Tracking Issue: CSL Spec Compliance

[Drodt]

This issue tracks all the citeproc tests Hayagriva does support in principle (they have no unsupported features like date ranges) but which do not yet pass.

Bugreports

• bugreports_AllCapsLeakage
• bugreports_ApostropheOnParticle
• bugreports_BadDelimiterBeforeCollapse
  • Passes in Fix year suffix collapse #367
• bugreports_ByBy
• bugreports_ChicagoAuthorDateLooping
• bugreports_CollapseFailure
• bugreports_ContainerTitleShort
• bugreports_DelimitersOnLocator
• bugreports_DisambiguationAddNames
• bugreports_DuplicateSpaces
• bugreports_DuplicateSpaces2
• bugreports_DuplicateSpaces3
• bugreports_DuplicateTerminalPunctuationInBibliography
  • Passes in Smart Quotation Marks in Formattable Strings. #99
• bugreports_FrenchApostrophe
• bugreports_IeeePunctuation
• bugreports_LabelsOutOfPlace
• bugreports_LegislationCrash
• bugreports_MovePunctuationInsideQuotesForLocator
• bugreports_NoTitle
• bugreports_SingleQuote
• bugreports_SortSecondaryKey
• bugreports_SortedIeeeItalicsFail
• bugreports_ThesisUniversityAppearsTwice
• bugreports_UndefinedBeforeVal
• bugreports_UndefinedInName
• bugreports_YearSuffixInHarvard1
• bugreports_disambigHang
• bugreports_parenthesis
• bugreports_parseName

Collapse

• collapse_AuthorCollapseNoDateSorted
• collapse_ChicagoAfterCollapse
• collapse_YearSuffixCollapse
• collapse_YearSuffixCollapseNoRange
  • Passes in Fix year suffix collapse #367
• collapse_YearSuffixCollapseNoYearSuffixDelimiter
• collapse_YearSuffixImplicitCollapseNoYearSuffixDelimiter

Date

• date_DateBC
  • Diverging behavior, replaced by local test case. See Tracking Issue: CSL Spec Compliance #327 (comment)
• date_DateNoDateNoTest
  • citeproc emits error; Hayagriva an empty output
• date_DayOrdinalDayOneOnly
  • Fixed in Fix date ordinals #366
• date_InPress
  • We don't support literals in date
• date_LopsidedDataYearSuffixCollapse
  • Passes in Fix year suffix collapse #367
• date_NegativeDateSort
  • Diverging behavior, replaced by local test case in Fix negative date sorting #368. See Tracking Issue: CSL Spec Compliance #327 (comment)
• date_NegativeDateSortViaMacro
  • Diverging behavior, replaced by local test case in Fix negative date sorting #368. See Tracking Issue: CSL Spec Compliance #327 (comment)
• date_NegativeDateSortViaMacroOnYearMonthOnly
  • Diverging behavior, replaced by local test case in Fix negative date sorting #368. See Tracking Issue: CSL Spec Compliance #327 (comment)
• date_NonexistentSortReverseBibliography
  • Passes in Fix sorting for empty sort values #390
• date_NonexistentSortReverseCitation
  • Passes in Fix sorting for empty sort values #390
• date_OtherWithDate
  • Passes in Print season when available and month is empty #391
• date_SeasonSubstituteInGroup
  • Passes in Print season when available and month is empty #391
• date_SortEmptyDatesBibliography
  • Passes in Fix sorting for empty sort values #390
• date_SortEmptyDatesCitation
  • Passes in Fix sorting for empty sort values #390
• date_String
  • We don't support raw in dates.
• date_Uncertain
  • Passes in Allow for uncertain JSON dates #396
• date_VariousInvalidDates
  • Very strange: We accept some dates we shouldn't (e.g., w/ negative month); but citeproc treats a month > 12 as a season: The season is the month - 12. I don't know why
• date_YearSuffixDelimiter
  • Passes in Fix year suffix collapse #367
• date_YearSuffixImplicitWithNoDate
  • I do not understand why this should be disambiguated. The references are not identical.
• date_YearSuffixWithNoDate
  • Same as date_YearSuffixImplicitWithNoDate

Decorations

• decorations_Baseline
  • Essentially same output but with additional <sup> tags. Overwrite the test or get rid of additional tags?
• decorations_NestedQuotes
  • Hayagriva does not recognize ‘ as quotation mark characters. Could be handled once Smart Quotation Marks in Formattable Strings. #99 is merged.

Disambiguate

• disambiguate_AddNamesFailure
  • Passes in Rework Citation Disambiguation #413
• disambiguate_AddNamesFailureWithAddGivenname
  • Passes in Rework Citation Disambiguation #413
• disambiguate_AllNamesBaseNameCountOnFailureIfYearSuffixAvailable
• disambiguate_AllNamesGenerally
• disambiguate_AllNamesSimpleSequence
• disambiguate_AllNamesWithInitialsBibliography
  • Passes in Fix name sorting when using form=count #313
• disambiguate_AllNamesWithInitialsGenerally
• disambiguate_AndreaEg1a
  • Passes in Rework Citation Disambiguation #413
• disambiguate_AndreaEg1b
• disambiguate_AndreaEg1c
  • Passes in Rework Citation Disambiguation #413
• disambiguate_AndreaEg2
• disambiguate_AndreaEg3
• disambiguate_AndreaEg4
• disambiguate_AndreaEg5
• disambiguate_ByCiteBaseNameCountOnFailureIfYearSuffixAvailable
  • Passes in Rework Citation Disambiguation #413
• disambiguate_ByCiteGivennameExpandCrossNestedNames
• disambiguate_ByCiteIncremental1
  • Passes in Rework Citation Disambiguation #413
• disambiguate_ByCiteIncremental2
• disambiguate_ByCiteMinimalGivennameExpandMinimalNames
  • Passes in Rework Citation Disambiguation #413
• disambiguate_ByCiteRetainNamesOnFailureIfYearSuffixNotAvailable
  • Passes in Rework Citation Disambiguation #413
• disambiguate_CitationLabelDefault
• disambiguate_CitationLabelInData
• disambiguate_DisambiguateTrueReflectedInBibliography
• disambiguate_ExtraTextCitation
• disambiguate_IncrementalExtraText
• disambiguate_InitializeWithButNoDisambiguation
• disambiguate_PrimaryNameGenerally
• disambiguate_PrimaryNameWithInitialsLimitedToPrimary
• disambiguate_PrimaryNameWithParticle
• disambiguate_SkipAccessedYearSuffix
• disambiguate_ToInitialOnly
• disambiguate_Trigraph
• disambiguate_YearSuffixAndSort
• disambiguate_YearSuffixAtTwoLevels
• disambiguate_YearSuffixMixedDates
  • Passes in Fix year suffix collapse #367
• disambiguate_YearSuffixTwoPairsBibliography
  • Passes in Fix name sorting when using form=count #313
• disambiguate_YearSuffixTwoPairsFirstNameBibliography
  • Passes in Fix name sorting when using form=count #313
• disambiguate_YearSuffixTwoPairsFullNamesBibliography
  • Passes in Fix name sorting when using form=count #313
• disambiguate_YearSuffixWithMixedCreatorTypes
  • Passes in Rework Citation Disambiguation #413

Display

• display_AuthorAsHeading
• display_LostSuffix
• display_SecondFieldAlignClone

Etal

• etal_UseZeroFirst
  • Passes in Do not render empty et al. #415

Flip Flop

• flipflop_Apostrophes
• flipflop_LeadingSingleQuote
• flipflop_QuotesInFieldNotOnNode
• flipflop_QuotesNodeLevelMarkup
  • Passes in Smart Quotation Marks in Formattable Strings. #99
• flipflop_SingleBeforeColon
• flipflop_StartingApostrophe
• fullstyles_ChicagoArticleTitleQuestion
• fullstyles_ChicagoAuthorDateSimple

Group

• group_ComplexNesting
  • Passes in Don't count year-suffix as a variable access #400
• group_SuppressTermInMacro
  • Passes in Fix rendering of macros #419
• group_SuppressTermWhenNoOutputFromPartialDate

Label

• label_CollapsedPageNumberPluralDetection
• label_PluralWithAnd
• label_PluralWithCommaAnd
• label_PluralWithCommaLocalizedAnd
• label_PluralWithLocalizedAmpersand
• label_PluralWithLocalizedAnd

Locator

• locator_SingularEmbeddedLabelAfterPlural
• locator_TrickyEntryForPlurals

Magic

• magic_CapitalizeFirstOccurringNameParticle
• magic_CapitalizeFirstOccurringTerm
• magic_CitationLabelInBibliography
• magic_CitationLabelInCitation
• magic_ImplicitYearSuffixExplicitDelimiter
• magic_NameSuffixNoComma
• magic_NameSuffixWithComma
• magic_PunctuationInQuoteNested
• magic_PunctuationInQuoteTrueSuppressExtra
• magic_StripPeriodsTrueShortForm
• magic_SubsequentAuthorSubstitute
• magic_SubsequentAuthorSubstituteNotFooled
• magic_SubsequentAuthorSubstituteNotFooled
  • Passes in Add support for subsequent author substitution #228
• magic_SuperscriptChars
• magic_SuppressLayoutDelimiterIfPrefixComma
• magic_TermCapitalizationWithPrefix

Name

• name_ApostropheInGivenName
  • Passes in Smart Quotation Marks in Formattable Strings. #99
• name_ArticularWithComma
  • Passes in Handle comma-suffix in names #420
• name_AuthorCount
  • Passes in Fix author count with et al. #421
• name_AuthorCountWithMultipleVariables
  • Passes in Fix author count with et al. #421
• name_AuthorEditorCount
  • Passes in Fix author count with et al. #421
• name_CeltsAndToffsCrowdedInitials
  • Passes in Do not initialize lower case words #422
• name_CeltsAndToffsSpacedInitials
  • Passes in Do not initialize lower case words #422
• name_CiteGroupDelimiterWithYearSuffixCollapse
  • Passes in Use cite-group-delimiter as fallback for year-suffix-delimiter #423
• name_CiteGroupDelimiterWithYearSuffixCollapse2
• name_CiteGroupDelimiterWithYearSuffixCollapse3
  • Passes in Use cite-group-delimiter as fallback for year-suffix-delimiter #423
• name_DelimiterAfterInverted
• name_EtAlWithCombined
• name_HebrewAnd
• name_HyphenatedNonDroppingParticle1
• name_HyphenatedNonDroppingParticle2
• name_InTextMarkupInitialize
• name_InTextMarkupNormalizeInitials
• name_InitialsInitializeFalse
• name_InitialsInitializeFalseEmpty
• name_InitialsInitializeFalsePeriod
• name_InitialsInitializeFalsePeriodSpace
• name_InitialsInitializeTrue
• name_InitialsInitializeTrueEmpty
• name_InitialsInitializeTruePeriod
• name_InitialsInitializeTruePeriodSpace
• name_LongAbbreviation
• name_LowercaseSurnameSuffix
• name_OnlyGivenname
• name_ParseNames
• name_ParsedCommaDelimitedDroppingParticleSortOrderingWithoutAffixes
  • Passes in Smart Quotation Marks in Formattable Strings. #99
• name_ParsedDroppingParticleWithApostrophe
• name_ParticleCaps1
• name_ParticleCaps2
• name_ParticleCaps3
• name_ParticleParse1
• name_SplitInitials
• name_SubsequentAuthorSubstituteMultipleNames
  • Passes in Add support for subsequent author substitution #228
• name_SubsequentAuthorSubstituteSingleField
  • Passes in Add support for subsequent author substitution #228
• name_SubstituteOnNamesSpanGroupSpanFail
• name_SubstitutePartialEach
  • Passes in Add support for subsequent author substitution #228
• name_TwoRolesSameRenderingSeparateRoleLabels
• name_namepartAffixes

Nameattr

• nameattr_NamesDelimiterOnBibliographyInBibliography
• nameattr_NamesDelimiterOnCitationInCitation
• nameattr_NamesDelimiterOnStyleInBibliography
• nameattr_NamesDelimiterOnStyleInCitation

Number

• number_LeadingZeros
  • Passes in Fix parsing of atypical page numbers and serial numbers #445
• number_MixedText
  • Passes in Fix parsing of atypical page numbers and serial numbers #445
• number_PlainHyphenOrEnDashAlwaysPlural

Page

• page_ChicagoWeird
• page_Expand
• page_ExpandWeirdComposite
• page_Minimal
• page_NoOption

Plural

• plural_NameLabelAlways
• plural_NameLabelContextualPlural
• plural_NameLabelContextualSingular
• plural_NameLabelDefaultPlural
• plural_NameLabelDefaultSingular
• plural_NameLabelNever

Position

• position_FalseInBibliography
  • Passes in Position always tests false when in bibliography #425

Punctuation

• punctuation_DefaultYearSuffixDelimiter
  • Passes in Fix year suffix collapse #367
• punctuation_FrenchOrthography
• punctuation_FullMontyField
• punctuation_FullMontyPlain
• punctuation_FullMontyQuotesIn
• punctuation_FullMontyQuotesOut
• punctuation_OnMacro

Quotes

• quotes_PunctuationWithInnerQuote
• quotes_QuotesUnderQuotesFalse

Simplespace

• simplespace_case1

Sort

• sort_AguStyle
  • Passes in Fix name sorting when using form=count #313
• sort_AguStyleReverseGroups
  • Passes in Suppress et al in sort #426
• sort_ChangeInNameSort
• sort_ChicagoYearSuffix1
  • Passes in Add support for subsequent author substitution #228
• sort_ChicagoYearSuffix2
• sort_ConditionalMacroDates
  • Passes in Add Collation-Based String Sorting #314
• sort_DropNameLabelInSort
• sort_LeadingA
• sort_LeadingApostropheOnNameParticle
• sort_NameImplicitSortOrderAndForm
  • Passes in Fix name sorting when using form=count #313
• sort_NameVariable
• sort_NumberOfAuthorsAsKey
  • Passes in Fix name sorting when using form=count #313
• sort_OmittedBibRefMixedNumericStyle
• sort_OmittedBibRefNonNumericStyle
• sort_Quotes
• sort_SeparateAuthorsAndOthers
• sort_StatusFieldAscending
  • Passes in Fix sorting for empty sort values #390
• sort_SubstituteTitle
  • Passes in Smart Quotation Marks in Formattable Strings. #99
• sort_VariousNameMacros1
  • Passes in Add citeproc tests that failed because of <b> </b> #479
• sort_VariousNameMacros2
  • Passes in Add citeproc tests that failed because of <b> </b> #479
• sort_VariousNameMacros3
  • Passes in Add citeproc tests that failed because of <b> </b> #479

Substitute

• substitute_SharedMacro
• substitute_SubstituteOnlyOnceTermEmpty

Textcase

• textcase_InQuotes
• textcase_LastChar
• textcase_NoSpaceBeforeApostrophe
  • Passes in Smart Quotation Marks in Formattable Strings. #99
• textcase_NonEnglishChars
• textcase_RepeatedTitleBug
• textcase_SkipNameParticlesInTitleCase
• textcase_TitleCaseWithCleverBrandName
• textcase_TitleWithEmDash

Variables

• variables_ContainerTitleShort

[PgBiel]

Wow, that is quite comprehensive. This will certainly be a very useful reference for future work. Thank you! 🙂

[PgBiel]

As noted at #333 (comment), we will probably intentionally keep date_DateBC failing (also see #235).