Track upstream agent CLI versions - #1620
Conversation
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / timed out waiting for workflow completion. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/30964834356 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Overall verdict: pending / incomplete. No live-stack job had failed at the time of this comment, but the matrix had not completed, so catalog/evidence consistency still needs final CI confirmation from the linked run. |
Live-stack QARun: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/30964850568 Overall verdict: not complete within the 20-minute QA wait window. No live-stack failures were observed before timeout; build, matrix computation, and all vanilla NI scenarios had passed. The two Codex BP interactive scenarios were still in progress when the wait window expired.
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"pi","model":"foundry-gpt54mini","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"}
]Scope note: this matrix targets Atlas agent-version catalog/evidence consumption paths for PR #1620 rather than transport or hook changes. |
Live-stack QAResult: not final - timed out waiting for selected live-stack jobs. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/30964913235 The workflow was dispatched for adversarial QA of PR #1620. The process wait window expired after Build All completed and while the selected scenario jobs were still in progress. Tested matrix
Current job status
Overall verdict: not passed yet. No scenario failures were observed before timeout, but the live-stack jobs had not completed. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete. The live-stack workflow was dispatched and is still running, but the QA polling process timed out after 20 minutes before the scenario jobs completed. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/30964922275 Matrix tested:
Current job status:
Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked run for final scenario conclusions. |
|
Adversarial review result: changes requested. GitHub would not let this actor submit a formal request-changes review because the PR is bot-authored by the same app, so I’m posting the blocking review as a comment. Blockers
Majors
QAI dispatched QA via Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
|
Requesting changes based on the adversarial review process. Major finding:
Fix: add QA status: The dispatched Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete. The live-stack workflow was dispatched and was still running when the 20-minute QA polling window expired. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/30965049909 Focused matrix:
Current job status at timeout:
Coverage rationale: PR #1620 changes Atlas AgentVersion graph metadata and generated tracker artifacts, so this matrix focuses on BP predefined/create graph/catalog consumers plus one vanilla adapter baseline. The workflow result should be checked once the remaining jobs complete. |
Live-stack QAResult: in progress after Babysitter polling timeout. The QA process waited 20 minutes; the GitHub Actions run is still active. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/30965059325 Focus: adversarial review of Atlas graph agent-version metadata update, including affected Atlas graph/catalog surfaces, provenance/evidence-source coverage, and generated tracker artifact consistency. Tested matrix
Current job status
Overall verdict: not yet complete; no scenario failure has been reported, but the live-stack scenario jobs have not reached terminal conclusions yet. |
|
Adversarial review result: changes requested. GitHub would not let this actor submit a formal request-changes review because the PR is bot-authored by the same app, so I am posting the review decision as a comment. Major Finding
Fix: add the 2026-08-04 EvidenceSource records using the established 2026-07-17 pattern, reference the exact new AgentVersion IDs, then rerun Additional Issues
QALocal verification passed for Dispatched QA via Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Live-stack QAResult: pending / not yet passed. The live-stack workflow was dispatched for adversarial QA, but the process wait window timed out while the GitHub Actions run was still in progress. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/30965297624
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true},
{"agent":"claude","model":"anthropic-sonnet46","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true},
{"agent":"pi","model":"foundry-deepseek","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"antigravity","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"}
]Overall verdict: not passed yet because final job conclusions are unavailable. Re-check the run link for the final result. |
Live-stack QAResult: timeout / still running. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/30965295899 The predefined QA process waited 20 minutes, but the run was still
Matrix tested:
Reasoning: PR #1620 changes Atlas agent-version graph metadata and generated tracker artifacts. This matrix covers representative graph consumers across raw adapter install and babysitter-plugin install paths without running the full cross-product. |
Adversarial review decision: changes requestedGitHub would not allow this bot account to submit a formal request-changes review because it is the PR author, so I am posting the decision as a PR comment instead. I cannot approve this as a complete Atlas graph update in its current form. The review found no security blockers, but it did find major correctness/provenance problems and the higher-level approach check failed. Major findings
All 16 new AgentVersion records add release dates, upstream tags, release-note summaries, and behavioral/security claims, but their edges only contain Fix: add
The Codex record uses Fix: rename the affected IDs to the canonical Additional issues
Missing scopeThe PR description says this updates Atlas AgentVersion records from the daily upstream release check, but the diff only adds raw AgentVersion graph records and tracker artifacts. For this to be mergeable as a complete graph update, it should also include EvidenceSource records, QAQA Dispatch was triggered for PR #1620 on branch Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Live-stack QAResult: timeout / still running. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31061195839 The predefined QA process dispatched live-stack QA for adversarial review of PR #1620 and waited 20 minutes. The GitHub Actions run was still
Matrix tested:
Coverage rationale: PR #1620 changes Atlas AgentVersion graph metadata and generated tracker artifacts, so this adversarial QA matrix focuses on BP predefined/create graph/catalog consumer paths across Codex and Claude, plus one raw Codex adapter baseline. Overall verdict: not passed yet because final job conclusions are unavailable. Re-check the linked run for the terminal result. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / timed out waiting for workflow completion. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31061208047 The predefined QA process was executed for adversarial review of PR #1620 against branch
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true}
]Coverage rationale: PR #1620 changes Atlas AgentVersion graph metadata and generated tracker artifacts, so this matrix focuses on BP predefined/create graph/catalog consumers, bridged-hooks plugin coverage, and vanilla Hermes/Gemini adapter baselines across Foundry and Gemini providers. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked run for final Live Stack conclusions. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / timed out waiting for workflow completion. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31061241026 The predefined QA process dispatched
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: PR #1620 changes Atlas AgentVersion graph metadata and generated tracker artifacts, so this matrix targets BP predefined graph/catalog consumption, BP create process-generation paths, bridged-hooks plugin behavior, and vanilla adapter baselines across Foundry and Gemini providers. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Re-check the linked run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / queued at timeout. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31061264182 The predefined QA process dispatched a focused live-stack matrix for adversarial review of the Atlas AgentVersion graph metadata update, with attention to catalog/evidence/source coverage and generated artifact consistency. The process waited 20 minutes, but the GitHub Actions run did not reach a terminal result. At timeout, the workflow was still queued overall.
Focused matrix:
Overall verdict: not passed yet. No live-stack scenario failure was observed, but final job conclusions are unavailable because the run remained queued through the QA wait window. |
Adversarial Review Decision: Changes RequestedI cannot approve this PR as a complete Atlas agent-version graph update. The review found no security blocker, but it found major graph correctness/provenance issues, generated artifact inconsistencies, incomplete QA, and a failed required check. Major Findings
The added records carry release dates, upstream tags, package names, CLI commands, summaries, and release-note claims, but their edges only contain Fix: add the 2026-08-04
The Codex record is Fix: normalize the ID to the catalog stable ID convention and update any references/evidence records.
The Cursor record uses Fix: use the canonical slug for
Fix: include all committed tracker outputs, or rename/narrow the field so downstream consumers do not misinterpret it.
The notes say release-note bodies are stored under Fix: commit those referenced body artifacts or remove/update the note.
Fix: get required PR checks green and obtain a terminal passing Live Stack verdict after the graph fixes. Missing GuardrailsThe current checks did not catch the missing evidence-source shard or the ID-shape issues. Please add metadata verification that every upstream-current Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Live-stack QAResult: in progress after Babysitter polling timeout. The predefined QA process waited 20 minutes, but the GitHub Actions run had not reached a terminal conclusion. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31061260206 Focused matrix:
Current job status at timeout:
Coverage rationale: PR #1620 changes Atlas AgentVersion graph metadata and generated tracker artifacts. This matrix focuses on babysitter-plugin predefined/create catalog consumers, bridged-hooks transport coverage, and vanilla adapter baselines for adversarial review coverage. Overall verdict: not passed yet. No failing live-stack job had been reported when the QA process timed out, but the run is still active and must be checked for final conclusions. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / timed out while queued. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31061275508 The workflow was dispatched for adversarial QA of PR #1620 against
Matrix tested:
Coverage rationale: PR #1620 changes Atlas AgentVersion graph metadata and generated tracker artifacts, so this focused matrix targets BP predefined/create graph/catalog consumers, bridged-hooks plugin integration, and representative vanilla adapter baselines without running the full cross-product. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Re-check the linked run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31061264056 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Overall verdict: not passed yet. No scenario failures were available at the time of this comment, but final live-stack conclusions are still pending. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / still running after the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31061260206 Focus: adversarial QA for the Atlas agent-version graph metadata update, with attention to catalog/evidence/source coverage and generated artifact consistency. Tested matrix
Current job status at timeout
Overall verdict: not passed yet. The workflow did not reach a terminal result within the QA process timeout; scenario jobs had not started by the final poll. Follow the linked run for final job conclusions before treating this QA as green. |
Adversarial Review Decision: Changes RequestedI cannot approve this PR as a complete Atlas AgentVersion update. The review found two blockers, two major issues, and no terminal passing QA verdict. Blockers
The new AgentVersion records only add Fix: add
The Codex record uses Fix: normalize the Codex ID to the canonical AgentVersion shape expected by the catalog generator and update any evidence or references added for this version. Major Issues
QAI dispatched Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Adversarial Review Decision: Changes RequestedI cannot approve this PR as a complete Atlas agent-version graph update. The review found no command-injection/secret/security blocker in the changed data files, but it found a blocking graph provenance issue, multiple major correctness/artifact issues, and QA is not green. Blocker
The PR adds 16 Fix: add the 2026-08-04 Major Findings
Fix: include all committed tracker outputs, or rename/narrow the field so downstream consumers do not treat it as a complete PR artifact manifest.
The notes say release-note bodies are stored under Fix: commit the referenced body artifacts or update the summary so it only describes files that actually exist.
The new Codex node is Fix: normalize the generated record to the SDK-generated shape or add a documented alias/migration path, then test it.
The Cursor node uses Fix: rename the node to the generated slug form or add an explicit tested exception. Missing Guardrails
QAQA Dispatch run Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Adversarial Review Decision: Changes RequestedI cannot approve this PR as a complete Atlas agent-version graph update. The review found a blocker, several major correctness/provenance issues, a failed approach check, and QA did not produce a terminal passing verdict. Blocker
The PR adds 16 Fix: add a 2026-08-04 Major Findings
Fix: normalize the ID to the SDK-generated form and update references/evidence records accordingly.
The Cursor record uses Fix: use the canonical slug for the
Fix: include all committed tracker outputs, or rename/narrow the field so downstream consumers do not treat it as a full changed-file manifest.
The notes say release-note bodies are stored under Fix: commit the referenced release-note and issue body artifacts, or remove/update the note to match the artifact set actually included in the PR.
The PR adds a generated graph shard but does not add or extend checks that would fail on missing evidence-source coverage, missing direct evidence/claims, summary artifact self-inconsistency, or SDK ID drift for Fix: add validation for upstream-current QAI dispatched The PR branch also had failing CI history: the latest PR CI run I inspected had Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31138600758 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: PR #1620 changes Atlas AgentVersion graph metadata and generated tracker artifacts, so this focused matrix targets BP predefined/create catalog/evidence consumers, Codex ID-sensitive coverage, bridged-hooks plugin integration, and representative vanilla adapter baselines. Overall verdict: not passed yet. No terminal live-stack conclusion was available at timeout; follow the linked run for final job results before treating QA as green. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31138615415 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked run for final job conclusions before treating this QA as green. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31138679513 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: PR #1620 changes Atlas AgentVersion graph metadata and generated tracker artifacts, so this focused matrix targets BP predefined/create graph/catalog consumers, Codex bridged-hooks plugin integration, and representative vanilla adapter baselines across Gemini/Foundry providers. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31138694128 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: PR #1620 changes Atlas AgentVersion graph metadata and generated tracker artifacts, so this focused matrix targets BP predefined/create graph/catalog consumers, bridged-hooks plugin integration, and representative vanilla adapter baselines. Overall verdict: not passed yet. No scenario failures were available because the live-stack jobs did not start within the QA polling window. Follow the linked run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31230747158 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: this matrix targets BP predefined/create catalog-consumer paths, Codex graph-read paths with Google provider coverage, Claude create/predefined coverage on Foundry, bridged-hooks plugin integration, and representative vanilla Hermes/Gemini adapter baselines without running the full cross-product. Overall verdict: not passed yet. No live-stack scenario job conclusions were available by timeout; follow the linked run for final job results before treating QA as green. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31230756861 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: this matrix targets Atlas AgentVersion graph/catalog consumers through BP predefined/create paths, Codex bridged-hooks plugin integration, and representative vanilla adapter baselines without running the full cross-product. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
Adversarial Review Decision: Changes RequestedI cannot approve this PR as a complete Atlas AgentVersion tracker update. The review found a blocking provenance gap, multiple generated-artifact consistency issues, a failed approach check, and no passing QA verdict. Blocker
The PR adds 16 AgentVersion records with release claims such as Fix: add Major Findings
The Cursor record ID is Fix: rename the Cursor node to
Fix: include all committed tracker outputs in
The note says release-note bodies are under Fix: commit the referenced release-note and issue body artifacts, or update the generated note to describe only artifacts actually present in the PR.
The existing test filters only Copilot nodes, so generated upstream-current AgentVersion records for other agents can drift from the ID/versionRange convention and still pass local verification. This PR demonstrates the gap with Cursor's ID/versionRange mismatch. Fix: generalize ID-alignment validation for generated upstream-current AgentVersion records, with explicit allowlisted historical exceptions where intentional. Add evidence coverage validation for upstream-current shards. QAI dispatched fresh QA via Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31230804232 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: this matrix targets BP predefined/create graph/catalog consumer paths, a bridged-hooks plugin lane, and representative vanilla adapter baselines without running the full cross-product. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
|
GitHub did not accept a formal request-changes review from this actor, so I am posting the decision as a comment. Adversarial Review Decision: Changes RequestedI cannot approve this PR as a complete Atlas AgentVersion tracker update. The review found a blocking provenance gap, multiple generated-artifact consistency issues, a failed approach check, and no passing QA verdict. Blocker
The PR adds 16 AgentVersion records with release claims such as Fix: add Major Findings
The Cursor record ID is Fix: rename the Cursor node to
Fix: include all committed tracker outputs in
The note says release-note bodies are under Fix: commit the referenced release-note and issue body artifacts, or update the generated note to describe only artifacts actually present in the PR.
The existing test filters only Copilot nodes, so generated upstream-current AgentVersion records for other agents can drift from the ID/versionRange convention and still pass local verification. This PR demonstrates the gap with Cursor's ID/versionRange mismatch. Fix: generalize ID-alignment validation for generated upstream-current AgentVersion records, with explicit allowlisted historical exceptions where intentional. Add evidence coverage validation for upstream-current shards. QAI dispatched fresh QA via Missing Guardrails
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31230832259 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}]Coverage rationale: PR #1620 changes Atlas AgentVersion graph metadata and generated tracker artifacts used by catalog/evidence workflows. The matrix targets BP predefined/create paths for catalog-consuming process flows across Codex and Claude, includes a bridged-hooks BP lane for plugin/hook integration, and adds a vanilla Hermes non-interactive baseline. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
|
GitHub did not accept a formal request-changes review from this actor, so I am posting the decision as a comment. Adversarial Review Decision: Changes RequestedI cannot approve this PR as a complete Atlas AgentVersion tracker update. The review found one blocker, four major issues, a failed approach check, and QA did not produce a terminal passing verdict. Blocker
The PR adds 16 Prior upstream-current drops, including Fix: add Major Findings
The Cursor node ID is Fix: rename the node to
Fix: include all committed tracker outputs in
The note says release-note bodies are stored under Fix: commit the referenced release-note and issue body artifacts, or update the generated note so it only describes artifacts present in the PR.
The current ID-alignment test filters only Copilot nodes. This PR adds generated upstream Fix: add validation for generated upstream-current QAI dispatched Missing Guardrails
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31286708292 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: PR #1620 changes Atlas AgentVersion graph metadata and generated tracker artifacts consumed by catalog/evidence workflows. This matrix targets BP predefined/create catalog-consuming flows across Codex and Claude, includes a bridged-hooks BP lane for plugin/hook integration, and adds vanilla Hermes and Gemini baselines without running the full cross-product. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked workflow for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31286708602 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: this matrix targets BP predefined/create catalog-consuming process flows, a Codex bridged-hooks BP lane for plugin/hook integration, and one vanilla Hermes non-interactive adapter baseline. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31286714260 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: PR #1620 changes Atlas AgentVersion graph metadata and generated tracker artifacts, so the matrix targets BP predefined/create catalog-consuming process paths across Codex and Claude, adds a Codex bridged-hooks BP lane for plugin/hook integration, and includes a Hermes vanilla non-interactive adapter/provider baseline. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31286715705 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}]Coverage rationale: this matrix targets BP predefined/create graph/catalog consumer paths for Codex and Claude, a BP bridged-hooks lane, and representative vanilla adapter baselines for Hermes and Gemini. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31286733702 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: this matrix targets BP predefined/create graph/catalog consumer paths, a bridged-hooks BP lane for plugin/hook integration, and representative vanilla adapter baselines without running the full cross-product. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31286725203 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: this matrix targets BP predefined/create graph/catalog consumer paths across Codex and Claude, includes a bridged-hooks BP lane for plugin/hook integration, and adds a vanilla Hermes non-interactive baseline. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31286734794 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: this matrix targets BP predefined/create catalog-consuming paths across Codex and Claude, a BP bridged-hooks plugin lane, and representative vanilla Hermes/Gemini adapter baselines without running the full cross-product. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31286733222 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: this matrix targets BP predefined/create graph/catalog consumer paths across Codex and Claude, includes a Codex bridged-hooks BP lane, and adds representative Hermes/Gemini vanilla adapter baselines. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
|
GitHub did not accept a formal request-changes review from this actor ( Adversarial Review Decision: Changes RequestedI cannot approve this PR as a complete Atlas AgentVersion tracker update. The review found one blocker, four major issues, a failed approach check, and no passing QA verdict. Blocker
The PR adds a 2026-08-04 batch of Fix: add Major Findings
QAI dispatched Missing Guardrails
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
|
Adversarial review decision: changes requested. I cannot approve this PR as a complete Atlas AgentVersion tracker update. The review found one blocker, four major issues, a failed approach check, and no passing QA verdict. Blocker
The PR adds 16 Fix: add Major Findings
The Cursor node ID is Fix: rename the node to
Fix: include all committed tracker outputs in
The note says release-note bodies are stored under Fix: commit the referenced release-note and issue body artifacts, or update the generated note so it only describes artifacts present in the PR.
The current ID-alignment test filters only Copilot nodes. This PR adds generated upstream Fix: add validation for generated upstream-current QAI dispatched Missing Guardrails
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Adversarial Review Decision: Changes RequestedI cannot approve this PR. It adds Atlas AgentVersion facts without the matching provenance shard, leaves a generated ID drift that can break SDK subject lookups, has generated artifact metadata inconsistencies, and QA did not produce a passing terminal verdict. Blocker
The PR adds 16 Fix: add Major Findings
The Cursor node ID is Fix: rename the node to
Fix: include all committed tracker output paths in
The note says release-note bodies are under Fix: commit the referenced release-note and issue body artifacts, or update the generated note to describe only artifacts present in the PR.
The current ID-alignment test filters only Copilot nodes, so generated upstream-current AgentVersion records for other agents can drift from the ID/versionRange convention and still pass local verification. This PR's Cursor record demonstrates the gap. Fix: generalize generated upstream AgentVersion ID-alignment validation, add explicit allowlisted historical exceptions where intentional, and add evidence coverage validation for upstream-current shards. QAI dispatched Missing Guardrails
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31345217920 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: this matrix targets BP predefined/create graph/catalog consumer paths across Codex and Claude, includes a Codex bridged-hooks BP lane, and adds a Hermes vanilla adapter baseline. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31345251972 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: this matrix targets BP predefined/create graph/catalog consumer paths across Codex and Claude, includes a Codex bridged-hooks BP lane, and adds Hermes/Gemini vanilla adapter baselines. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31345210522 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: this matrix targets BP predefined/create graph/catalog consumer paths across Codex and Claude, includes a Codex bridged-hooks BP lane, and adds representative Hermes/Gemini vanilla adapter baselines. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31345263549 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: this matrix targets BP predefined/create graph/catalog consumer paths across Codex and Claude, includes a Codex bridged-hooks BP lane, and adds a Hermes vanilla adapter baseline. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31345254060 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: this matrix targets BP predefined/create graph/catalog consumer paths across Codex and Claude, includes a Codex bridged-hooks BP lane, and adds representative Hermes/Gemini vanilla adapter baselines. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31345256835 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: this matrix targets BP predefined/create graph/catalog consumer paths across Codex and Claude, includes a Codex bridged-hooks BP lane, and adds representative Hermes/Gemini vanilla adapter baselines. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked workflow run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31345256492 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: this matrix targets BP predefined/create graph/catalog consumer paths across Codex and Claude, includes a Codex bridged-hooks BP lane, and adds representative Hermes/Gemini vanilla adapter baselines for the Atlas AgentVersion metadata and generated tracker artifact changes. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
Live-stack QAResult: incomplete / not passed within the 20-minute QA wait window. Run: https://github.com/a5c-ai/babysitter/actions/runs/31345268029 The workflow was dispatched against
Matrix tested: [
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"claude","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"interactive","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"create"},
{"agent":"codex","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-hooks","install":"bp","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"hermes","model":"foundry-gpt55","mode":"ni","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"},
{"agent":"gemini","model":"google-gemini31","mode":"bridged-interactive","install":"vanilla","live":true,"process_mode":"predefined"}
]Coverage rationale: this matrix targets BP predefined/create graph/catalog consumer paths across Codex and Claude, includes a Codex bridged-hooks BP lane, and adds representative Hermes/Gemini vanilla adapter baselines. Overall verdict: not passed yet. Follow the linked run for final job conclusions before treating QA as green. |
Adversarial Review Decision: Changes RequestedI cannot approve this PR. It adds Atlas Blocker
The PR adds 16 Fix: add Major Findings
The node ID is Fix: rename the node to
Fix: include all committed tracker output paths in
The note says release-note bodies are stored under Fix: commit the referenced release-note and issue body artifacts, or update the generated note so it only describes artifacts present in the PR.
The current test filters only Fix: generalize generated/upstream QAI dispatched Missing Guardrails
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
|
GitHub rejected the formal request-changes review from this actor: Review Can not request changes on your own pull request. Posting the adversarial review decision as a comment. Adversarial Review Decision: Changes RequestedI cannot approve this PR. It adds Atlas AgentVersion facts without the matching provenance shard, leaves generated metadata inconsistencies, has an ID-alignment risk, and QA did not produce a passing terminal verdict. Blocker
The PR adds the 2026-08-04 AgentVersion batch, but PR head does not add packages/atlas/graph/catalog-meta/evidence-sources/upstream-current-2026-08-04.yaml. Prior upstream-current batches, including upstream-current-2026-07-17.yaml, include EvidenceSource nodes that reference each added AgentVersion and product. Without this shard, Atlas catalog/evidence consumers can ingest release/version facts without first-class provenance. Fix: add packages/atlas/graph/catalog-meta/evidence-sources/upstream-current-2026-08-04.yaml following the 2026-07-17 pattern, reference every new AgentVersion and corresponding product/agent, then rerun npm run verify:metadata and npm run build --workspace=@a5c-ai/atlas. Major Findings
QAI dispatched qa-dispatch.yml as run 31345106255. Poll 1 was queued; polls 2 through 24 remained in progress in Run a5c-ai/babysitter/packages/adapters/triggers@staging; poll 25 hit the GitHub installation API rate limit. No terminal passing QA verdict was obtained, so QA is inconclusive/not passed. Current PR checks also show Docs QA failed. Risk AssessmentRisk level: risk:high.
|
Adversarial Review Decision: Changes RequestedI cannot approve this PR. It adds Atlas AgentVersion facts without the matching provenance shard, leaves generated metadata inconsistencies, lacks guardrails for the new generated records, and QA did not produce a terminal passing verdict. Blocker
The PR adds a 2026-08-04 batch of Fix: add Major Findings
The new Cursor node is Fix: rename the node to
Fix: include all committed tracker output paths in
The note says release-note bodies are stored under Fix: commit the referenced release-note and issue body artifacts, or update the generated note to describe only artifacts present in the PR.
The current ID-alignment test filters only Copilot nodes, so generated upstream AgentVersion records for Cursor and similar agents can drift from the SDK ID convention and still pass verification. This PR demonstrates that gap. Fix: generalize generated upstream AgentVersion ID-alignment validation and add evidence coverage validation for upstream-current shards, with explicit allowlisted exceptions where intentional. QAI dispatched Missing Guardrails
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
|
GitHub refused a formal request-changes review from this actor ( Adversarial review decision: changes requested. I cannot approve this PR as a complete Atlas AgentVersion tracker update. It adds new Atlas release/version facts without matching same-date provenance, leaves a generated ID drift that can split SDK/catalog lookups, has generated artifact metadata inconsistencies, and QA did not produce a passing terminal verdict. Blocker
The PR adds the 2026-08-04 Fix: add Major Findings
The Cursor node ID is Fix: rename the node to
Fix: include all committed tracker output paths in
The note says release-note bodies are stored under Fix: commit the referenced release-note and issue body artifacts, or update the generated note so it only describes artifacts present in the PR.
The current ID-alignment test filters only Copilot nodes. This PR adds generated upstream Fix: generalize upstream-current QAI dispatched Missing Guardrails
Risk AssessmentRisk level:
|
Updates Atlas AgentVersion records from the daily upstream host agent release check.
Artifacts:
Verification: