#9 (dispatch 43723179143, 14:13Z) was refused because cgwalters-forge/ostree is a promote fork in .github/pass.json L91 but in no bounds file. ostree#9 mirrors the operator's \"take this\" on upstream ostree 3696. tracker#1691 (for tracker#1689) admits the fork; it is approved and clean, and waits on the operator because it changes operator paths. The pass logs ostreedev/ostree 3696 as \"operator direction already handled\" although its run was refused; it will not retry it on its own after #1691 merges.\n- Passes: 14:26Z (43724350212) read under budget, started agentic-job#4113 and published holds. claude and openai are both near pace. Operator-comment reads on 7 items still end \"poll request budget exhausted\".\n- Size refusals (88122969) are now 8 in window, last 13:36Z (agent-board#1004 fix rounds). The owner tracker#1430 has no parent epic, so the pass never implements it; nothing has moved since 11-14. tracker#680's plan dates from 11-02 and the epics check flags it, so I asked its coordinator for a fresh plan (plan_epic).\n- tracker#890: planned 11-14 21:44Z, 25 of 26 children closed, no change needed.\n- Held agentic-job drafts #3674, #3690, #3694, #3695, #3696 and #4253 are unchanged; none is eligible for remove_needs_human (all drafts).\n\n### Requested\n\n14:50Z: plan_epic tracker#680 (no-runnable-work) and this state. No dispatch: both pools are near pace and the pass is starting work. No status update (already sent today).\n\n### Excluded from supervisor dispatch\n\nAs in the 10:50Z revision, plus tracker#982 (owned by tracker#42), agentic-job#2070 (follow agentic-job#4253), cgwalters-forge/ostree#9 (until tracker#1691 merges). agent-board#636 and actions#230 are closed. Dispatch only to claude and openai, and to openai only when it is not over.\n\n### Owners and gates\n\nAs in the 10:50Z revision. Size refusals (88122969) remain owned by tracker#1430 (needs an epic parent; see plan_epic above). Bounds 2a72bf79 (agent-board#782's branch) is left to the operator. Bounds 37f6023a is owned by tracker#1689/#1691.\n\nMissing executor capabilities: as in the 10:50Z revision (file_bug without a health signature while bugEpic is set; clear_needs_human disabled; no release-train dispatch action), plus no way to set an issue's parent epic. The read-only profile cannot write a findings document or edit a topic issue body. Unowned candidate bugs with no signature: (1) the pass budgets from a rate-limit snapshot even when the window resets during the pass (agent-board; link tracker#680); (2) the release train replaces the local secure-host forwarder in wrappers (agent-board release_train.rs L103-122; link tracker#680, tracker#1673); (3) the pass marks an operator direction handled when its mirrored dispatch was refused (agent-board; ostree 3696 example).\n\nOperator asks: unchanged from the 10:50Z revision (recommend yes to each), plus agentic-job#4253 remove needs-human (recommend yes). New: approve tracker#1691 to admit cgwalters-forge/ostree to the midstream bounds (target bounds are yours; recommend yes, since pass.json already maps the fork and you asked for ostree 3696), then re-dispatch ostree#9.\n\n### Next checks\n\nactions#274 fix rounds and merge (v0.6.14 wrappers pin). Whether tracker#680's fresh plan adopts tracker#1430 and the train forwarder defect. tracker#1691 approval, then ostree#9. Whether 37f6023a or edf5e96f recur (then file_bug with signature). agentic-job#4253 and #3690 holds. agentic-job#4113 triage result. agent-board#1004 fix round 43725907045. bootc#136 review. tracker#1688 outcome. agent-board#1002 follow-up. tracker#1687 label and answer. tracker#1685 closure. forge-sync drift failure (43716492097, not yet read). Next status update after 11-16 10:50Z.\n\nSupervisor profile: cgwalters-forge/agenthome at ce75a397b285ee000d4046bae405e0ecb6bb08d6\n"}
    

    Pass and pace. The 14:26Z pass (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/43724350212) ran within its request budget, started cgwalters-forge/agentic-job#4113 and published holds. claude and openai are both near pace. Seven operator-comment reads still end "poll request budget exhausted". No dispatch from me: the pass is starting work and no pool is under its pace.

    release / scheduled. The train recovered. Run https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/43725581856 succeeded after cgwalters-forge/agent-board#1012 merged and closed cgwalters-forge/agent-board#636 (cgwalters-forge/actions#273 closed cgwalters-forge/actions#230). Its wrapper pin PR cgwalters-forge/actions#274 fails ci, workflows-check, wrapper-runner and review. All four have one cause: agent-board's repin_host_line (crates/board-forge/src/release_train.rs L103-122) rewrites the local ./.agentic-job-source/secure-host forwarder into a direct action pin, which drops the forwarder's write-policy translation. Our decision: the train should move only remote secure-host pins. Poll fix rounds can repair actions#274 on its release-train branch. Nothing owns the agent-board defect yet, and file_bug needs a health signature while bugEpic is set, so it is recorded in state.

    signatures / epics. New bounds signature 37f6023a: triage of cgwalters-forge/ostree#9 (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/43723179143) was refused because the ostree fork is in .github/pass.json but in no bounds file. Size refusals 88122969 (8, last 13:36Z) belong to #1430, which has no parent epic, so the pass never implements it. #680 was last planned 11-02, so I ask its coordinator for a fresh plan. #890 was planned yesterday and is 25 of 26 done.

    held / queue / needs-supervisor / runs / dispatch. Unchanged since the last record: the agentic-job drafts are held for the operator, the queue entries wait on operator review, and the 13 promotion handoffs are the same set.

    Operator decides. Approve #1691, which admits cgwalters-forge/ostree to the midstream bounds (recommend yes: pass.json already maps the fork and you asked for ostree 3696). Earlier asks stand (state 718).

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  19. cgwalters-bot commented on Nov 15, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"plan_epic","epic":1215,"reason":"no-runnable-work"}
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"plan_epic","epic":1311,"reason":"no-runnable-work"}
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"plan_epic","epic":1260,"reason":"no-runnable-work"}
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"replace_state","body":"# Supervisor state\n\n## Latest sweep: 2026-11-15 ~15:35Z (daily pass)\n\nI read state 718 first (last edited 14:51Z, unchanged at re-read) and kept its record. Operator notes: unchanged since 11-14. This was the daily sweep for supervisor run 43728368589. Read-only. Older detail is in this issue's edit history (index in the 11-14 08:05Z revision; 11-15 00:40Z for the release-train root cause, 07:25Z for the hold tally and the 13 promotion handoffs, 08:30Z for tracker#1688 and the release-list re-holds, 09:40Z for the coordinator-rescope gap, 10:50Z for the three implement dispatches, 13:10Z for the #636/#230 triage verdicts, 14:50Z for the train forwarder defect, ostree#9 bounds and tracker#1691).\n\n### Changed since 14:50Z\n\n- Passes 14:40Z, 14:50Z and 15:00Z went idle on both pools because the request budget ran out before stage 4 read its candidates (101, 258 and 126 left unread). Each pass sized its share from a rate-limit snapshot taken minutes before the window reset. This is unowned candidate bug (1) below, now seen holding starts three passes running.\n- Pass 15:10Z (43728377990) had a fresh budget, considered all 258 candidates with 12 slots free and started nothing: runnable work has run out. Both pools are near pace for now but will fall under. An implement run on agentic-job#1623 was in flight at 15:30Z.\n- The plan_epic for tracker#680 (14:51Z marker) cannot help: the pass holds #680 because its 11-02 plan's apply stopped at action 4 (create_sub_issue tracker#1147) unproved, and only a person inspecting tracker#680 comment 6577063919 and replacing the plan or commenting releases it. Same kind of person-only hold: tracker#331 (refused plan, 10-28), tracker#1356 (invalid plan JSON), agent-board#830 (session plan with no dispatch record).\n- actions#274 (v0.6.14 wrappers pin): fix round 43726823987 succeeded; now approved, merge state blocked pending checks.\n- agent-board#1004 fix round 43725907045 failed on the size refusal; 88122969 now count 9 (owner tracker#1430, no epic parent).\n- Release-list items actions#187 and atomic-linux-sandbox#17 are held again by poll's stop marker, as in the 08:30Z revision; release_listed would only re-hold them.\n- No change: 13 promotion handoffs (needs-supervisor), held agentic-job drafts #3674/#3690/#3694/#3695/#3696/#4253, stale runs 43388110612/43096024384/43096023375, queue evidence on agentic-job, review gaps (agentic-job#3713, review#336/#341/#376, cgwalters-forge.github.io#1).\n\n### Requested\n\n15:35Z: plan_epic tracker#1215, tracker#1311, tracker#1260 (no-runnable-work; open children 20, 8 and 3; no earlier marker) and this state. No dispatch: the pass found nothing startable, and both pools are near pace. No status update (already sent today).\n\n### Excluded from supervisor dispatch\n\nAs in the 14:50Z revision.\n\n### Owners and gates\n\nAs in the 14:50Z revision.\n\nMissing executor capabilities: as in the 14:50Z revision (file_bug without a health signature while bugEpic is set; clear_needs_human disabled; no release-train dispatch action; no way to set an issue's parent epic; no findings-document write or topic issue-body edit). Unowned candidate bugs with no signature: (1) the pass budgets from a rate-limit snapshot even when the window resets during the pass, starving stage 4 (agent-board; link tracker#680, related agent-board#803; evidence passes 43725586327, 43726506190, 43727402180); (2) the release train replaces the local secure-host forwarder in wrappers (agent-board release_train.rs L103-122; link tracker#680, tracker#1673); (3) the pass marks an operator direction handled when its mirrored dispatch was refused (agent-board; ostree 3696 example).\n\nOperator asks: unchanged from the 14:50Z revision (recommend yes to each). New: inspect tracker#680's stopped 11-02 apply and replace its plan or comment, so the poller-bug epic can plan again (recommend: comment to release it; its children include the unowned bugs above).\n\n### Next checks\n\nWhether the three plan_epic markers yield runnable children and starts. tracker#680 release. Whether the next passes keep starving on the budget snapshot (then file bug (1) once a signature exists or the operator files it). actions#274 merge. tracker#1691 approval, then ostree#9. agentic-job#1623 implement result. agentic-job#4113 triage result. agent-board#1004 size refusals. tracker#1688 outcome. forge-sync drift failure (43716492097, not yet read). Next status update after 11-16 10:50Z.\n\nSupervisor profile: cgwalters-forge/agenthome at ce75a397b285ee000d4046bae405e0ecb6bb08d6\n"}
    

    Pass and pace. The pass runs. The 14:40Z, 14:50Z and 15:00Z passes (43725586327, 43726506190, 43727402180) went idle on both pools. In each one the request budget ran out before stage 4 read its candidates, because the pass sized its share from a rate-limit snapshot taken a few minutes before the window reset. Once the budget was fresh, the 15:10Z pass (43728377990) considered all 258 candidates with free slots and still started nothing, so runnable work has run out. Both pools are near pace for now but will fall under. I asked three infrastructure epics with open children and no recent planning request for fresh plans: tracker#1215, tracker#1311 and tracker#1260. The budget-snapshot defect is still unowned (agent-board; related agent-board#803). I cannot file it because file_bug needs a health signature while bugEpic is set, and none exists for this defect.

    epics. The 14:51Z plan_epic on tracker#680 cannot take effect. The pass holds tracker#680 because its 11-02 plan's apply stopped at action 4 (creating tracker#1147) and was never confirmed, and only a person can release that hold. tracker#331 (refused plan), tracker#1356 (invalid plan JSON) and agent-board#830 (session plan with no dispatch record) are stuck the same way. tracker#890 is fine.

    Other checks. actions#274, which moves the wrappers' pin to v0.6.14, is approved after a successful fix round and is waiting on checks. The agent-board#1004 fix round failed on the size refusal again (signature 88122969, now 9 times, owned by tracker#1430). Nothing changed since the 14:50Z record for these: the 13 promotion handoffs (needs-supervisor), the held agentic-job drafts, the stale runs, the queue and reviews evidence, and release-train scheduling. actions#187 and atomic-linux-sandbox#17 are on the release list but poll holds them again. Sending release_listed would only get them held again, so I did not. No status update: one already went out today.

    Operator asks. Inspect tracker#680's stopped apply and replace its plan or comment to release it. I recommend a comment, since it holds the poller-bug epic. Earlier asks are unchanged; tracker#1691 is still the most useful one to approve.

    Findings documents: this read-only profile cannot write one or edit a topic issue body.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  20. cgwalters-bot commented on Nov 15, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor

    Health sweep 16:35Z. I'm asking only for the state replacement. Both pools are near pace and the 16:21Z pass found nothing ready to start. The blockers named below need a person or a poller fix, and a dispatch would not move them.

    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"replace_state","body":"# Supervisor state\n\n## Latest sweep: 2026-11-15 ~16:35Z (health pass)\n\nI read state 718 first (last edited 14:51Z, unchanged at re-read) and kept its record. Operator notes: unchanged since 11-14. This was the health sweep for supervisor run 43735117071. Read-only. Older detail is in this issue's edit history (index in the 11-14 08:05Z revision; 11-15 00:40Z for the release-train root cause, 07:25Z for the hold tally and the 13 promotion handoffs, 08:30Z for tracker#1688 and the release-list re-holds, 09:40Z for the coordinator-rescope gap, 10:50Z for the three implement dispatches, 13:10Z for the #636/#230 triage verdicts, 14:50Z for the actions#274 train defect and bounds 37f6023a).\n\n### Changed since 14:50Z\n\n- actions#274 (wrappers pin v0.6.14, tracker#1673) merged 15:24Z after fix round 43726823987 and a fresh approval. The wrappers now pin remote secure-host, so the release_train.rs forwarder defect (candidate bug 2) no longer bites; dropped from the candidate list. The release train succeeded at 14:40Z and 15:47Z (43731789077); the scheduled check still lists the 11:13Z failure and should clear on the next scheduled run.\n- My 14:50Z plan_epic on tracker#680 cannot take effect. The pass holds the epic because its 11-02 plan apply is \"not proved\" (action 4, create_sub_issue tracker#1147) and is never replayed until a person comments or replaces the plan (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/issues/680#issuecomment-6577063919). tracker#1147 is in fact #680's sub-issue and closed, so the write landed. Operator ask added below. Candidate bug 4: the pass should re-check an unproved apply's writes itself instead of holding the epic for a person.\n- agentic-job#4113 triage (43725028816, 14:38Z) found merging stopped at 00:09 with 12 approved Rust test-port PRs conflicting in docs/plan.md and tests/check.rs. The pass now holds #4113 \"Waiting\" on those same PRs, so the plan meant to repair them waits on them. Their rebase rounds are blocked by size refusals (88122969, now 9 in window, last 15:04Z), still owned by tracker#1430, which has no parent epic. Candidate bug 5: the overlap wait should not apply when the plan targets the PRs it waits on.\n- Pass 16:21Z (43733667212): idle, 12 slots free, all 259 candidates held. Top hold causes: 40 assigned to the operator, 30 triage partly, 18 dispatched-already with replan scheduled, 17 open dependencies, 16 triage verdict needs-issue (\"controller: create the follow-up issue\"), 9 needs-design. claude and openai both near pace per the health check. Candidate bug 6: needs-issue verdicts wait for a controller that no longer runs after the cutover; the pass should file the follow-up itself.\n- tracker#1691 (admit cgwalters-forge/ostree to bounds) is getting a fix round (43736091668, in flight); it still needs operator approval as a target-bounds change.\n- needs-supervisor: the same 13 promotion handoffs (bootc 94/113/119/120/123, composefs-rs 49/50/59/60/64/66/67/82); midstream promotion is the operator's, no action.\n- runs: 43388110612 (poll, queued since 11-13) and 43096024384/43096023375 (review/ci, queued since 11-11) are stuck queued, not working; the operator may cancel them.\n\n### Requested\n\n16:35Z: this state only. No dispatch: pools near pace and the pass found nothing ready; the blockers above need a person or a poller fix. No status update (already sent today). No file_bug: the only repeating signature (88122969) is owned by tracker#1430.\n\n### Excluded from supervisor dispatch\n\nAs in the 14:50Z revision (cgwalters-forge/ostree#9 until tracker#1691 merges). Dispatch only to claude and openai, and to openai only when it is not over.\n\n### Owners and gates\n\nAs in the 14:50Z revision. Size refusals (88122969) owned by tracker#1430 (needs an epic parent). Bounds 2a72bf79 left to the operator. Bounds 37f6023a owned by tracker#1689/#1691.\n\nMissing executor capabilities: as in the 10:50Z revision (file_bug without a health signature while bugEpic is set; clear_needs_human disabled; no release-train dispatch action), no way to set an issue's parent epic, and no way to clear an epic's unproved-apply hold. The read-only profile cannot write a findings document or edit a topic issue body. Unowned candidate bugs with no signature (all agent-board, link tracker#680): (1) the pass budgets from a rate-limit snapshot even when the window resets during the pass; (3) the pass marks an operator direction handled when its mirrored dispatch was refused (ostree 3696); (4) unproved epic apply never re-verified; (5) overlap wait holds a plan on the PRs it repairs (agentic-job#4113); (6) needs-issue verdicts wait for the retired controller.\n\nOperator asks: unchanged from the 14:50Z revision (recommend yes to each). New: comment on tracker#680 (or replace its plan) to clear the unproved-apply hold, since tracker#1147 landed (recommend yes); parent tracker#1430 under tracker#680 so the pass can implement it, which unblocks the agentic-job rebases and #4113 (recommend yes).\n\n### Next checks\n\ntracker#680 hold cleared and its fresh plan. tracker#1691 fix round, approval, then ostree#9. agentic-job#4113 and the 12 conflicting PRs. Whether 37f6023a or edf5e96f recur (then file_bug with signature). agentic-job#4253 and #3690 holds. agent-board#1004 size refusals. Scheduled release-train check clearing. bootc#136 review. tracker#1688 outcome. tracker#1687 label and answer. tracker#1685 closure. forge-sync drift failure (43716492097, not yet read). Next status update after 11-16 10:50Z.\n\nSupervisor profile: cgwalters-forge/agenthome at ce75a397b285ee000d4046bae405e0ecb6bb08d6\n"}
    

    epics. My 14:50Z plan_epic on tracker#680 can't take effect. The pass holds the epic because the apply of its 11-02 plan is "not proved" (create_sub_issue tracker#1147), and it waits for a person to comment or replace the plan (record). tracker#1147 is #680's sub-issue and is closed, so the write did land. Operator: one comment on tracker#680 clears the hold (recommend yes). The pass should verify such writes itself. That is a candidate agent-board bug, but I can't file it without a health signature. tracker#890 is unchanged from the last record.

    queue, capacity, idle. The agentic-job#4113 triage found that merging stopped at 00:09. Twelve approved test-port PRs (#4045, #4013, #3879 and others) conflict on docs/plan.md. The pass now holds #4113 to wait on those same PRs, so the plan that would repair them never starts. Their rebase rounds keep hitting the size refusal (88122969, 9 times, last 15:04Z), which tracker#1430 owns. #1430 has no parent epic, so the pass never implements it. Operator: parent tracker#1430 under tracker#680 (recommend yes). The 16:21Z pass held all 259 candidates. The largest causes were items assigned to the operator, partly triage verdicts, scheduled replans, and 16 needs-issue verdicts that wait on a controller that no longer runs. That last one is another poller gap.

    release, scheduled. actions#274 (wrappers on v0.6.14) merged at 15:24Z after one fix round and a fresh approval. The train succeeded at 15:47Z. The scheduled-failure check still points at the 11:13Z run and should clear on the next scheduled run.

    signatures, apply-failures. The only repeating signature is 88122969, and tracker#1430 owns it, so I filed no duplicate. Bounds 37f6023a (ostree#9) has a fix in tracker#1691, which has a fix round in flight. Admitting the fork is a target-bounds change, so it still needs operator approval (recommend yes).

    needs-supervisor, held, reviews. The same 13 promotion handoffs on bootc and composefs-rs are held, and so are the same agentic-job drafts (#3674, #3690, #3694, #3695, #3696). Midstream promotion is the operator's call, and a draft can't get remove_needs_human. The reviews list is unchanged.

    runs, dispatch. Poll 43388110612 (11-13) and review/ci 43096024384/43096023375 (11-11) are stuck in the queue and doing nothing. The operator can cancel them. The dispatch check's run 39698121265 is unchanged.

    The full record is in tracker#718.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  21. cgwalters-bot commented on Nov 15, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"replace_state","body":"# Supervisor state\n\n## Latest sweep: 2026-11-15 ~17:45Z (daily pass)\n\nI read state 718 first (last edited 16:37Z, unchanged at re-read) and kept its record. Operator notes: unchanged since 11-14. This was the daily pass for supervisor run 43741933160. Read-only. Older detail is in this issue's edit history (index in the 11-14 08:05Z revision; 11-15 00:40Z for the release-train root cause, 07:25Z for the hold tally and the 13 promotion handoffs, 08:30Z for tracker#1688 and the release-list re-holds, 09:40Z for the coordinator-rescope gap, 10:50Z for the three implement dispatches, 13:10Z for the #636/#230 triage verdicts, 14:50Z for the actions#274 train defect and bounds 37f6023a, 16:35Z for candidate bugs 4 to 6 and the #680 unproved-apply hold).\n\n### Changed since 16:35Z\n\n- Pass 17:22Z (43740777137): idle again, all candidates held for the same causes as at 16:21Z. claude and openai near pace, so the idle slots are not a capacity gap. New in its log: \"operator comments error: poll request budget exhausted; retried each pass\" on seven items, including tracker#680 and tracker#1691. An operator comment there may be read a pass late. Watch whether it recurs; if it does, it is an agent-board budget bug (link tracker#680).\n- tracker#1691 (ostree bounds): fix round 43736091668 landed; the review approved head f5a01b6 at 17:37Z with one follow-up (the new comment.toml rule drops bootc-dev forks such as homebrew-bcvk from triage/research comment admission). It still shows changes requested and blocked, and it remains the operator's target-bounds decision.\n- Release train succeeded again at 16:47Z (43737426072). The scheduled check still lists the 11:13Z schedule failure until the next scheduled run.\n- Size refusals (88122969) unchanged since 15:04Z; still owned by tracker#1430.\n- needs-supervisor: the same 13 promotion handoffs; the health report shows the first three. Midstream promotion is the operator's.\n- Release list: actions#187 and atomic-linux-sandbox#17 are open and held, but each was released before and re-held by poll at the same stop marker (actions#187 on 11-12, atomic-linux-sandbox#17 on 11-06). Releasing them again would loop, so I did not.\n\n### Requested\n\n17:45Z: this state only. No dispatch: pools near pace and nothing is ready. No status update (already sent today). No file_bug: the only repeating signature is owned by tracker#1430.\n\n### Excluded from supervisor dispatch\n\nAs in the 14:50Z revision (cgwalters-forge/ostree#9 until tracker#1691 merges). Dispatch only to claude and openai, and to openai only when it is not over.\n\n### Owners and gates\n\nAs in the 14:50Z revision. Size refusals (88122969) owned by tracker#1430 (needs an epic parent). Bounds 2a72bf79 left to the operator. Bounds 37f6023a owned by tracker#1689/#1691.\n\nMissing executor capabilities: as in the 10:50Z revision (file_bug without a health signature while bugEpic is set; clear_needs_human disabled; no release-train dispatch action), no way to set an issue's parent epic, and no way to clear an epic's unproved-apply hold. The read-only profile cannot write a findings document or edit a topic issue body. Unowned candidate bugs with no signature (all agent-board, link tracker#680): (1) the pass budgets from a rate-limit snapshot even when the window resets during the pass; (3) the pass marks an operator direction handled when its mirrored dispatch was refused (ostree 3696); (4) unproved epic apply never re-verified; (5) overlap wait holds a plan on the PRs it repairs (agentic-job#4113); (6) needs-issue verdicts wait for the retired controller; (7, watch) operator-comment reads dropped when the pass request budget runs out.\n\nOperator asks (recommend yes to each): unchanged from the 14:50Z revision; comment on tracker#680 (or replace its plan) to clear the unproved-apply hold, since tracker#1147 landed; parent tracker#1430 under tracker#680 so the pass can implement it, which unblocks the agentic-job rebases and #4113; approve tracker#1691 (target bounds), deciding whether bootc-dev forks should keep comment admission.\n\n### Next checks\n\ntracker#680 hold cleared and its fresh plan. tracker#1691 approval, then ostree#9. Operator-comment budget warnings recurring. agentic-job#4113 and the 12 conflicting PRs. Whether 37f6023a or edf5e96f recur (then file_bug with signature). agentic-job#4253 and #3690 holds. agent-board#1004 size refusals. Scheduled release-train check clearing. bootc#136 review. tracker#1688 outcome. tracker#1687 label and answer. tracker#1685 closure. forge-sync drift failure (43716492097, not yet read). Next status update after 11-16 10:50Z.\n\nSupervisor profile: cgwalters-forge/agenthome at ce75a397b285ee000d4046bae405e0ecb6bb08d6\n"}
    

    Daily pass 17:45Z. I'm asking only for the state replacement. Both pools are near pace, the 17:22Z pass found nothing ready to start, and today's status update has already gone out. Most checks are unchanged since the 16:35Z sweep (#656 (comment)).

    Pass and pace. The pass ran at 17:22Z (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/43740777137) and started nothing. Every candidate is held for the same reasons as before: assigned to the operator, partly-done triage verdicts, replans already scheduled, open dependencies, needs-issue verdicts, and overlap waits on the conflicting agentic-job test-port PRs. Both pools are near pace, so the free slots are not a capacity gap. One new thing in its log: reads of operator comments on seven items, tracker#680 and tracker#1691 among them, were skipped because the pass's request budget ran out ("retried each pass"). I'm watching this. If it recurs, it is an agent-board bug, because an operator comment that clears a hold would be read late.

    signatures / apply-failures. The only repeating signature is the size refusal on rebase pushes. It hasn't recurred since 15:04Z and tracker#1430 still owns it. The four other signatures have each been seen once.

    needs-supervisor. These are the same 13 midstream promotion handoffs. Promoting them is the operator's call, so I'm not asking for anything.

    epics. tracker#680 is still held on its unproved 11-02 apply, even though tracker#1147 landed. tracker#890 is still stale. tracker#331 and tracker#1356 still wait for a person to replace their plans.

    queue / held / runs. The PRs that left the agentic-job queue are the 12 approved test-port PRs that conflict in docs/plan.md and tests/check.rs. Their rebases are blocked by the size refusals (tracker#1430). The holds on agentic-job#3674 and #3690 haven't changed. The three runs stuck in the queue since 11-11 and 11-13 are still not working, and the operator may cancel them.

    scheduled. The release train succeeded at 16:47Z (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/43737426072). The check still lists the 11:13Z scheduled failure and should clear on the next scheduled run.

    needs-human queue. actions#187 and atomic-linux-sandbox#17 are on the release list and still held. Poll re-held each one at the same stop marker after an earlier release, so a second release would just loop. I didn't request one.

    Operator decisions (I recommend yes to each):

    • Comment on tracker#680, or replace its plan, to clear the unproved-apply hold.
    • Parent tracker#1430 under tracker#680 so the pass can fix the size refusals.
    • Approve tracker#1691, the ostree target-bounds change. Its 17:37Z review approved head f5a01b6 but noted that the new rule drops bootc-dev forks from triage and research comment admission. Decide whether to keep that or follow up.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  22. cgwalters-bot commented on Nov 15, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type": "supervisor_action", "action": "comment", "repository": "cgwalters-forge/agent-board", "item": 840, "body": "The pass is again skipping operator comments once its request budget runs out, the starvation #876 was meant to end. Every pass since 17:45Z on 2026-11-15 (tracker runs 43742898416, 43743829603, 43744781086, 43745760050, 43747194243) logs \"operator comments error: poll request budget exhausted; retried each pass\" on the same seven items, among them tracker#680 and tracker#1691, while stage 4 leaves 250+ candidates unread. No operator comment has been lost yet, but a new one on those items would go unread. The fix belongs here or in a reopened #876 (tracker#680)."}
    {"type": "supervisor_action", "action": "replace_state", "body": "# Supervisor state\n\n## Latest sweep: 2026-11-15 ~18:55Z (health pass)\n\nI read state 718 first (last edited 17:48Z, unchanged at re-read) and kept its record. Operator notes: unchanged since 11-14. Health from supervisor run 43748361118. Read-only. Older detail is in this issue's edit history (index in the 11-14 08:05Z revision; 11-15 00:40Z for the release-train root cause, 07:25Z for the hold tally and the 13 promotion handoffs, 08:30Z for tracker#1688 and the release-list re-holds, 09:40Z for the coordinator-rescope gap, 10:50Z for the three implement dispatches, 13:10Z for the #636/#230 triage verdicts, 14:50Z for the actions#274 train defect and bounds 37f6023a, 16:35Z for candidate bugs 4 to 6 and the #680 unproved-apply hold, 17:45Z for the first operator-comment budget warning).\n\n### Changed since 17:45Z\n\n- The pass is starting work again: 17:55Z planning (tracker#782, run 43744477149) plus a check rerun, 18:05Z one fix, 18:15Z implement agent-board#1016 (claude, 43746752259, in flight), 18:31Z (43747194243) planning on tracker#1224 (triage 43748094909, openai, succeeded). claude and openai are both near pace, so the free slots are not a capacity gap. The capacity check reads unavailable as of 18:47Z, while a poll was in flight.\n- Candidate 7 confirmed: every pass since 17:45Z (43742898416, 43743829603, 43744781086, 43745760050, 43747194243) logs \"operator comments error: poll request budget exhausted\" on the same seven items (tracker#680, #1691, #674, #677, #982, agent-board#257, composefs-rs#66), and stage 4 leaves 250+ candidates unread. It reopens what agent-board#876 fixed. No operator comment has been missed yet (none on #680 since 10-17; #1691's latest operator action is the 16:32Z review). With no health signature, file_bug is refused while bugEpic is set, so I requested a comment on agent-board#840 instead.\n- tracker#1691: still CHANGES_REQUESTED/BLOCKED on the operator's approval of the head; the pass names it as blocker for eight items.\n- Signatures, apply-failures, needs-supervisor (13 promotion handoffs), held, queue, reviews, runs (the ghost runs 43388110612, 43096024384, 43096023375, 39698121265), dispatch, epics (#680, #890): unchanged since 17:45Z.\n\n### Requested\n\n18:55Z: comment on agent-board#840 (operator-comment budget regression) and this state. No dispatch: pools near pace. No status update (already sent today). No file_bug: 88122969 is owned by tracker#1430, and the other signatures have count 1.\n\n### Excluded from supervisor dispatch\n\nAs in the 14:50Z revision (cgwalters-forge/ostree#9 until tracker#1691 merges). Dispatch only to claude and openai, and to openai only when it is not over. agent-board#840 now holds a supervisor comment.\n\n### Owners and gates\n\nAs in the 14:50Z revision. Size refusals (88122969) owned by tracker#1430 (needs an epic parent). Bounds 2a72bf79 left to the operator. Bounds 37f6023a owned by tracker#1689/#1691. Operator-comment budget starvation: agent-board#840 (regression of #876).\n\nMissing executor capabilities: as in the 10:50Z revision (file_bug without a health signature while bugEpic is set; clear_needs_human disabled; no release-train dispatch action), no way to set an issue's parent epic, and no way to clear an epic's unproved-apply hold. The read-only profile cannot write a findings document or edit a topic issue body. Unowned candidate bugs with no signature (all agent-board, link tracker#680): (1) the pass budgets from a rate-limit snapshot even when the window resets during the pass; (3) the pass marks an operator direction handled when its mirrored dispatch was refused (ostree 3696); (4) unproved epic apply never re-verified; (5) overlap wait holds a plan on the PRs it repairs (agentic-job#4113); (6) needs-issue verdicts wait for the retired controller. (7) is now recorded on agent-board#840.\n\nOperator asks (recommend yes to each): unchanged from the 14:50Z revision; comment on tracker#680 (or replace its plan) to clear the unproved-apply hold, since tracker#1147 landed; parent tracker#1430 under tracker#680 so the pass can implement it, which unblocks the agentic-job rebases and #4113; approve tracker#1691 (target bounds), deciding whether bootc-dev forks should keep comment admission; reopen agent-board#876 or let #840 carry the operator-comment budget fix.\n\n### Next checks\n\nagent-board#1016 implement outcome. tracker#1224 planning result. Operator-comment budget warnings (whether #840 picks them up). tracker#680 hold cleared and its fresh plan. tracker#1691 approval, then ostree#9. agentic-job#4113 and the 12 conflicting PRs. Whether 37f6023a or edf5e96f recur (then file_bug with signature). agentic-job#4253 and #3690 holds. agent-board#1004 size refusals. Scheduled release-train check clearing. bootc#136 review. tracker#1688 outcome. tracker#1687 label and answer. tracker#1685 closure. forge-sync drift failure (43716492097, not yet read). Next status update after 11-16 10:50Z.\n\nSupervisor profile: cgwalters-forge/agenthome at ce75a397b285ee000d4046bae405e0ecb6bb08d6\n"}
    

    Pass and pools. The pass is running and starting work: planning on tracker#782 and tracker#1224, one fix round, and an implement run on agent-board#1016 that is still going (pass 43747194243). claude and openai are both near pace, so the free slots are not a capacity gap. I dispatched nothing.

    Operator comments starved again (new). Every pass since 17:45Z logs "operator comments error: poll request budget exhausted" on the same seven items, among them tracker#680 and tracker#1691 (for example 43745760050). This undoes what agent-board#876 fixed. None of the operator's comments has been missed yet. With bugEpic set, the executor refuses a file_bug that has no signature, so I requested a short comment on the open agent-board#840 instead. Operator: reopen #876, or let #840 carry the fix (recommended: #840).

    Unchanged since the last record. Size refusals (88122969) are still owned by tracker#1430, and the other signatures have count 1. The 13 promotion handoffs (needs-supervisor) wait on the operator, who owns midstream promotion. The held, queue and reviews checks show the same agentic-job holds and conflicting PRs as before, behind #4113 and tracker#1430. The runs and dispatch checks list GitHub ghost runs that cannot be cancelled. The epics check covers the #680 unproved-apply hold. tracker#1691 still waits on the operator's approval of its head (target bounds), and the pass reports that it holds eight items. No status update: today's has already gone out.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  23. cgwalters-bot commented on Nov 15, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"plan_epic","epic":890,"reason":"no-runnable-work"}
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"plan_epic","epic":160,"reason":"no-runnable-work"}
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"plan_epic","epic":674,"reason":"no-runnable-work"}
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"replace_state","body":"# Supervisor state\n\n## Latest sweep: 2026-11-15 ~19:50Z (daily pass)\n\nI read state 718 first (last edited 18:57Z, unchanged at re-read) and kept its record. Operator notes: unchanged since 11-14. Health from supervisor run 43753628716 (sweep 19:39Z). Read-only. Older detail is in this issue's edit history (index in the 11-14 08:05Z revision; 11-15 00:40Z for the release-train root cause, 07:25Z for the hold tally and the 13 promotion handoffs, 08:30Z for tracker#1688 and the release-list re-holds, 09:40Z for the coordinator-rescope gap, 10:50Z for the three implement dispatches, 13:10Z for the #636/#230 triage verdicts, 14:50Z for the actions#274 train defect and bounds 37f6023a, 16:35Z for candidate bugs 4 to 6 and the #680 unproved-apply hold, 17:45Z for the first operator-comment budget warning, 18:55Z for candidate 7 on agent-board#840).\n\n### Changed since 18:55Z\n\n- The operator approved tracker#1691 (target bounds) at 19:33Z on head f5a01b6. It is mergeable, not yet in the merge queue; the poll should queue it. ostree#9 stays excluded until it merges.\n- claude is well under pace with free slots; openai is near. Pass 43752913296 started no implement: \"schedule: no candidate started\", every candidate held as \"dispatched already\" until a re-plan date up to a week out (agentic-job#4140 first), focus epic tracker#1671 0 ready. It spent the slot on early planning of tracker#596 (astra) and three fix rounds. Fixes in flight: atomic-linux-sandbox#18, #19, agentic-job#3333, agent-board#1004; implement agentic-job#1623.\n- The operator's own fixes for this are open: tracker#1700 (let claude run ahead of pace, wip 20) is approved but conflicts with tracker#1699 (merged 19:28Z, six open bot PRs per repository); tracker#1698 (agent recovery instead of operator parking) has changes requested.\n- Around 19:02Z conflicted held PRs were closed as stale and around 19:15Z reopened (\"should be rebased, not re-planned\"): actions#187, #208, #220, tracker#1295, #1303, #1444, #1448, #1452 at least. They are drafts, DIRTY, held needs-human; the rebase waits on agent recovery. actions#187 is in the release list but was released 11-11 and re-held 11-12 by poll, so release_listed would loop; not requested.\n- Operator-comment budget warnings continue (five items in 43752913296; #840 holds the supervisor comment).\n- Signatures, apply-failures, needs-supervisor (bootc and composefs-rs promotion handoffs), runs (ghost runs 43388110612, 43096024384, 43096023375, 39698121265), dispatch, queue, epics (#680, #890): unchanged.\n\n### Requested\n\n19:50Z: plan_epic on tracker#890, #160 and #674 (no-runnable-work), the operator-labelled live epics not brought forward in the last day and with no run in flight, to give claude ready work. Epics labelled by the bot (#1671, #1396, #1456 and others) are not live for plan_epic. No dispatch: every claude candidate sits in the pass's re-plan hold, which the supervisor must not pre-empt. No status update (sent today). No file_bug: 88122969 is owned by tracker#1430; other signatures have count 1.\n\n### Excluded from supervisor dispatch\n\nAs in the 14:50Z revision (cgwalters-forge/ostree#9 until tracker#1691 merges). Dispatch only to claude and openai, and to openai only when it is not over. agent-board#840 holds a supervisor comment.\n\n### Owners and gates\n\nAs in the 14:50Z revision. Size refusals (88122969) owned by tracker#1430 (needs an epic parent). Bounds 2a72bf79 left to the operator. Bounds 37f6023a owned by tracker#1689/#1691. Operator-comment budget starvation: agent-board#840 (regression of #876). plan_epic only reaches epics last labelled by the operator: 1047, 890, 766 (needs-design), 680, 677, 674, 596, 160.\n\nMissing executor capabilities: as in the 10:50Z revision (file_bug without a health signature while bugEpic is set; clear_needs_human disabled; no release-train dispatch action), no way to set an issue's parent epic, no way to clear an epic's unproved-apply hold, and plan_epic cannot reach bot-labelled epics. The read-only profile cannot write a findings document or edit a topic issue body. Unowned candidate bugs with no signature (all agent-board, link tracker#680): (1) budget from a stale rate-limit snapshot; (3) operator direction marked handled after a refused mirror dispatch; (4) unproved epic apply never re-verified; (5) overlap wait holds a plan on the PRs it repairs (agentic-job#4113); (6) needs-issue verdicts wait for the retired controller. (7) is on agent-board#840.\n\nOperator asks (recommend yes to each): rebase or let the pass rebase tracker#1700 and merge it; resolve the requested changes on tracker#1698 so conflicted held PRs are rebased by agents; comment on tracker#680 (or replace its plan) to clear the unproved-apply hold; parent tracker#1430 under tracker#680; reopen agent-board#876 or let #840 carry the operator-comment budget fix; consider labelling the bot-labelled epics yourself so plan_epic can reach them.\n\n### Next checks\n\ntracker#1691 queued and merged, then ostree#9. tracker#1700 and #1698 outcome and whether claude starts implement work. Plan results on #890, #160, #674. tracker#596 planning (astra). agentic-job#1623 implement. Reopened held PRs rebased. Operator-comment budget warnings. tracker#680 hold. agentic-job#4113 and the conflicting PRs. Whether 37f6023a or edf5e96f recur (then file_bug with signature). forge-sync drift failure (43716492097, still unread). Next status update after 11-16 10:50Z.\n\nSupervisor profile: cgwalters-forge/agenthome at ce75a397b285ee000d4046bae405e0ecb6bb08d6\n"}
    

    Pass and pace. The pass runs and starts work: fix rounds, a planning run on tracker#596 and an implement on agentic-job#1623 are in flight. claude is well under pace with free slots and openai is near pace. The latest pass (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/43752913296) started no implement: every candidate is held as already dispatched until its re-plan date, and the focus epic tracker#1671 has nothing ready. To give claude ready work I ask for fresh plans on tracker#890, #160 and #674. These are the live epics the operator labelled that were not brought forward in the last day. The bot labelled #1671, #1396 and #1456, so plan_epic cannot reach them. The operator's own fixes are open: tracker#1700 (let claude run ahead of pace) is approved but now conflicts with tracker#1699, which merged at 19:28Z. tracker#1698 (agent recovery) has changes requested. Status stays at-risk until claude takes implement work. No status update was sent; one already went out today.

    Held and reopened PRs. Around 19:02Z the bot closed conflicted held PRs as stale and reopened them about 15 minutes later for rebasing: actions#187, #208, #220 and tracker#1295, #1303, #1444, #1448, #1452. They are drafts with conflicts. The rebase waits on agent recovery (tracker#1698). actions#187 is in the release list, but the poll already re-held it once after its 11-11 release, so I did not request release_listed again.

    tracker#1691. The operator approved it at 19:33Z. It is mergeable but not yet queued. The poll should queue it, and the unqueued check will flag it after an hour if not. ostree#9 stays excluded until it merges.

    Unchanged. Signatures: 88122969 is owned by tracker#1430 and the rest have count 1. Also unchanged: apply-failures, needs-supervisor promotion handoffs, the ghost runs, dispatch, queue, epics #680 and #890, and the operator-comment budget warnings on agent-board#840.

    Operator decisions (recommend yes): merge tracker#1700 after its rebase; settle tracker#1698; clear the unproved-apply hold on tracker#680; parent tracker#1430 under #680; label the bot-labelled epics yourself so plan_epic can reach them. The read-only profile cannot write findings documents or edit topic issue bodies.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  24. cgwalters-bot commented on Nov 15, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"dispatch","repository":"cgwalters-forge/agent-board","item":1009,"kind":"triage","pool":"claude","reason":"no-plan"}
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"dispatch","repository":"cgwalters-forge/agent-board","item":1019,"kind":"triage","pool":"claude","reason":"no-plan"}
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"dispatch","repository":"cgwalters-forge/agent-board","item":1011,"kind":"triage","pool":"claude","reason":"no-plan"}
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"dispatch","repository":"cgwalters-forge/agent-board","item":1010,"kind":"triage","pool":"claude","reason":"no-plan"}
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"replace_state","body":"# Supervisor state\n\n## Latest sweep: 2026-11-15 ~21:05Z\n\nI read state 718 first (last edited 19:53Z, unchanged at re-read) and kept its record. Operator notes are unchanged. Health came from this run's report and pass 43759635161 (20:43Z). The sweep was read-only. Older detail is in this issue's edit history (index in the 11-14 08:05Z revision; 11-15 19:50Z for the 19:02Z close-and-reopen of held PRs and the plan_epic picks).\n\n### Changed since 19:50Z\n\n- tracker#1691 merged at 20:00Z and tracker#1700 at 20:08Z. tracker#1698 still conflicts and has changes requested.\n- ostree#9 is no longer excluded, now that tracker#1691 has merged.\n- Pass 43759635161 still started nothing for claude or openai (both under pace, 18 slots free). Three things held it. The request budget left 209 candidates unread (owned by agent-board#803). The new six-PR cap held implement in tracker and agentic-job (owned by agent-board#1020; its fix agent-board#1021 is approved and green and should be merged by the poll; agent-board#1018 covers midstream drafts). Every implement candidate it read had already been dispatched and waits for its re-plan date. The pass is planning focus epic tracker#1671, so the early plans requested at 19:50Z for #890, #160 and #674 wait until it finishes (one epic per pass).\n- New refusal: implement run 43758005696 on rhel-bootc-examples#33 failed the bounds check: the source issue in tracker is not within midstream.toml's fork-only rule. This follows 75a584e. Count 1; no health signature, so no file_bug. Changing the bounds is the operator's call.\n- needs-supervisor: anaconda#2 and #3 joined the conflicting handoff-PR holds (drafts on a midstream fork, in the promote queue).\n- agentic-job v0.6.15 was released at 20:01Z; dispatch is pinned to v0.6.14 (090d0f2). This needs a reviewed pin PR.\n- Signatures (88122969, owned by tracker#1430), runs (ghost runs 43388110612, 43096024384, 43096023375, 39698121265), dispatch, queue (agentic-job#3879 is approved but conflicting) and epics (#680, #890): unchanged.\n\n### Requested\n\n21:05Z: triage (claude, no-plan) on agent-board#1009, #1019, #1011 and #1010, the open, unplanned bot-filed pass issues with no run in flight. These use claude's free slots without opening PRs. Skipped agent-board#1018 (agent-board#1021 refers to it). No status update (sent today). No file_bug.\n\n### Excluded from supervisor dispatch\n\nAs in the 14:50Z revision (cgwalters-forge/ostree#9 until tracker#1691 merges). Dispatch only to claude and openai, and to openai only when it is not over. agent-board#840 holds a supervisor comment.\n\n### Owners and gates\n\nAs in the 14:50Z revision. Size refusals (88122969) owned by tracker#1430 (needs an epic parent). Bounds 2a72bf79 left to the operator. Bounds 37f6023a owned by tracker#1689/#1691. Operator-comment budget starvation: agent-board#840 (regression of #876). plan_epic only reaches epics last labelled by the operator: 1047, 890, 766 (needs-design), 680, 677, 674, 596, 160.\n\nMissing executor capabilities: as in the 10:50Z revision (file_bug without a health signature while bugEpic is set; clear_needs_human disabled; no release-train dispatch action), no way to set an issue's parent epic, no way to clear an epic's unproved-apply hold, and plan_epic cannot reach bot-labelled epics. The read-only profile cannot write a findings document or edit a topic issue body. Unowned candidate bugs with no signature (all agent-board, link tracker#680): (1) budget from a stale rate-limit snapshot; (3) operator direction marked handled after a refused mirror dispatch; (4) unproved epic apply never re-verified; (5) overlap wait holds a plan on the PRs it repairs (agentic-job#4113); (6) needs-issue verdicts wait for the retired controller. (7) is on agent-board#840.\n\nOperator asks (recommend yes to each): fix midstream bounds so tracker source issues are admitted for midstream forks with issues disabled (rhel-bootc-examples#33); resolve the requested changes on tracker#1698; comment on tracker#680 to clear the unproved-apply hold; parent tracker#1430 under tracker#680; consider labelling the bot-labelled epics yourself so plan_epic can reach them.\n\n### Next checks\n\nTriage results on agent-board#1009, #1019, #1011 and #1010. Whether agent-board#1021 merges and the pin carries it. Plans for #1671, then #890, #160 and #674. Whether the bounds refusal recurs (then file_bug with its signature). ostree#9 dispatch. The v0.6.15 pin PR. Reopened held PRs rebased. tracker#596 planning. agentic-job#1623. forge-sync drift failure (43716492097). Next status update after 11-16 10:50Z.\n\nSupervisor profile: cgwalters-forge/agenthome at ce75a397b285ee000d4046bae405e0ecb6bb08d6\n"}
    

    claude and openai are under pace with free slots, and the latest pass (43759635161) still started no implement work. Three things held it. The request budget left 209 candidates unread (agent-board#803). The new six-PR cap held implement in tracker and agentic-job (agent-board#1020; its fix agent-board#1021 is approved and green, so the poll should merge it). Every implement candidate it read waits for its re-plan date. The pass is planning focus epic tracker#1671 first, so the early plans for #890, #160 and #674 wait a pass. To use claude now without adding PRs, I ask for triage on four unplanned bot-filed pass issues. The status update is not marked on-track; one was already sent today.

    New refusal: implement run 43758005696 on rhel-bootc-examples#33 failed the bounds check. Its source issue is in tracker, and since 75a584e midstream.toml admits only topic forks. This is the first occurrence and it has no health signature, so I filed no bug. Operator: allow tracker as a source repository for midstream forks? Recommended: yes.

    Merged since the last sweep: tracker#1691 and #1700. tracker#1698 still conflicts and has changes requested.

    needs-supervisor: anaconda#2 and #3 joined the bootc and composefs-rs handoff conflicts. They are drafts on a midstream fork, waiting for the operator to promote them. The executor has no action for these.

    release: agentic-job v0.6.15 is out and dispatch is pinned to v0.6.14. This needs a reviewed pin PR.

    Unchanged: apply-failures (88122969 is owned by tracker#1430). runs are the same ghost runs. queue: agentic-job#3879 is approved but conflicting and needs a rebase; there is no action for that here. epics #680 and #890 are as recorded in state.

    Missing capabilities: this profile cannot write the findings document or edit topic issue bodies. file_bug needs a health signature while bugEpic is set. There is no rebase action.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  25. cgwalters-bot commented on Nov 15, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"comment","repository":"cgwalters-forge/tracker","item":1605,"body":"A third case: poll.yml has been disabled_manually since 2026-11-15 21:07:50Z, and its last run (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/43761490771) was cancelled mid-pass. A pass running outside the workflow keeps dispatching, but it publishes no `.state/pass.json` (see agent-board#1010). Health reported `poll` ok in https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/43775378804, while pace, capacity and held were unavailable. The health check should also fail when the poll workflow is disabled."}
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"replace_state","body":"# Supervisor state\n\n## Latest sweep: 2026-11-15 ~23:45Z\n\nI read state 718 first (last edited 21:06Z, unchanged at re-read) and kept its record. Operator notes are unchanged. Health came from this run's artifact (supervisor run 43775378804). The sweep was read-only. Older detail is in this issue's edit history (index in the 11-14 08:05Z revision; 11-15 19:50Z for the held-PR reopen and plan_epic picks; 11-15 21:05Z for the pass blockers and the rhel-bootc-examples#33 bounds refusal).\n\n### Changed since 21:05Z\n\n- The hosted poll is off. poll.yml has been disabled_manually since 21:07:50Z, and its last run 43761490771 was cancelled mid-pass. No operator comment explains it. Since then, dispatches (fix rounds at 21:20, 22:02, 22:24 and 23:06Z, implements on agent-board#1023/#1024/#1025, agentic-job#4113/#4259) come straight from the bot account, from a pass run outside the workflow. The bot's agent-board#1010 note at 21:44Z says a local `pass --apply` fails to write `.state/pass.json`. So no pass state is published. That is why pace, capacity, held, stranded and reviews are now unavailable. Health still reports `poll` ok, which is the gap tracker#1605 covers; evidence added there.\n- Nothing merges while the poll is off: agent-board#1021 (approved and clean since 20:46Z) and tracker#1701 (agent-board pin to e6b525b, approved and clean) wait.\n- Triage results: agent-board#1009 not-done (only the skip-line wording is worth fixing), #1019 partly (openPrCap is on; agentRecovery waits on tracker#1698; pass.json options are not in `unset`), #1011 not-done (a `pass --pull` selector), #1010 not-done (pin/config skew, mostly tracker-side). Each needs implement under an epic plan; none has an epic parent.\n- New signatures, each count 1 (no file_bug): 6bd43eae (org rules for tracker), 8bce83dd (replacement branch moved), b6fa244c (missing data), edf5e96f (timeout). 88122969 is at count 4, still owned by tracker#1430. Needs-you \"no concrete question\" (fdf7497e, 56) is owned by tracker#1443; \"incomplete sources\" is count 1.\n- needs-human queue: 6 open items, all operator questions or held bugs. No releaseList item is still held. Nothing to clear.\n\n### Requested\n\n23:45Z: a comment on tracker#1605 adding the disabled-workflow case. No dispatch, because pace cannot be observed and the local pass is already starting claude work. No status update (sent today). No file_bug.\n\n### Excluded from supervisor dispatch\n\nAs in the 14:50Z revision. ostree#9 is no longer excluded. Dispatch only to claude and openai, and to openai only when it is not over. agent-board#840 and tracker#1605 hold supervisor comments.\n\n### Owners and gates\n\nAs in the 21:05Z revision. Size refusals (88122969): tracker#1430. Needs-you placeholders: tracker#1443. Poll chain and health-ok gap: tracker#1605. Bounds 2a72bf79 and the rhel-bootc-examples#33 refusal are left to the operator. Bounds 37f6023a: tracker#1689/#1691 (merged). plan_epic only reaches epics last labelled by the operator: 1047, 890, 766 (needs-design), 680, 677, 674, 596, 160.\n\nMissing executor capabilities: as in the 21:05Z revision, plus file_bug cannot file a failure with no health signature while bugEpic is set (the disabled poll and the local state-write failure have none). The read-only profile cannot write a findings document or edit a topic issue body.\n\nOperator asks (recommend yes to each): re-enable poll.yml, or say the local pass is meant to run for now and make it publish state; fix midstream bounds for rhel-bootc-examples#33; resolve the requested changes on tracker#1698; comment on tracker#680 to clear the unproved-apply hold; parent tracker#1430 under tracker#680; label the bot-labelled epics yourself so plan_epic can reach them.\n\n### Next checks\n\nWhether poll.yml is back on and a pass publishes state (then pace, capacity and held become observable again). agent-board#1021 and tracker#1701 merging. Implement planning for agent-board#1009, #1011, #1019 and #1010. Plans for #1671, then #890, #160 and #674. Whether any count-1 signature recurs (then file_bug with its signature). The v0.6.15 pin PR. agentic-job#1623. Next status update after 11-16 10:50Z.\n\nSupervisor profile: cgwalters-forge/agenthome at b68e3f632a870aa1bb681b811693bdf86c1ff077\n"}
    

    Pass and pools. The hosted poll is off: poll.yml has been disabled manually since 21:07Z, and its last run (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/43761490771) was cancelled mid-pass. Work still starts. Since then the bot account has dispatched claude fix rounds and implements (agent-board#1023, #1024, #1025, agentic-job#4113, #4259) from a pass running outside the workflow. Per the bot's note on agent-board#1010, that pass cannot write its state file, so nothing is published. That is why pace, capacity, held, stranded and reviews are unavailable this run. Whether any pool is under pace can't be told from here. Nothing merges either: agent-board#1021 and tracker#1701 have both been approved and clean for hours. Health still reports poll ok, the gap tracker#1605 owns, so the comment above adds this case there. I dispatched nothing, to avoid racing the local pass while pace is unobservable.

    Triage follow-up. All four triages I asked for at 21:05Z finished. agent-board#1009, #1011 and #1010 are not done and #1019 is partly done. Each needs an implement-sized PR and none has an epic parent yet, so the pass has to plan them. None is close evidence.

    Signatures and apply failures. 88122969 (count 4) is still owned by tracker#1430. Four new signatures appeared, each at count 1, so no bug yet. The needs-you "no concrete question" signature (56) is owned by tracker#1443. "incomplete sources" is at count 1.

    Unchanged. Ghost runs (runs, dispatch), queue (agentic-job#3817, #3835 and #3879 are approved but conflicting; fix rounds are running on that series), epics #680 and #890, and the agentic-job v0.6.15 pin, which still needs a reviewed PR.

    needs-human. 6 open items, all genuine operator questions or held bugs. No releaseList item is still held, and nothing qualifies for clearing.

    Operator asks (recommend yes): re-enable poll.yml, or confirm the local pass is meant to run for now and have it publish state. The other standing asks are in the state issue.

    Missing capability: file_bug requires a health signature while bugEpic is set, so the local pass's state-write failure cannot be filed from here.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  26. cgwalters-bot commented on Nov 16, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"dispatch","repository":"cgwalters-forge/agent-board","item":1018,"kind":"triage","pool":"claude","reason":"no-plan"}
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"comment","repository":"cgwalters-forge/agent-board","item":994,"body":"Evidence from 2026-11-16 (pass https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/43782385458): the cap's land-first choice names pull requests that cannot land, so ready work behind them waits indefinitely. agent-board#1021 (approved) waits on #782, which is on branch plan-comment-table, outside the fix-round bounds, with changes requested since 11-07, so it gets no fix rounds. agent-board#1031 waits on draft #957, and actions#208, #220 and #278 wait on draft actions#139. In agentic-job, ten approved pull requests (#3789, #3817 and #3835 among them) wait on #3333, which conflicts and is on its second rebase round, and the repository is well past the cap, so new starts there are held (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/43781389188). Expected: skip drafts, out-of-bounds branches and changes-requested pull requests when choosing what to land first, and report a blocker that cannot move."}
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"comment","repository":"cgwalters-forge/agent-board","item":803,"body":"Fresh evidence from 2026-11-16: the claude pool is under pace and the hosted passes start little. https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/43781389188 went idle with claude under pace because stage 4's budget left 12 candidates unread, the first being cgwalters-forge/review#381, which already has an accepted implement plan. The next pass, https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/43782385458, hit the token's share before the epics stage, reported that the focus epic cgwalters-forge/tracker#1671 was not confirmed live, and started nothing. Request budget still decides whether the pass starts work, and a focus epic that could not be read should not stop every start."}
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"replace_state","body":"# Supervisor state\n\n## Latest sweep: 2026-11-16 ~01:10Z\n\nI read state 718 first (last edited 11-15 23:45Z, unchanged at re-read) and kept its record. Operator notes are unchanged. Health came from this run's artifact (supervisor run 43783340030, sweep 11-15 23:32Z); pass state from poll run 43782385458. The sweep was read-only. Older detail is in this issue's edit history (index in the 11-14 08:05Z revision; 11-15 19:50Z for the held-PR reopen and plan_epic picks; 11-15 21:05Z for the pass blockers and the rhel-bootc-examples#33 bounds refusal; 11-15 23:45Z for the poll-off episode).\n\n### Changed since 23:45Z\n\n- The hosted poll is back: pass (apply) runs every ten minutes since 00:08Z (43778628177, 43780163014, 43781389188, 43782385458) and publishes pass-state again. They dispatched 8, 1, 1 and 0. The poll-off case is recorded on tracker#1605.\n- Claude is well under pace, openai near it. Two things hold claude work:\n  - Request budget: 43781389188 went idle with 12 stage-4 candidates unread (first review#381, which has an accepted implement plan); 43782385458 stopped at the token share before the epics stage, could not confirm focus tracker#1671 live, and started nothing. Owner: agent-board#803 (evidence comment requested).\n  - openPrCap picks blockers that cannot land: agent-board#1021 (approved) waits on #782 (branch plan-comment-table, outside fix bounds, changes requested since 11-07); agent-board#1031 waits on draft #957; actions#208/#220/#278 wait on draft actions#139; ten agentic-job PRs (incl. #3789, #3817, #3835, the queue check) wait on #3333 (conflicting, rebase round 2), and agentic-job has 19 open bot PRs against a cap of 6, so agentic-job#4113 and other agentic-job starts are held. Owner: agent-board#994 (evidence comment requested); agent-board#1018 (drafts counted) dispatched for triage.\n- needs-supervisor: 13 promotion handoffs in midstream forks (anaconda#2/#3, bootc#94/#113/#120/#123, composefs-rs#49/#50/#60/#64/#67/#82) skip as conflicting handoff fork PRs (agent-board crates/board-forge/src/promote/handoff.rs:179-184: more than one fork PR cross-references the same source item); bootc#119 and composefs-rs#59 need one deterministic source issue. Midstream drafts wait on the operator; no signature hash, so no file_bug.\n- Signatures unchanged: all count 1 except 88122969 at count 4 (owned by tracker#1430). Needs-you: fdf7497e (no concrete question) now 103, owned by tracker#1443; d92111f8 (incomplete sources) count 1.\n- tracker#1701 merged (pin now 20d1a3c). tracker#1704 is approved and clean; the pass should land it.\n- Release: wrapper pins agentic-job v0.6.11; v0.6.15 is out. Dependabot bumps tracker#1588-#1591 to 0.6.12 sit with changes requested or blocked.\n- runs: tracker runs 43388110612 (poll), 43096024384 (review), 43096023375 (ci) still queued since 11-11/11-13; the poll works, so not an outage. Left to the operator to cancel.\n- needs-human queue: tracker#1653, #1623, #1605, #1600, #1561, #1204. No releaseList item still held (agentic-job#2642 is closed). Nothing to clear.\n\n### Requested\n\n01:10Z: dispatch triage agent-board#1018 on claude (no-plan); comments on agent-board#994 and agent-board#803 with the evidence above. No status update (sent in the last day). No file_bug (no new recurring signature).\n\n### Excluded from supervisor dispatch\n\nAs in the 14:50Z revision. Dispatch only to claude and openai, and to openai only when it is not over. agent-board#840, tracker#1605, agent-board#994 and agent-board#803 hold supervisor comments.\n\n### Owners and gates\n\nAs in the 21:05Z revision. Size refusals (88122969): tracker#1430. Needs-you placeholders: tracker#1443. Poll chain and health-ok gap: tracker#1605. Budget starvation: agent-board#803. openPrCap blocker choice: agent-board#994, #1018. Bounds 2a72bf79 (agent-board#782's branch) and the rhel-bootc-examples#33 refusal are left to the operator. plan_epic only reaches epics last labelled by the operator: 1047, 890, 766 (needs-design), 680, 677, 674, 596, 160; plan_epic is at today's cap.\n\nMissing executor capabilities: as in the 21:05Z revision; file_bug cannot file a failure with no health signature while bugEpic is set; no action moves a bot PR to a bot/ branch (agent-board#782) or parents a triaged issue under an epic (agent-board#1009, #1010, #1011, #1019 need that before implement). The read-only profile cannot write a findings document or edit a topic issue body.\n\nOperator asks (recommend yes to each): close agent-board#782 or move it to a bot/ branch so agent-board#1021 can land; parent agent-board#1009/#1010/#1011/#1019 under tracker#680; fix midstream bounds for rhel-bootc-examples#33; resolve the requested changes on tracker#1698; comment on tracker#680 to clear the unproved-apply hold; parent tracker#1430 under tracker#680; label the bot-labelled epics yourself so plan_epic can reach them.\n\n### Next checks\n\nagent-board#1018 triage result. Whether agentic-job#3333 lands and agentic-job drains below the cap. agent-board#1021 and tracker#1704 merging. Whether passes still stop on request budget (then more evidence on agent-board#803). Implement planning for agent-board#1009, #1011, #1019, #1010. Plans for #1671, then #890, #160 and #674. Any count-1 signature recurring (then file_bug with its signature). The v0.6.15 pin. Next status update after 11-16 10:50Z.\n\nSupervisor profile: cgwalters-forge/agenthome at b68e3f632a870aa1bb681b811693bdf86c1ff077\n"}
    

    Poll and pass. The hosted poll is back. Since 00:08Z it has run a pass every ten minutes (latest finished 43782385458), and pass state is published again. The last four passes dispatched 8, 1, 1 and 0. No section failed. The claude pool is well under pace with free slots, and openai is near pace. Mistral got nothing. Two things hold claude work. First, request budget: 43781389188 went idle with 12 candidates unread, starting with review#381, which already has a plan. The next pass ran out before it read the epics and so could not confirm the focus epic tracker#1671, which stopped every start. agent-board#803 owns this, and I'm adding the evidence there. Second, the open-PR cap tells the pass to land PRs that cannot land. agent-board#1021 (approved) waits on #782, which is on an out-of-bounds branch with changes requested. agent-board#1031 and actions#208/#220/#278 wait on drafts. Ten agentic-job PRs wait on the conflicting #3333, and agentic-job is far past its cap. agent-board#994 owns this, and I'm adding the evidence there. I'm also dispatching triage on agent-board#1018 (the cap counts drafts) to claude.

    queue. agentic-job#3789, #3817 and #3835 left the queue because they conflict. All are approved and waiting behind #3333's rebase round. This is not a flake or an outage.

    needs-supervisor. Thirteen midstream promotion handoffs are skipped because more than one fork PR references the same source item (agent-board crates/board-forge/src/promote/handoff.rs:179-184). Two more need a single source issue. These are drafts waiting on the operator, and there is no signature hash, so I'm not filing a bug.

    signatures, apply-failures, needs-you. Nothing new recurs. 88122969 (size refusal) stays at count 4 under tracker#1430. The others are at count 1. The needs-you placeholders are under tracker#1443.

    runs, dispatch, epics. Three tracker runs (poll, review, ci) have been queued since 11-11 or 11-13. The poll works, so this is not an outage, and the operator can cancel them. The dispatch and epics evidence (tracker#680, #890, run 39698121265) is unchanged from earlier records.

    release. The wrapper pins agentic-job v0.6.11 while v0.6.15 is out. The Dependabot bumps to 0.6.12 (tracker#1588-#1591) are stuck with changes requested.

    held, stranded, reviews, pace. The health sweep at 23:32Z was taken while pass state was unpublished. Pass state is back now, so these should become observable on the next sweep.

    Operator asks (recommend yes): close agent-board#782 or move it to a bot/ branch so #1021 can land; parent agent-board#1009, #1010, #1011 and #1019 under tracker#680 so they can be implemented. The earlier asks recorded in state stand. Missing capabilities: file_bug needs a health signature while bugEpic is set; no action moves a bot PR's branch or sets an issue's epic parent; this read-only profile cannot write a findings document.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  27. cgwalters-bot commented on Nov 16, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"replace_state","body":"# Supervisor state\n\n## Latest sweep: 2026-11-16 ~01:45Z\n\nI read state 718 first (last edited 01:10Z, unchanged at re-read) and kept its record. Operator notes are unchanged. Health came from this run's artifact (supervisor run 43786923351); pass state from poll run 43785354953 (01:17Z). The sweep was read-only. Older detail is in this issue's edit history (index in the 11-14 08:05Z revision; 11-15 19:50Z for the held-PR reopen and plan_epic picks; 11-15 21:05Z for the pass blockers and the rhel-bootc-examples#33 bounds refusal; 11-15 23:45Z for the poll-off episode; 11-16 01:10Z for the budget and openPrCap evidence).\n\n### Changed since 01:10Z\n\n- The pass is spending again. 43785354953 started 7 (2 triage, 2 fix, a session, a continuation, a check rerun); the 01:33Z pass 43786933689 started 7 more by 01:41Z (triage agentic-job#3000, #3410, review#305; sessions workflow-compiler#66, atomic-linux-sandbox#24, agenthome#92, agent-board#1032). Claude and openai are still under pace but are being worked, so nothing is held by the supervisor.\n- agent-board#1018 triage (run 43784703378): not-done; drafts in midstream forks count toward openPrCap. I take its recommendation: exempt midstream forks from the cap and keep fail-closed when midstreams are unread. This is our own infrastructure, so no operator ask. Implement waits on epic parentage.\n- agent-board#1021 and tracker#1704 merged.\n- agentic-job#3333 (approved, conflicting) is parked mechanically: rebase round 2 (run 43778755369) ended success with no new head, and the poll requested cgwalters's review. No action removes a bot-made review request or restarts a rebase. The pass now names agentic-job#3690, #3674 and #3695 as cap blockers instead.\n- tracker#1605 hold released by the pass (operatorAsk policy) and triaged at 01:26Z.\n- Signatures: 88122969 still count 4 (tracker#1430); others count 1. Needs-you fdf7497e now 107 (tracker#1443).\n- tracker#680 still holds on the unproved apply of plan 6577032663 (create_sub_issue for tracker#1147); only a person can clear it.\n\n### Requested\n\n01:45Z: replace_state only. No dispatch (the pass started 14 runs in two passes), no status update (sent in the last day), no file_bug (no new recurring signature).\n\n### Excluded from supervisor dispatch\n\nAs in the 14:50Z revision. Dispatch only to claude and openai, and to openai only when it is not over. agent-board#840, tracker#1605, agent-board#994 and agent-board#803 hold supervisor comments.\n\n### Owners and gates\n\nAs in the 21:05Z revision. Size refusals (88122969): tracker#1430. Needs-you placeholders: tracker#1443. Poll chain and health-ok gap: tracker#1605. Budget starvation: agent-board#803. openPrCap blocker choice: agent-board#994; drafts counted: agent-board#1018 (decided: exempt midstreams). Bounds 2a72bf79 (agent-board#782's branch) and the rhel-bootc-examples#33 refusal are left to the operator. plan_epic only reaches epics last labelled by the operator: 1047, 890, 766 (needs-design), 680, 677, 674, 596, 160; plan_epic is at today's cap.\n\nMissing executor capabilities: as in the 21:05Z revision; file_bug cannot file a failure with no health signature while bugEpic is set; no action removes a bot-made review request or restarts a rebase (agentic-job#3333); no action moves a bot PR to a bot/ branch (agent-board#782) or parents a triaged issue under an epic (agent-board#803, #994, #1009, #1010, #1011, #1018, #1019 need that before implement). The read-only profile cannot write a findings document or edit a topic issue body.\n\nOperator asks (recommend yes to each): parent agent-board#1018, #994, #803, #1009, #1010, #1011, #1019 under tracker#680; remove your review request on agentic-job#3333 (or review it) so the poll retries the rebase; close agent-board#782 or move it to a bot/ branch; fix midstream bounds for rhel-bootc-examples#33; resolve the requested changes on tracker#1698; comment on tracker#680 to clear the unproved-apply hold; parent tracker#1430 under tracker#680; label the bot-labelled epics yourself so plan_epic can reach them.\n\n### Next checks\n\nResults of the triage runs on agentic-job#3000, #3410, review#305, tracker#1694, tracker#1605. Whether agentic-job#3333 rebases and agentic-job drains below the cap. Whether passes still stop on request budget (agent-board#803). Implement for agent-board#1018 and #1009/#1010/#1011/#1019 once parented. Plans for #1671 (0 ready), then #890, #160 and #674. Any count-1 signature recurring (then file_bug with its signature). The v0.6.15 pin. Next status update after 11-16 10:50Z.\n\nSupervisor profile: cgwalters-forge/agenthome at b68e3f632a870aa1bb681b811693bdf86c1ff077\n"}
    

    pass / pace. The hosted pass runs every ten minutes and is spending again: 43785354953 started 7 runs, and the 01:33Z pass 43786933689 started 7 more (triage, sessions, fixes). Claude and openai are still under pace, but the pass is working them, so I sent no extra dispatch. Focus tracker#1671 has nothing ready; plan_epic is at today's cap.

    Since 01:10Z. agent-board#1018 triage found the open-PR cap counts midstream drafts. I'm taking its recommendation (exempt midstream forks, stay fail-closed when unread); it needs epic parentage before implement. agent-board#1021 and tracker#1704 merged. agentic-job#3333 is parked mechanically: its second rebase round ended with no new head and the poll asked cgwalters for review. No action can remove that request or restart the rebase (missing capability).

    Unchanged checks. needs-supervisor: midstream handoffs with conflicting fork PRs, as recorded in state 718. Signatures: only 88122969 recurs (tracker#1430). Needs-you placeholders: tracker#1443. Release: pin v0.6.11 trails v0.6.15. runs: three tracker runs queued since 11-11/11-13 for the operator to cancel. queue: agentic-job#3789/#3817/#3835 wait behind the cap. stranded/reviews/held: observations unavailable. needs-human: tracker#1653, #1623, #1600, #1561, #1204; none released or listed.

    Operator asks (recommend yes): parent agent-board#1018, #994, #803, #1009, #1010, #1011 and #1019 under tracker#680; review or drop your review request on agentic-job#3333; comment on tracker#680 to clear its unproved-apply hold. Others are as listed in state 718.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  28. cgwalters-bot commented on Nov 16, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"replace_state","body":"# Supervisor state\n\n## Latest sweep: 2026-11-16 ~03:05Z\n\nI read state 718 first (last edited 01:45Z, unchanged at re-read) and kept its record. Operator notes are unchanged. Health came from this run's artifact (supervisor run 43794245035); pass state from pass run 43792913770 (02:33Z). GitHub status was operational. The sweep was read-only. Older detail is in this issue's edit history (index in the 11-14 08:05Z revision; 11-15 19:50Z for the held-PR reopen and plan_epic picks; 11-15 21:05Z for the pass blockers and the rhel-bootc-examples#33 bounds refusal; 11-15 23:45Z for the poll-off episode; 11-16 01:10Z for the budget and openPrCap evidence; 11-16 01:45Z for the pass restarting).\n\n### Changed since 01:45Z\n\n- The 02:33Z pass started only a planning run for tracker#1671 (run 43793803506) with 15 slots free. Claude is well under pace and openai is near pace. What holds the work, and the cause of each hold:\n  - openPrCap in agentic-job: the chain waits on agentic-job#3674 (continuation round 3 running), then #3690/#3695. The implement plans posted at 01:50Z for agentic-job#3000 and #3410 wait behind it.\n  - openPrCap in tracker: 10 of its open bot PRs are stale drafts left by partial or failed runs (tracker#1625, #1624, #1618, #1582, #1530, #1492, #1468, #1461, #1444, #1303, #1295), and the pass logs nothing for them. They block the new implement plans for tracker#1605 and #1694. agent-board#1018 exempts only midstream forks, so this is a separate pass gap (new, no owner).\n  - agenthome#93 is approved, clean and green, but the poll parked it at 01:34Z with an operator review request: \"reserved check rerun did not finish within its recovery window\". Rerun run 43781875091 attempt 2 had finished green at 01:29Z. In agent-board's crates/board-forge/src/poll.rs (around line 6487), a failed job URL left over from the run's earlier attempt counts as stale and keeps it waiting until the window ends. This is a poller defect (new, no owner). It holds agenthome#76 and #52.\n  - needs-issue holds (12): owned by agent-board#1023. Its triage at 02:38Z found the needs-issue part plannable.\n  - agentic-job#3333 is still parked by the poll's operator review request.\n- needs-supervisor: the pass skips 14 midstream promotion handoffs (anaconda#2, #3; bootc#94, #113, #119, #120, #123; composefs-rs#49, #50, #59, #60, #64, #67, #82). The same 14 were skipped at 01:33Z, so this is not new. Each source issue has more than one draft fork PR (anaconda#2 \"Part of #1\" and #3 \"Closes #1\"), or the PR has no single source line. The pass fails closed on purpose (agent-board#928, #930). Choosing which draft to promote is the operator's call.\n- tracker#1698 closed at 02:59Z, superseded by tracker#1708. Its same-repository branch cannot take agent pushes to .github, which is the new apply signature 745b0f48 (count 1). The operator ask to resolve its requested changes is dropped.\n- Triage results: agentic-job#3000, #3410, tracker#1694 and tracker#1605 all got implement plans (all held by openPrCap, see above). review#305: partly; the remaining producer work already has agent-board issues.\n- Signatures: 88122969 still count 4 (tracker#1430, open). Needs-you fdf7497e now 98 (tracker#1443, open). Other problem signatures are count 1.\n- Unchanged: the runs check (tracker runs 43388110612, 43096024384, 43096023375 queued since 11-11/11-13); the dispatch check (run 39698121265, in progress since 10-22, too old to cancel); the v0.6.15 pin (workflows still on v0.6.11 and v0.6.14); stranded/reviews/held have no observation.\n\n### Requested\n\n03:05Z: replace_state only. No dispatch: every pool with work is held by openPrCap or by the two parks above, and triage would only add plans behind the same cap. No plan_epic: 890 is planning now, and 160/674/680 were brought forward within 24 hours; 596 and 677 were re-planned in the last day with nothing new. No status update (one went out in the last day). No file_bug: the two new pass defects have no health signature, and file_bug needs one while bugEpic is set.\n\n### Excluded from supervisor dispatch\n\nAs in the 14:50Z revision. Dispatch only to claude and openai, and to openai only when it is not over. agent-board#840, tracker#1605, agent-board#994 and agent-board#803 hold supervisor comments.\n\n### Owners and gates\n\nAs in the 21:05Z revision. Size refusals (88122969): tracker#1430. Needs-you placeholders: tracker#1443. Poll chain and health-ok gap: tracker#1605. Budget starvation: agent-board#803. openPrCap blocker choice: agent-board#994; midstream drafts counted: agent-board#1018 (decided: exempt midstreams). Dead-end holds including needs-issue: agent-board#1023. Unowned: own-repo stale drafts holding openPrCap; the agenthome#93 rerun-window park. Bounds 2a72bf79 (agent-board#782's branch) and the rhel-bootc-examples#33 refusal are left to the operator. plan_epic only reaches epics last labelled by the operator: 1047, 890, 766 (needs-design), 680, 677, 674, 596, 160.\n\nMissing executor capabilities: as in the 21:05Z revision. file_bug cannot file a failure that has no health signature while bugEpic is set (blocks both new pass defects). No action removes a bot-made review request or restarts a rebase (agentic-job#3333, agenthome#93). No action moves a bot PR to a bot/ branch (agent-board#782) or parents a triaged issue under an epic (agent-board#803, #994, #1009, #1010, #1011, #1018, #1019 need that before implement). The read-only profile cannot write a findings document or edit a topic issue body.\n\nOperator asks (recommend yes to each): remove your review request on agenthome#93 and agentic-job#3333 (or review them) so the poll picks them up again; file agent-board bugs under tracker#680 for the own-repo stale drafts and the rerun-window park, or let file_bug accept unsigned failures; parent agent-board#1018, #994, #803, #1009, #1010, #1011, #1019 and tracker#1430 under tracker#680; close agent-board#782 or move it to a bot/ branch; fix midstream bounds for rhel-bootc-examples#33; pick one draft per source issue for the 14 skipped midstream handoffs; comment on tracker#680 to clear the unproved-apply hold; label the bot-labelled epics yourself so plan_epic can reach them.\n\n### Next checks\n\nWhether agentic-job#3674 lands and the agentic-job chain drains. Whether tracker's stale drafts get an owner and tracker drops under the cap so #1605 and #1694 start. agenthome#93 after the review request clears. tracker#1708 implement. agent-board#1023 implement. Plans for #1671, #890. Any count-1 signature recurring (then file_bug with its signature), 745b0f48 especially. The v0.6.15 pin. Next status update after 11-16 10:50Z.\n\nSupervisor profile: cgwalters-forge/agenthome at b68e3f632a870aa1bb681b811693bdf86c1ff077\n"}
    

    Pass and pace. The pass runs. The 02:33Z pass (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/tracker/actions/runs/43792913770) started only a planning run for tracker#1671, with 15 slots free. Claude is well under pace and openai is near it. Four triages finished with implement plans (agentic-job#3000, #3410, tracker#1605, tracker#1694), and openPrCap holds all four. In agentic-job the cap chain waits on agentic-job#3674, whose continuation is running. In tracker, 10 of the 13 open bot PRs are stale drafts left by partial or failed runs (for example tracker#1625, #1468, #1295). The pass logs nothing for them, and agent-board#1018 only exempts midstream forks. This is a pass gap with no owner. I am not dispatching triage, because it would only add plans behind the same cap. Status stays not on-track while this holds; no update is due today.

    Poller defect, agenthome#93. The PR is approved, clean and green. The poll parked it at 01:34Z with an operator review request: "reserved check rerun did not finish within its recovery window". The rerun (https://github.com/cgwalters-forge/agenthome/actions/runs/43781875091, attempt 2) had finished green at 01:29Z. In agent-board's crates/board-forge/src/poll.rs (around line 6487), a failed job URL left over from the run's earlier attempt counts as stale, so the poll keeps waiting until the window ends. This holds agenthome#76 and #52. file_bug needs a health signature while bugEpic is set, and neither defect has one. So I cannot request either bug, and no action removes a bot-made review request.

    needs-supervisor. The pass skips the same 14 midstream promotion handoffs at 01:33Z and 02:33Z. Each source issue has more than one draft fork PR (anaconda#2 and #3 both claim anaconda#1), or the PR has no single source line. The pass fails closed on purpose (agent-board#928). Which draft to promote is the operator's call.

    Other checks. apply-failures: new signature 745b0f48 (count 1) is tracker#1698's same-repository .github push. That PR was closed at 02:59Z and replaced by tracker#1708, so its operator ask is dropped. signatures: 88122969 is still count 4, owned by tracker#1430. needs-you: count 98, owned by tracker#1443. queue: agentic-job#3817, #3835 and #3789 are approved, green and conflicting, behind the agentic-job cap chain, with no hold to lift. The runs and dispatch checks, the v0.6.15 pin (workflows still pin v0.6.11/v0.6.14) and the unobserved stranded/reviews/held checks are unchanged since the last record. GitHub status is operational.

    Operator asks (recommend yes): remove your review request on agenthome#93 and agentic-job#3333 so the poll picks them up again. File agent-board bugs under tracker#680 for the own-repo stale drafts and the rerun-window park, or let file_bug accept unsigned failures. Pick one draft per source issue for the skipped midstream handoffs. The earlier asks in the state issue still stand.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  29. cgwalters-bot commented on Nov 16, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"replace_state","body":"# Supervisor state\n\n## Latest sweep: 2026-11-16 ~03:55Z\n\nI read state 718 first (last edited 03:03Z, unchanged at re-read) and kept its record. Operator notes are unchanged. Health came from this run's artifact (supervisor run 43800051573); pass state from poll run 43798823049 (03:45Z pass). The pace snapshot comment linked from the health report could not be read with this run's token (404), so the pool picture carries over from 03:05Z: claude well under pace, openai near. GitHub status was operational. The sweep was read-only. Older detail is in this issue's edit history (index in the 11-14 08:05Z revision; 11-15 19:50Z for the held-PR reopen and plan_epic picks; 11-15 21:05Z for the pass blockers and the rhel-bootc-examples#33 bounds refusal; 11-15 23:45Z for the poll-off episode; 11-16 01:10Z for the budget and openPrCap evidence; 11-16 01:45Z for the pass restarting; 11-16 03:05Z for the tracker stale drafts, the agenthome#93 rerun-window park and the 14 midstream handoffs).\n\n### Changed since 03:05Z\n\n- The 03:45Z pass started no implement work with 17 slots free. It only brought forward a planning run for tracker#1311 on fable (run 43799655041), after its sub-issue agentic-job#3143 closed, and continued agentic-job#3690 (round 1, run 43799173936). Every followed repository with ready work is at openPrCap.\n- agentic-job#3674 (draft) is now held needs-human: continuation round 3 (run 43791911800) handed back missing_data with no change, because trusted workflow admission and hosted digest acceptance need trusted-base approval. That is a real operator decision, not a stale checkpoint. The agentic-job chain now waits on #3690 (continuing) and then #3695, no longer on #3674.\n- queue check: agentic-job#3817, #3835 and #3789 are approved but conflicting (DIRTY) and left the queue. The pass holds them behind #3690/#3695 for overlapping paths (blocker choice owned by agent-board#994). Once #3690 lands they need a rebase. Not a flake or an outage.\n- review is now at openPrCap too (6 of 6 open bot PRs), so review#381 waits. Of the six: review#299, #254, #243 are stale conflicting drafts (same pattern as tracker's stale drafts). review#341 is approved but parked by the poll's operator review request. review#376 and #336 have had no successful review since 11-14: their review agent runs (review runs 43596529499 and 43547342212) failed during the 11-14 network-join credential outage, and the pass logs no line for either PR. Their reviews need a restart.\n- Signatures: unchanged. 88122969 count 4 (tracker#1430, open). Needs-you fdf7497e now 99 (tracker#1443, open). New needs-you d92111f8 \"incomplete sources\" count 1. Other problem signatures are count 1.\n- releaseList: no listed item is still open and held, so nothing to release. clear_needs_human has no daily cap (disabled). Closed items that still carry needs-human after a bot close (for example agentic-job#2642) could be cleared once it is enabled.\n- Unchanged: needs-supervisor (the same 14 midstream handoffs; the operator chooses which draft to promote); runs check (tracker runs 43388110612, 43096024384, 43096023375 queued since 11-11/11-13); dispatch check (run 39698121265, too old to cancel); v0.6.15 pin; agenthome#93 and agentic-job#3333 parked by the poll's operator review request; stranded/reviews/held unobserved; epics 680 and 890 as before.\n\n### Requested\n\n03:55Z: replace_state only. No dispatch: triage or research would only add plans behind the same openPrCap in every repository with work, and implement cannot start past it. No plan_epic: nothing new since 03:05Z (1311 is already brought forward by the pass). No status update (one went out in the last day). No file_bug: no recurring signature lacks an open bug, and the new pass defects have no signature while bugEpic is set. No remove_needs_human: the three conflicting agentic-job PRs carry no hold, and #3674 is a draft held for a real decision.\n\n### Excluded from supervisor dispatch\n\nAs in the 14:50Z revision. Dispatch only to claude and openai, and to openai only when it is not over. agent-board#840, tracker#1605, agent-board#994 and agent-board#803 hold supervisor comments.\n\n### Owners and gates\n\nAs in the 21:05Z revision. Size refusals (88122969): tracker#1430. Needs-you placeholders: tracker#1443. Poll chain and health-ok gap: tracker#1605. Budget starvation: agent-board#803. openPrCap blocker choice: agent-board#994; midstream drafts counted: agent-board#1018 (decided: exempt midstreams). Dead-end holds including needs-issue: agent-board#1023. Unowned: own-repo stale drafts holding openPrCap (tracker and now review); the agenthome#93 rerun-window park; PRs whose review failed in an outage getting no pass line and no review retry (review#376, #336). Bounds 2a72bf79 (agent-board#782's branch) and the rhel-bootc-examples#33 refusal are left to the operator. plan_epic only reaches epics last labelled by the operator: 1047, 890, 766 (needs-design), 680, 677, 674, 596, 160.\n\nMissing executor capabilities: as in the 21:05Z revision. file_bug cannot file a failure that has no health signature while bugEpic is set (blocks the three unowned pass defects). No action removes a bot-made review request or restarts a rebase or a review (agentic-job#3333, agenthome#93, review#341, #376, #336). No action moves a bot PR to a bot/ branch (agent-board#782) or parents a triaged issue under an epic (agent-board#803, #994, #1009, #1010, #1011, #1018, #1019 need that before implement). clear_needs_human is disabled. The read-only profile cannot write a findings document or edit a topic issue body. The pace snapshot is not readable from this run.\n\nOperator asks (recommend yes to each): decide trusted-base approval for agentic-job#3674's workflow admission; restart the reviews on review#376 and #336; remove your review request on agenthome#93, agentic-job#3333 and review#341 (or review them); file agent-board bugs under tracker#680 for own-repo stale drafts, the rerun-window park and the missing review retry, or let file_bug accept unsigned failures; parent agent-board#1018, #994, #803, #1009, #1010, #1011, #1019 and tracker#1430 under tracker#680; close agent-board#782 or move it to a bot/ branch; fix midstream bounds for rhel-bootc-examples#33; pick one draft per source issue for the 14 skipped midstream handoffs; comment on tracker#680 to clear the unproved-apply hold; label the bot-labelled epics yourself so plan_epic can reach them.\n\n### Next checks\n\nWhether agentic-job#3690 lands and #3817/#3835/#3789 get rebased. The #3674 decision. Whether tracker's and review's stale drafts get an owner and those repositories drop under the cap (tracker#1605, #1694, review#381). Reviews on review#376/#336. agenthome#93 after the review request clears. tracker#1708 and agent-board#1023 implement. Plans for #1311, #1671, #890. Any count-1 signature recurring (then file_bug with its signature), 745b0f48 and d92111f8 especially. The v0.6.15 pin. Whether the pace snapshot is readable. Next status update after 11-16 10:50Z.\n\nSupervisor profile: cgwalters-forge/agenthome at b68e3f632a870aa1bb681b811693bdf86c1ff077\n"}
    

    Pass and pools. The 03:45Z pass (poll run) started no implement work, though 17 slots were free. It brought forward planning for tracker#1311 and continued agentic-job#3690. Claude is still well under pace and openai is near. What holds them is openPrCap: every followed repository with ready work is at its cap. Review joined them this pass (review#381 waits). Dispatching triage would only add more plans behind the same cap, so I requested nothing but state. The poll and pass-errors checks are ok.

    agentic-job#3674 is now held needs-human. Its third continuation round (run) stopped because workflow admission and hosted digest acceptance need trusted-base approval. That is a real operator decision, not a stale checkpoint. The chain now waits on #3690 (continuing), then #3695.

    queue: agentic-job#3817, #3835 and #3789 are approved but have merge conflicts. The pass holds them behind #3690/#3695 because their paths overlap (agent-board#994 owns that choice). They need a rebase once #3690 lands. This is not a flake and not an outage.

    reviews: review#376 and #336 have had no successful review since 11-14. Their review runs (1, 2) failed during that day's credential outage, and the pass has never retried them. Operator: restart both reviews. review#299, #254 and #243 are stale conflicting drafts, like tracker's, and they count against review's cap. review#341 is approved but parked by an operator review request.

    Unchanged: the 14 midstream handoffs (needs-supervisor; the operator picks one draft per source issue), the old queued runs, the v0.6.15 pin, signatures (88122969 → tracker#1430; needs-you → tracker#1443; the rest are count 1). No releaseList item is still held.

    Missing capabilities: there is no action to restart a review or a rebase, or to remove a bot-made review request. file_bug cannot take an unsigned failure while bugEpic is set. clear_needs_human is disabled. This run cannot read the pace snapshot or write findings documents. Operator asks, with the full list in tracker#718: decide agentic-job#3674, restart the review#376/#336 reviews, and lift the review requests on agenthome#93, agentic-job#3333 and review#341.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

  30. cgwalters-bot commented on Nov 16, 2026

    @cgwalters-bot
    CollaboratorAuthor
    {"type":"supervisor_action","action":"replace_state","body":"# Supervisor state\n\n## Latest sweep: 2026-11-16 ~05:10Z\n\nI read state 718 first (last edited 03:58Z, unchanged at re-read) and kept its record. Operator notes are unchanged. Health came from this run's artifact (supervisor run 43806972298); pass state from poll run 43805839361 (04:44Z pass) and the dispatches of the in-flight poll 43806981990. GitHub status was operational. The sweep was read-only. Older detail is in this issue's edit history (index in the 11-14 08:05Z revision; 11-15 19:50Z for the held-PR reopen and plan_epic picks; 11-15 21:05Z for the pass blockers and the rhel-bootc-examples#33 bounds refusal; 11-15 23:45Z for the poll-off episode; 11-16 01:10Z for the budget and openPrCap evidence; 11-16 01:45Z for the pass restarting; 11-16 03:05Z for the tracker stale drafts, the agenthome#93 rerun-window park and the 14 midstream handoffs; 11-16 03:55Z for the #3674 hold and the review#376/#336 outage-failed reviews).\n\n### Changed since 03:55Z\n\n- The cap blockers are moving. The 04:55Z poll started fix rounds (claude) on tracker#1295, agentic-job#3690, #3695 and #3674, all draft and DIRTY (tracker runs 43807779443, 43807788333, 43807797274, 43807792901). The #3674 round runs while #3674 stays held needs-human for the trusted-base decision; a rebase does not answer that decision. Check whether the round respected the hold.\n- tracker#1708 (PR recovery with a scoped recovery-triage route) closed at 04:06Z with 172d233 on main.\n- The 04:44Z pass started only a planning run for tracker#677 on fable (run 43806625016), with 19 slots free. Merged/enqueued 0. Every ready candidate waits on openPrCap overlap behind the PRs above (agentic-job, tracker, actions behind actions#202, agent-board behind agent-board#782). It also spent its request share: discovery deferred and 40 repositories wait for the next pass (budget owner agent-board#803).\n- Pace: the pace snapshot was readable through the pass log. claude is well under, openai is under but near. Repositories below their cap (agenthome, forge-infra, cgwalters-forge.github.io, atomic-linux-sandbox) have no ready no-plan work: agenthome#76, #52 and atomic-linux-sandbox#16 have plans, and agenthome#2's parent tracker#1694 is not a live epic.\n- Signatures: fdf7497e 95 (tracker#1443). 88122969 4 (tracker#1430). 8cd57072 \"question present\" 24 is a non-problem signature. Problem signatures other than these are count 1.\n- Still dead-ended on triage verdict needs-issue (agent-board#1023): agent-board#1002, #650; tracker#1208, #1268, #1273, #1443, #1473, #1477, #1527, #1572; review#290; agentic-job#3617. tracker#1445 has a done verdict but was not locked throughout its triage, so it is not closeable.\n- Unchanged: needs-supervisor (14 midstream handoffs); runs check (tracker runs 43388110612, 43096024384, 43096023375 queued since 11-11/11-13); dispatch check (run 39698121265); queue (agentic-job#3817, #3835, #3789 DIRTY behind #3690/#3695); review#376/#336 still without a review on their head (BEHIND); review#341 approved, parked by the operator review request; v0.6.15 pin; tracker#680 unproved apply.\n\n### Requested\n\n05:10Z: replace_state only. No dispatch: no ready issue lacks a plan outside the capped repositories, and the poll's own fix rounds are now clearing the cap blockers. No plan_epic: tracker#677 was brought forward by the pass, and nothing else changed. No status update (one went out in the last day). No file_bug: no problem signature at count two or more lacks an open bug. No remove_needs_human: no approved, green, non-draft conflict-only hold.\n\n### Excluded from supervisor dispatch\n\nAs in the 14:50Z revision. Dispatch only to claude and openai, and to openai only when it is not over. agent-board#840, tracker#1605, agent-board#994 and agent-board#803 hold supervisor comments.\n\n### Owners and gates\n\nAs in the 21:05Z revision. Size refusals (88122969): tracker#1430. Needs-you placeholders: tracker#1443. Poll chain and health-ok gap: tracker#1605. Budget starvation and request share: agent-board#803. openPrCap blocker choice: agent-board#994; midstream drafts counted: agent-board#1018 (decided: exempt midstreams). Dead-end holds including needs-issue: agent-board#1023. PR recovery: tracker#1708 (closed). Unowned: own-repo stale drafts holding openPrCap (tracker and review); the agenthome#93 rerun-window park; PRs whose review failed in an outage getting no pass line and no review retry (review#376, #336). Bounds 2a72bf79 (agent-board#782's branch) and the rhel-bootc-examples#33 refusal are left to the operator. plan_epic only reaches epics last labelled by the operator: 1047, 890, 766 (needs-design), 680, 677, 674, 596, 160.\n\nMissing executor capabilities: as in the 21:05Z revision. file_bug cannot file a failure that has no health signature while bugEpic is set (blocks the three unowned pass defects). No action removes a bot-made review request or restarts a rebase or a review (agentic-job#3333, agenthome#93, review#341, #376, #336). No action creates the follow-up issue a needs-issue verdict asks for. No action moves a bot PR to a bot/ branch (agent-board#782) or parents a triaged issue under an epic (agent-board#803, #994, #1009, #1010, #1011, #1018, #1019 need that before implement). clear_needs_human is disabled. The read-only profile cannot write a findings document or edit a topic issue body.\n\nOperator asks (recommend yes to each): decide trusted-base approval for agentic-job#3674's workflow admission; restart the reviews on review#376 and #336; remove your review request on agenthome#93, agentic-job#3333 and review#341 (or review them); file agent-board bugs under tracker#680 for own-repo stale drafts, the rerun-window park and the missing review retry, or let file_bug accept unsigned failures; parent agent-board#1018, #994, #803, #1009, #1010, #1011, #1019 and tracker#1430 under tracker#680; close agent-board#782 or move it to a bot/ branch; fix midstream bounds for rhel-bootc-examples#33; pick one draft per source issue for the 14 skipped midstream handoffs; comment on tracker#680 to clear the unproved-apply hold; label the bot-labelled epics yourself so plan_epic can reach them.\n\n### Next checks\n\nOutcome of the fix rounds on tracker#1295, agentic-job#3690, #3695 and #3674 (and whether #3674's hold stayed in place); then whether #3817/#3835/#3789 rebase and the caps open. Whether the next pass finishes its repository discovery within its request share. The #3674 decision. Tracker's and review's stale drafts (tracker#1605, #1694, review#381). Reviews on review#376/#336. agenthome#93 after the review request clears. agent-board#1023 implement. Plans for #677, #1311, #1671, #890. Any count-1 problem signature recurring (then file_bug with its signature), 745b0f48 and d92111f8 especially. The v0.6.15 pin. Next status update after 11-16 10:50Z.\n\nSupervisor profile: cgwalters-forge/agenthome at b68e3f632a870aa1bb681b811693bdf86c1ff077\n"}
    

    poll and pass: The pass ran at 04:44Z (poll 43805839361). It started only a planning run for tracker#677, with slots free and nothing merged. Every ready candidate waits on open-PR caps behind conflicting drafts. It also used up its request share, so 40 repositories wait for the next pass (agent-board#803). The 04:55Z poll then started claude fix rounds on the cap blockers tracker#1295 and agentic-job#3690, #3695 and #3674. These should clear the agentic-job and tracker caps once they land. tracker#1708 (PR recovery) closed with 172d233.

    pace and capacity: claude is well under pace and openai is near it. The work is held by the caps above, and the fix rounds are now moving those caps. Repositories below their cap have no ready work without a plan: agenthome#76, agenthome#52 and atomic-linux-sandbox#16 have plans, and agenthome#2's parent is not a live epic. So I requested no dispatch. Twelve issues remain stuck on triage verdict needs-issue, which agent-board#1023 owns; no action lets me create those follow-up issues. Status is not on track while this stands, but a status update already went out today.

    held, needs-you: agentic-job#3674 stays held for your trusted-base decision. A fix round started on it anyway; I will check whether it kept the hold. review#376 and #336 still have no review on their current head and need a restart. agenthome#93, agentic-job#3333 and review#341 wait on your review request.

    signatures, queue, runs, release, needs-supervisor, dispatch, epics: No change since the last record. No problem signature at count two or more lacks an open bug (tracker#1430, tracker#1443). agentic-job#3817, #3835 and #3789 are conflicting behind #3690 and #3695. The three runs queued since 11-11/11-13 are still queued. The pin is still behind v0.6.15. The 14 midstream handoffs still wait for you to pick a draft, and tracker#680 still has an unproved apply.

    Operator asks, unchanged and with yes recommended for each, are listed in tracker#718. The read-only profile cannot update findings documents or topic issue bodies.

    Generated by supervisor · ◷

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions